I know a lot of people don't like their stick concealer. But it's seriously the ONLY brand besides bare minerals that actually matches my skintone. I'm an NW15, so I'm a weird pale because I'm warm toned.
I also have what I lovingly refer to as "zombie circles" under my eyes. I inherited my dads bags under my eyes and dark dark circles, no matter how great I eat, how much water I drink or how much sleep I get. They're always there and have been my entire life.
The concealer formula is nice and creamy and blends easily when I apply it with my fingers.
I've been using it since I was 15 years old...and I just turned 30.
It's the only makeup product that I've consistently been wearing since I first started wearing makeup. I tried other brands and they all just don't match my skin. I've tried stila, which is oily, covergirl which turned orange, and countless other brands that all were too watery, too yellow or too orange to work on my face.
I would absolutely cry if they discontinued it because I've been using it for so long.
The bizarre thing is that in the tube it looks way more peachy orange than it reads on me.
I don't mind their eyeshadows, but a lot of them are too powdery/chalky for my taste. I like their nail polishes. But the concealer stick is the one product I buy from them as soon as mine starts getting low.
I also had terrible luck with their foundation. Their concealer stick does not bother my skin at all or make me break out in the slightest. But that foundation just totally made my skin freak out. For the record, all drugstore foundations do that to me.
Their mascaras have never impressed me, and I don't like lipstick, so I don't buy theirs.
I do like their powdered bronzers though.