Birchbox October 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
so my best friend's box switched today from 11 to 1

she is quite happy about that, but it still hasn't shipped.

which she is not so happy about

did this happen to anybody else yet?

I know they can change before the 10th, but on the 15th

what the heck

 
Well said.
Thanks! Hats off to you, too. Hard to run a business, let alone be successful right now. Times are hard, even with our first world problems. Speaking of which, I feel like we're getting a little lost among the grievances repeatedly tossed around. Now that people are actually getting boxes, any reviews on products? I'm still waiting on one box, but am curious about some of the other stuff. The Eve Lom muslin cloth and Orofluido elixer, specifically..plus the lippie products! Any thoughts towards them being good products or not?
 
Originally Posted by drk51284 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

This is a throwback to September, but does anyone know if Color Club made a color similar to the rose gold that wasn't "Put a pin in it"? I picked up a set of 7 polishes for $8 and one is a rose-metallic, but seems to lean a little more silver than I'd imagined (I haven't seen "put a pin in it" except on the interwebs, and this looks the same). I happened to drop into Target and see Essie's "Penny Talk", which people said was similar - but that one definitely ran more gold/copper in tone. I feel like tracking down Color Club names is pretty much impossible, so if anyone has anecdotal evidence, I'd appreciate it!

It's not color club, but I have orly's "rage" and tried to do a barely noticeable statement nail. Yeah, couldn't tell a difference. In the bottle orly has a bigger flake of glitter, but on the nail you can't tell.

 
Originally Posted by soccerkidtlk /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Has anyones tracking info not updated at all??? I feel like im the only one with no tracking and its been a week...
Mine still hasn't updated, but one of my boxes showed up today. Don't lose hope!

 
Originally Posted by gypsiemagic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I call that highway robbery

woooo labor, you cut the elastics. shit ain't worth an extra 40 cents, a 5 year old can cut elastic and tie them.

plus I got to pick my colors. 60 took me all of 15 minutes to whip out.
I'm sorry, but I don't think you understand the big picture. There is more labor than simply making the elastics (tie/cut). That seller is also taking time to take pictures, upload pictures, organize a shop on etsy, handle sales inquiries, email/package/ship... If that is how she is making a living, it's not highway robbery at all. It's your choice to pay for something or not. If you prefer to make your own, good for you for saving some money. Many people are happy to pay for someone else to do the work; their time is worth that extra 40 cents. If she charged at cost, she would effectively be paying you to take her product.

 
Originally Posted by lunadust /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got box one today. The gloss sample is very tiny but I think there is a few uses in it. 
What color was your Essie polish? I should be receiving box 1 later this week, and I'm dying to know the polish color! :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
you mean the same DDF cleanser that's in this box, or the one that was in the sample society? I just don't understand how their products are marketed towards sensitive skin, bc they seem to give people terrible reactions. I mean why include common irritants?

Originally Posted by Meshybelle /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I had a terrible allergic reaction to the DDF cleanser. It's still healing and its been three weeks!! Yikes, be careful!!
 
Originally Posted by winkiepup /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got Box #2 today. It smells really strange...but anyway, it had:

Full Size Essie Fair Game

Joanna Vargas Daily Serum Marie Veronique Organics Body Oil Sprout Lip Balm   The serum is not very big...nor is the body oil. A bit underwhelming, but there's the Essie...   and the Luna bar!
I got that box too. I think my favorite part was the Luna bar. I dont even like the color of the essie!! But at least it's full size, it is hard to please everyone.
 
Originally Posted by americanclassic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

you mean the same DDF cleanser that's in this box, or the one that was in the sample society? I just don't understand how their products are marketed towards sensitive skin, bc they seem to give people terrible reactions. I mean why include common irritants?
the vasanti in my september box irritated my skin too and i put down sensitive skin in my profile. i tried it 5x with no other products before i came to that conclusion...however the alffia three step system that came in the my shade of brown box cured my dry skin. (facial scrub, facial toner, and moisturizer) plus the proceeds for that company goes to fair trade and gender empowerment in west africa

 
Originally Posted by americanclassic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

you mean the same DDF cleanser that's in this box, or the one that was in the sample society? I just don't understand how their products are marketed towards sensitive skin, bc they seem to give people terrible reactions. I mean why include common irritants?
It was the, DDF skin brightening cleanser. The one that smells like licorice. I got it in last months box. That's the reason why I used it because it is marketed for sensitive skin. I have used products that have not agreed with my skin before, but never had a reaction as bad as the one I had with DDF.

 
the vasanti in my september box irritated my skin too and i put down sensitive skin in my profile. i tried it 5x with no other products before i came to that conclusion...however the alffia three step system that came in the my shade of brown box cured my dry skin. (facial scrub, facial toner, and moisturizer) plus the proceeds for that company goes to fair trade and gender empowerment in west africa
Aww.. I had the opposite, I really liked the Vasanti lol. My skin felt extra soft and nice afterwards.
 
Originally Posted by MissLindaJean /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Aww.. I had the opposite, I really liked the Vasanti lol. My skin felt extra soft and nice afterwards.
yeah  i wanted to like it too. i only put a dab of it on my face and it got itchy. i thought that it was this new primer that i was using but my face felt irritated as soon as i rinsed the vasanti off :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> 

 
Originally Posted by MissLindaJean /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Aww.. I had the opposite, I really liked the Vasanti lol. My skin felt extra soft and nice afterwards.
I hated that stuff. Maybe I'm just a wuss and have no pain threshold, but I thought the scrub was too harsh feeling. 

 
I literally just received my Birchbox so I thought I would post a pic (that's my excuse for the poor lighting.) Not too pleased this month. Excited to try everything but like everyone else has been saying, small samples. There were just so many other things I wanted: mascara, nail polish, candles, beauty blenders...



Luna Bar LemonZest

Lulu Organics Lavendar & Clary Hair Powder

Embryolisse 24 Hour Miracle Cream

Karuna Hydrating Treatment Mask

Naked Princess Lip Gloss in Barely Blus

Below is the box with the lip gloss taken out of the paper so you can see the size (i.e. tiny.)


 
I got this box too. It's kinda bumming me out....

Originally Posted by prachisrk /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Got my Box # 3. It should definitely be nominated for the worst birchbox box ever. 




No a single decent size product.



This naked princess gloss sample is equivalent to that flower sample. The amount of actual gloss in the sample is 1/4 the size of the case - 0.008 oz. Most of the case is the brush.  I do not have giant hands btw lol.



Another look.
 
Still no box ... bummer. 
icon_cry.gif


 
Originally Posted by winkiepup /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got Box #2 today. It smells really strange...but anyway, it had:

Full Size Essie Fair Game

Joanna Vargas Daily Serum Marie Veronique Organics Body Oil Sprout Lip Balm   The serum is not very big...nor is the body oil. A bit underwhelming, but there's the Essie...   and the Luna bar!
I got this box also today.   My essie color was "carry on."   Which is a dark redish purple, a good fall color I hope.   The sprout lip balm was in cocoa. 
 

Latest posts

Back
Top