@QueerAsFcuk
I had a gift sub sent out on the 26th and it is being delivered today, but it is normal for the subscription boxes to take a week or more since they use slower/cheaper shipping services for those. I'm surprised this one is getting to me so quickly considering the holiday and crazy online shopping weekend. For actual product orders from the shop, they usually use USPS Priority, so those come quicker.
As for the tracking numbers, on mine the second tracking number is the first tracking number with an additional prefix of numbers.
Has your 5-item part of the gift sub shipped yet? I am not sure how they do those, but I would have thought you would at least get a shipping notification. If I were you, I would probably wait until tomorrow or Friday to see if the Newgistics tracking updates, and if not call and ask about that and the 5-item order!