- Joined
- Sep 21, 2012
- Messages
- 1,246
- Reaction score
- 956
Quote: Originally Posted by saku /img/forum/go_quote.gif
OMG guys. i'm wearing my YSL glossy stain today again. and it's really really good! i put it on today at 6 AM, and it's still looking fab right now. i had to teach a class today and did lots of talking for 2 hours! i'm getting more!!! maybe a shade a month /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
@normajean2008 if you don't mind, which shades do you have?
No problem. Here are the colors I have. I also swatched pics for them.
First Row: (the top or left side between the two pictures...left to right/bottom to top)
3 Brun Cachemire
5 Rouge Vintage
6 Camel Croisiere
7 Corail Aquatique
Second Row: (the bottom or right side between the two pictures...left to right/bottom to top)
18 Rose Pastelle
26 Violine Surrealiste
27 Pêche Cerra-Cola
29 Rose Forreau
Number 18 wont look good on anybody who can't wear super pastel milky pink color lippies, it is very light on the lips. But if you can wear that type of color, this is a great one!
Number 7 and Number 29 are pretty close in color, with 29 being slightly more pinky peach base vs. orangey peach based. They are different enough on my lips that I wanted both.
I love Number 3 for when I want something kind of more dramatic, without being super dark and vampy, or in the red family.
Number 26 is pretty close to one I don't have, Number 16, but is slightly more subdued in brightness of the purple. Number 16 is very popular and pretty, but it is more *BAM, your wearing PURPLE* vs. *Wow, what a pretty purple*...if that makes sense.
I have also tried the Number 8, which is a bright orange/red. It had a dye I was allergic to and I had to return it, but I'm SUPER sensitive to orange and red dyes in lip products.
I've been wanting to pick up a true red, but I haven't been able to decide between two of these colors...and now I'm waiting on an order with the Shiseido glossy stain sample, so I'll try those out first to compare.
------------
I'm too lazy to quote again.... But Jeaniney... I hope you are one of the lucky ones with the cheaper version! My *personal* opinion (and I know others may not agree) is that the Loreal version is like a Toyota, the YSL like a Lexus. Same company, different levels of luxury and wear... To me, the Loreal version feels very thin and streaky/watery, but after 3-5 layers to get the true color it felt like I had cement/glue on my lips, or spackle... and the YSL feelt thicker, gel based and smooth. But some find the smell of the YSL too sickly sweet, or too sticky... I think the Loreal is just as strong smelling, but I like the YSL scent better (to my nose it is like a summer fruity cocktail drink type of smell), vs strong floral of Loreal. I'm of course not the ultimate authority on Glossy Stains, but these are my opinions on them, or rather my picky-ass-lip's opinion, lol.
Also, anybody trying those free sample cards to try these stains out--- they are a good representation of them, but the applicator is really key on how they look on your lips. The sample applicator is NOT as good as the real applicator and it sucks up a lot of the product and it doesn't go on quite as smoothly. I find using the tip of your small finger a better applicator for the free sample cards. Don't be stingy in application, but don't glob it on at once. Start with a normal gloss like layer first, wait a minute, apply again if needed. More you add, deeper the color and longer the staying power. I've never needed more than 2 coats for any of my 8 colors so far.
OMG guys. i'm wearing my YSL glossy stain today again. and it's really really good! i put it on today at 6 AM, and it's still looking fab right now. i had to teach a class today and did lots of talking for 2 hours! i'm getting more!!! maybe a shade a month /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
@normajean2008 if you don't mind, which shades do you have?
No problem. Here are the colors I have. I also swatched pics for them.
First Row: (the top or left side between the two pictures...left to right/bottom to top)
3 Brun Cachemire
5 Rouge Vintage
6 Camel Croisiere
7 Corail Aquatique
Second Row: (the bottom or right side between the two pictures...left to right/bottom to top)
18 Rose Pastelle
26 Violine Surrealiste
27 Pêche Cerra-Cola
29 Rose Forreau
Number 18 wont look good on anybody who can't wear super pastel milky pink color lippies, it is very light on the lips. But if you can wear that type of color, this is a great one!
Number 7 and Number 29 are pretty close in color, with 29 being slightly more pinky peach base vs. orangey peach based. They are different enough on my lips that I wanted both.
I love Number 3 for when I want something kind of more dramatic, without being super dark and vampy, or in the red family.
Number 26 is pretty close to one I don't have, Number 16, but is slightly more subdued in brightness of the purple. Number 16 is very popular and pretty, but it is more *BAM, your wearing PURPLE* vs. *Wow, what a pretty purple*...if that makes sense.
I have also tried the Number 8, which is a bright orange/red. It had a dye I was allergic to and I had to return it, but I'm SUPER sensitive to orange and red dyes in lip products.
I've been wanting to pick up a true red, but I haven't been able to decide between two of these colors...and now I'm waiting on an order with the Shiseido glossy stain sample, so I'll try those out first to compare.
------------
I'm too lazy to quote again.... But Jeaniney... I hope you are one of the lucky ones with the cheaper version! My *personal* opinion (and I know others may not agree) is that the Loreal version is like a Toyota, the YSL like a Lexus. Same company, different levels of luxury and wear... To me, the Loreal version feels very thin and streaky/watery, but after 3-5 layers to get the true color it felt like I had cement/glue on my lips, or spackle... and the YSL feelt thicker, gel based and smooth. But some find the smell of the YSL too sickly sweet, or too sticky... I think the Loreal is just as strong smelling, but I like the YSL scent better (to my nose it is like a summer fruity cocktail drink type of smell), vs strong floral of Loreal. I'm of course not the ultimate authority on Glossy Stains, but these are my opinions on them, or rather my picky-ass-lip's opinion, lol.
Also, anybody trying those free sample cards to try these stains out--- they are a good representation of them, but the applicator is really key on how they look on your lips. The sample applicator is NOT as good as the real applicator and it sucks up a lot of the product and it doesn't go on quite as smoothly. I find using the tip of your small finger a better applicator for the free sample cards. Don't be stingy in application, but don't glob it on at once. Start with a normal gloss like layer first, wait a minute, apply again if needed. More you add, deeper the color and longer the staying power. I've never needed more than 2 coats for any of my 8 colors so far.