Just got my box and I'm really glad I avoided checking the threads before then. I would've been having premature buyer's remorse. Instead I actually love it. Yes, even that beanie which made me go WTH when I first saw it.
I received the mink purse (brownish), a pale blue Pantone mug (549), the polish in Deep (dark aubergine), and I'm just adding a pic of the earrings since I can't find the style. They are silver with a white pearl. Sorry that my photography is awful so they look pinkish in parts. They are perfectly silver though. Very cool style and elegant. I expected some fringe after lurking her style pages in Marie Claire and am actually really happy with the way it's presented in the purse. It seems like a nice quality piece and the only drawback is that it won't have the longevity of real leather. Then again, will I be carrying a fringe purse in 5 years? Not sure ...
Overall I think it's really nicely curated. The oil for seasonal dry skin, a mug for drinking hot beverages, the dark polish is perfect for A/W, the beanie for cold weather, etc. The earrings are the "something shiny" according to her note (for those who haven't/won't receive the box).
The beanie I thought was going to be awful (like the hat in the summer box) but then I put it on and it was super cozy so I wore it in my house for a little and then kept it on when I went to run errands. It actually looks pretty cute and I also think it's amusing. it's got that crass class going for it.
I'm hoping that she doesn't quit because I feel I'm getting a lot out of her boxes and also Quarterly curators have been dropping like flies lately which bums me out.