Ok have to update my list, mainly because I can't even remember which ones I have right now!
Currently have:
Ipsy
Birchbox
Beauty Army
Goodies
Love Club
Yuzen
Bulu Box (for my hubby!)
Cravebox (occasionally, I don't get every box)
Had, but cancelled (and the reason why):
Citrus Lane (cost - I got a deal on 4 months, but am not paying $25/month)
Love With Food (Got a free box to try, not impressed with portion size)
Graze (loved it, they need to work out some shipping issues and I'll be back!)
Juniper ("time of the month" box, too expensive at $28/mo)
Glossybox (I'm getting the Feb box, but I've already cancelled. Too expensive, not impressed by the contents)
The Fancy (I'm trying one box with a coupon code, but at $39/month, no thanks!)
Want to try/will be trying soon:
Starlooks (I won one of the boxes! Yeeks!!)
Julep
Beauty Box 5
Sample Society
Ok I think that's it... may have to update later if I remember any more!