Birchbox October 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Originally Posted by peridotcricket /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Um, yeah, so I decided to try the Caudalie Vino Perfect stuff tonight. The little white tube with grapes on it. I squeezed out a little dab, rubbed it in, then went to squeeze out more, and it's empty. I have redness on my cheeks. A sample that covers 1/2 of 1 cheek is not a deluxe sample.

Is it even worth it to call Birchbox? I do not want them to send another one.
This is the main reason I contacted them in the first place and was told I'd get a replacement box. If you've seen any of my posts, you know it's been a fiasco. I don't even know if they have any more of that stuff, so they might just give you points. I'd try it. 

 
Originally Posted by OiiO /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Thanks for the heads up, I was exactly 10 pts short before I could cash in my pts for a gift sub :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
Thanks for letting us know! Is yours showing in your total points? Mine is saying +10 point and amount $10 but the $10 is not showing up in my total points for some reason.

 
Originally Posted by drk51284 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

You guys, Illume is the best company ever!

Someone on here posted about their candles on sale, and that you got 10% off and free shipping if you signed up with their website. I did so on a lark (late night drunken shopping... the other day I woke up with my wallet next to my face), and ordered one of their Applewood candles for a grand total of $6.30.

They called me before shipping the package to double-check my address, because it's an odd one and UPS wouldn't accept it as written. When they called, I asked about their "red cedar" fragrance, and if they could send a little piece of wax or something because I wanted to smell it (Because I was, honestly, considering buying it through Birchbox). They said "No, so sorry, we don't have anything like that, so sorry, everything went into production." It made sense, because I think they had something like 2 weeks to produce all the candles for Birchbox. Still, they were super sweet (they are Minnesotan, like me!).

And this is what they sent me:



The candle I ordered (burning) an additional candle in the same size - "roasting chestnuts" and a mini candle, lotion sample (both in "tuscan olive" and some matches in a little pouch. Already - super awesome, and I said thanks on their facebook page.

Today, I received a surprise package:



A monogramed candle in "red cedar" and a handwritten note!!

They are getting all my candle money. I don't normally buy too many candles, so it won't be often... but when it does, it will be through them.

Maybe Birchbox could take a leaf out of their book! :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
That is so cool!  I love candles so I will definitely check them out.

It's just so refreshing when people go out of their way to be nice.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
Originally Posted by drk51284 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

You guys, Illume is the best company ever!

Someone on here posted about their candles on sale, and that you got 10% off and free shipping if you signed up with their website. I did so on a lark (late night drunken shopping... the other day I woke up with my wallet next to my face), and ordered one of their Applewood candles for a grand total of $6.30.

They called me before shipping the package to double-check my address, because it's an odd one and UPS wouldn't accept it as written. When they called, I asked about their "red cedar" fragrance, and if they could send a little piece of wax or something because I wanted to smell it (Because I was, honestly, considering buying it through Birchbox). They said "No, so sorry, we don't have anything like that, so sorry, everything went into production." It made sense, because I think they had something like 2 weeks to produce all the candles for Birchbox. Still, they were super sweet (they are Minnesotan, like me!).

And this is what they sent me:



The candle I ordered (burning) an additional candle in the same size - "roasting chestnuts" and a mini candle, lotion sample (both in "tuscan olive" and some matches in a little pouch. Already - super awesome, and I said thanks on their facebook page.

Today, I received a surprise package:



A monogramed candle in "red cedar" and a handwritten note!!

They are getting all my candle money. I don't normally buy too many candles, so it won't be often... but when it does, it will be through them.

Maybe Birchbox could take a leaf out of their book! :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
Serendipity, you are SO right! I just made an order and called about shipping because i wasn't sure if it would be free and the wonan i spoke with mas SOO nice. I appreciated it so much. I bought a sweet rhubarb candle. 

 
Originally Posted by girlwithclass /img/forum/go_quote.gif


haha I'm kinda jealous. After the shipping issues last month, I cancelled, but decided to re-sub in hopes for a good box this month - I ended up resubscribing on the 3rd. At checkout it showed my box would ship out by the 13th. Well.. the 13th rolls around, and my profile hadn't updated to show an October box at all. My shipping info on my account page was still showing my September 'tracking' (which wasn't even accurate for last month, at that.. never received that box.) So.. I sent in an e-mail, and noticed that the very next day my account info had been changed to show October tracking instead, however now it was just blank (without a tracking number at all). I got an e-mail back finally on the 15th and the CS rep chalked it up to me having subscribed later in the month (so basically it is my fault and it's not a late box, even though it was supposed to ship out by the 13th??). Anyway she went on to say she did see an October box in my account.. whatever that means? My box page still hadn't updated at this point. I think on the 17th I finally received a shipping e-mail with tracking and when I logged in it showed I would be getting box #14. As far as I'm aware.. no one had even received that box yet, so I'm guessing it was indeed a late box for whatever reason.. and I was pretty irritated, so I wrote in to Birchbox again and explained why I am an unhappy subscriber lately (between inconsistencies in CS, late/mixed up shipping, etc etc etc.) it was a very well thought out e-mail and it was a bit on the long side. I waited 3 days and just got an e-mail back saying that they are 'so sorry' and would love to discuss over the phone how they can improve their service. Really? Waste of my time to even e-mail in the first place.. I don't feel like my concerns were ever taken seriously nor was I given a legitimate reason why my box shipped out so late. My tracking estimated an arrival of the 22nd. That has come and gone.. Now being the 24th, USPS has a delivery estimate for the 26th.. 

No awesome customer service for me. Just a very very late box. :/
yeah they tried to tell me that because I wasn't charged the 1st that their "rules" didn't apply to me and that instead of having been shipped out by the tenth they could ship it whenever and I was like listen.... its been over ten days, its been 13 days and my shipping and account page had not changed, I wrote a big long mean comment on their facebook page when they said they wouldn't give me points to compensate me for my box shipping out so late and they messaged me on fb saying they would give me 100 points for a late box, which they did. or else I would be furious. I feel bad for people that paid- didn't get an october box- and are getting a november box and thats it, u should have some sort of compensation for them not giving u a box this month and instead having to wait longer and get one next month. I'm irate already, and I even got 100 points... I think they should have given me TWO free months for my trouble of having to wait longer, its ridiculous. this is why I'm never subbing with them again. they should be overly nice and apologetic if they want to keep their costumers...

 
I started my 2nd subscription with a different email address through the link on the goop website halfway through the month and a few days later received this email:

Thank you for subscribing to Birchbox! We're so happy to have you on board. Unfortunately, we no longer have any October goop boxes in stock due to high demand. We understand you subscribed through the goop sign-up pagehttp://link.birchbox.com/50855ae075903c91df98ac3doos9.57/UG3Aq4qKJiQVsUUzBf599 and we are sorry that we cannot fulfill your request. Your first Birchbox will be the equally wonderful Transformation Birchbox, which is filled with samples to help you update your look.
 

I got a shipping notice on Monday and my tracking information has updated to show that the box is in my state today.

So apparently they found it more important to suck in new subscribers and fulfill their orders than to make sure current subscribers received their boxes. I wonder if anyone actually subscribed unfamiliar to Birchbox and solely because they are fans of the goop website and saw this opportunity posted there, only to receive the email I got saying that they weren't getting a goop box anyways.

By the way, my box has the tili bag, twistband, mox, lulu powder, mary loumanizer, and viva la juicy.

 
Originally Posted by katie danielle /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I started my 2nd subscription with a different email address through the link on the goop website halfway through the month and a few days later received this email:

Thank you for subscribing to Birchbox! We're so happy to have you on board. Unfortunately, we no longer have any October goop boxes in stock due to high demand. We understand you subscribed through the goop sign-up pagehttp://link.birchbox.com/50855ae075903c91df98ac3doos9.57/UG3Aq4qKJiQVsUUzBf599 and we are sorry that we cannot fulfill your request. Your first Birchbox will be the equally wonderful Transformation Birchbox, which is filled with samples to help you update your look.

I got a shipping notice on Monday and my tracking information has updated to show that the box is in my state today.

So apparently they found it more important to suck in new subscribers and fulfill their orders than to make sure current subscribers received their boxes. I wonder if anyone actually subscribed unfamiliar to Birchbox and solely because they are fans of the goop website and saw this opportunity posted there, only to receive the email I got saying that they weren't getting a goop box anyways.

By the way, my box has the tili bag, twistband, mox, lulu powder, mary loumanizer, and viva la juicy.
I was wondering the same thing about BB fulfilling the orders of new subscribers because I too signed up for a 2nd BB using the goop link. They emailed me on the 10th with a link to claim my goop birchbox subscription and shipped me a box on the 17th. It was actually a better box than the one from my main acct (which was a transformation box). I just can't believe they would ship boxes to new subscribers especially when they had people "claim" the new goop subscriptions so late and not ship out boxes to their current customers and now they've "run out" of samples to ship. That is terrible customer service. They shouldn't have taken on new customers if they couldn't fulfill the subscriptions of their current customers.

 
Originally Posted by zadidoll /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Anyone know where the picture of Mollie (in those ugly pants) is located at. It'd be about the November sneak peek.
lol

 
I just got off the phone with Sarah, a BB Ops rep. She was kind of witchy, but I'll just chalk that up to probably being berated by customers all month. She said that my replacement box would be sent out tomorrow. When I asked her to confirm if I'd still be getting box 11, she said that she only knew I was getting a Goop box, but not necessarily with the same contents. WHAT. THE. CRAP. Paulina just told me yesterday that I was getting box 11. SHENANIGANS.

 
Originally Posted by TXSlainte /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I guess the question really is...if someone put fingerprints on the Birchbox products, and no one was around to see someone put their fingerprints onthe products, did someone really put their fingerprints on the products? 
I like you, TXSlainte.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
After posting on their FB page and mentioning: no box, tracking info invalid, and no response to my email, BB finally got back to me.  I got the "normally we'd ship out a replacement box, but our inventory is depleted...sorry.  We'll give you next month's box for NO FEE!"  

And now I'm wondering: does this mean that they're not charging me for October, since I obviously shouldn't pay for something I didn't receive, AND they're giving me next month free?  Or does it mean that I was charged for a nonexistent box in October and they're just making up the improper charge in November by not charging me that month, meaning that I'm not really getting anything extra, just a refund on the paid-for-and-never-received October box?  

I emailed this question to the company, but SHOCKER! they have not responded to my email.  

THANKFULLY, I decided to subscribe to Ipsy this month (after reading some of the MUT reviews), and was really happy to get a bunch of great makeup samples.  If I hadn't gotten that sample fix this month, I might have gone crazy by now.  I just now resubscribed to the Look Bag.  I had it before and always got really great stuff.  There was a gel eyeliner that I got - full size and LOVE.  I'd always wondered about gel liner but didn't want to spend the money to try it if I wasn't sure.  Now I'm addicted.  I guess lookbag raised their prices, but they sent me this promo code for 20% off the first box, making it $9-something.  Here's the promo code - not sure how much longer it's valid for: TLB3

So now the real question is: if I love Ipsy stuff and I love Lookbag stuff, and I'm getting this frustrated with BB, and I never really get excited about the things they send me, should I just go ahead and cancel BB??  Maybe.  I'll definitely be giving Ipsy or LookBag as gifts this year instead of BB.

 
Yes mine showed up with the rest of my points and I was able to make a gift sub purchase right away.

Originally Posted by denise89 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Thanks for letting us know! Is yours showing in your total points? Mine is saying +10 point and amount $10 but the $10 is not showing up in my total points for some reason.
 
Originally Posted by CherBear711 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


THANKFULLY, I decided to subscribe to Ipsy this month (after reading some of the MUT reviews), and was really happy to get a bunch of great makeup samples.  If I hadn't gotten that sample fix this month, I might have gone crazy by now.  I just now resubscribed to the Look Bag.  I had it before and always got really great stuff.  There was a gel eyeliner that I got - full size and LOVE.  I'd always wondered about gel liner but didn't want to spend the money to try it if I wasn't sure.  Now I'm addicted.  I guess lookbag raised their prices, but they sent me this promo code for 20% off the first box, making it $9-something.  Here's the promo code - not sure how much longer it's valid for: TLB3

So now the real question is: if I love Ipsy stuff and I love Lookbag stuff, and I'm getting this frustrated with BB, and I never really get excited about the things they send me, should I just go ahead and cancel BB??  Maybe.  I'll definitely be giving Ipsy or LookBag as gifts this year instead of BB.
Have you read what happened with the items they (The Look Bag) sent out for October?

https://www.makeuptalk.com/t/129454/the-look-bag-october-2012/0_100

 
Originally Posted by BagLady /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I was wondering the same thing about BB fulfilling the orders of new subscribers because I too signed up for a 2nd BB using the goop link. They emailed me on the 10th with a link to claim my goop birchbox subscription and shipped me a box on the 17th. It was actually a better box than the one from my main acct (which was a transformation box). I just can't believe they would ship boxes to new subscribers especially when they had people "claim" the new goop subscriptions so late and not ship out boxes to their current customers and now they've "run out" of samples to ship. That is terrible customer service. They shouldn't have taken on new customers if they couldn't fulfill the subscriptions of their current customers.
I didn't opt in or out & I'm receiving goop- at this point not sure if I'll receive because it seems to be "lost" & there are no replacements.....

Loren, Oct 25 01:59 pm (EDT):

Hi Katie,

Thank you so much for being in touch and I'm so sorry about your missing Birchbox. We are currently looking in to this issue with our warehouse. I do believe this original package will still arrive to you.

We want to ensure that you receive a box for each $10 that you spend. To guarantee this I have waived next month's charge to make up for your missing Birchbox this month!

It is our policy for us to reship your Birchbox if it does not arrive to you, but unfortunately we are out of inventory at this time.

If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to give us a call toll free at 877-487-7272

XO,

Loren 

SO since you should receive a box for every $10 you spend & they waived next month's fee, I should expect to receive 1 out of 2 boxes.  No compensation or replacement for NO BOX??  I think its pretty unacceptable.

 
Originally Posted by zadidoll /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Have you read what happened with the items they (The Look Bag) sent out for October?

https://www.makeuptalk.com/t/129454/the-look-bag-october-2012/0_100
I just read all that to see what happened. The fact that people are still going to happily shell out their money after being deceived is insane. TLB does not state that they will be sending you expired/discontinued items as a disclaimer, so everyone is under the impression that they will be getting products that are not expired and still available to purchase. How can you be okay with being sent expired/discontinued items without first knowing that that's what they'll be? I am completely aghast at the level of apathy from some toward this. It's not my money, thankfully. 

 
Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I just read all that to see what happened. The fact that people are still going to happily shell out their money after being deceived is insane. TLB does not state that they will be sending you expired/discontinued items as a disclaimer, so everyone is under the impression that they will be getting products that are not expired and still available to purchase. How can you be okay with being sent expired/discontinued items without first knowing that that's what they'll be? I am completely aghast at the level of apathy from some toward this. It's not my money, thankfully. 
Expired of course is unacceptable, but "discontinued" shouldn't really be a problem. How many collections does MAC go through a year? Technically those are all "discontinued" and people go crazy for them.........

 
Originally Posted by lovelockdown /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Expired of course is unacceptable, but "discontinued" shouldn't really be a problem. How many collections does MAC go through a year? Technically those are all "discontinued" and people go crazy for them.........
Yes, but you know from the start that you will not be able to get those products once the collection has exited stores. TLB sent products that you wouldn't be able to purchase anywhere without you knowing. There's a difference. 

 
Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Yes, but you know from the start that you will not be able to get those products once the collection has exited stores. TLB sent products that you wouldn't be able to purchase anywhere without you knowing. There's a difference. 
Now you know. Subscribe or don't...ya know?

I prefer large items to tiny samples that I need to purchase to actually try. I personally never use a whole full size item, so there's no need for me to be able to purchase another. Yes, they did not put in a disclaimer, I'm not aware of a law that says they had to.

 
Originally Posted by drk51284 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

You guys, Illume is the best company ever!

**giant snip**
That is way above and beyond good customer service! Now I need to check out their site, thanks for the heads up!

 
Originally Posted by Scooby384 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Now you know. Subscribe or don't...ya know?

I prefer large items to tiny samples that I need to purchase to actually try. I personally never use a whole full size item, so there's no need for me to be able to purchase another. Yes, they did not put in a disclaimer, I'm not aware of a law that says they had to.
A law that says they had to? Really? That's quite extreme. This is a shady thing to do, simple as that.

Hmm. I should check to see how much my local dumpster is charging to have a go at its makeup contents. 

 

Latest posts

Back
Top