Wantable - new quarterly subscription

[meaganola]

It looks like I'll be reassessing my subs next month and deciding what to cut -- and whether I can justify adding this one.  I'm in the process of changing most of my subs over from my debit card to my credit card because my bank canceled my debit card due to fraudulent activity, and I have a feeling the credit card bill after the next round of charges will be a shocker.  It doesn't seem like it's as much money as it probably is when the charges are coming out of my checking account because those just kind of erode my bank balance like the tide washing over rocks and gradually creating sand instead of like a chainsaw attack lopping off a huge chunk all at once.

 

[Jflopez]

It looks like I'll be reassessing my subs next month and deciding what to cut -- and whether I can justify adding this one.  I'm in the process of changing most of my subs over from my debit card to my credit card because my bank canceled my debit card due to fraudulent activity, and I have a feeling the credit card bill after the next round of charges will be a shocker.  It doesn't seem like it's as much money as it probably is when the charges are coming out of my checking account because those just kind of erode my bank balance like the tide washing over rocks and gradually creating sand instead of like a chainsaw attack lopping off a huge chunk all at once.

You've got nothing to lose since you can return!

The other huge plus to wantable is that they give you the choice each month to skip if you need to. A little easier on the wallet when you need it.

 

[lloronita]

I've been with Wantable since they started and I've loved every box.  They comply very closely with your preferences (which you can change monthly) and send all full-size, high quality products.  It's the last subscription box I'd give up!  I don't think you'll be sorry if you go for it!

Plus their customer service is very responsive/helpful and their box always arrives promptly.

 

[Heather Hicks]

Originally Posted by lolley /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I received my May jewelry box last week.

I'm extremely happy with it /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I received a necklace and 4 pairs of earrings.

My preferences were followed perfectly.

Here is a pic:



I received the free Canadian box (just pay shipping and duty).

I won't be resubbing as the regular price is too steep.

Lolley--I love the necklace and the fact that you got matching earrings. If it were me, I'd prefer smaller hoops and the fringe style on the left isn't really me. But still, overall, I think it is really cute. What styles did you pick? I said I liked Classic, loved Glam, and liked Seasonal (I think) but this looks more like a 'rock style' to me. If that's the kind of stuff they consider 'rock,' I might should change my profile. That said, I just now caved to try the makeup box, so I'm not going to jump into the jewelry just yet. All the spikey necklaces I see worry me, but I'm thinking that may be 'boho' so I did say I hated 'boho.'

 

[MissTrix]

Originally Posted by Heather Hicks /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Quote: Originally Posted by lolley /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I received my May jewelry box last week.

I'm extremely happy with it /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I received a necklace and 4 pairs of earrings.

My preferences were followed perfectly.

Here is a pic:



I received the free Canadian box (just pay shipping and duty).

I won't be resubbing as the regular price is too steep.
Lolley--I love the necklace and the fact that you got matching earrings. If it were me, I'd prefer smaller hoops and the fringe style on the left isn't really me. But still, overall, I think it is really cute. What styles did you pick? I said I liked Classic, loved Glam, and liked Seasonal (I think) but this looks more like a 'rock style' to me. If that's the kind of stuff they consider 'rock,' I might should change my profile. That said, I just now caved to try the makeup box, so I'm not going to jump into the jewelry just yet. All the spikey necklaces I see worry me, but I'm thinking that may be 'boho' so I did say I hated 'boho.'


Spikey stuff would more than likely be "rock and roll". Boho would be more beaded hippie looking stuff. Think natural materials like crystals, leather, and turquoise and jewelry that looks handmade. If the spikes in question look like bone or wood or are accompanied by beading, then it very well might be boho. If you go back to this post of my May jewelry box:

https://www.makeuptalk.com/t/128094/wantable-new-quarterly-subscription/270#post_2087361

...the Zoe necklace (turquoise beads) would be "boho" while the Muccan necklace (spikes) would be rock and roll.

Hope this helped. 

 

[Heather Hicks]

Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Spikey stuff would more than likely be "rock and roll". Boho would be more beaded hippie looking stuff. Think natural materials like crystals, leather, and turquoise and jewelry that looks handmade. If the spikes in question look like bone or wood or are accompanied by beading, then it very well might be boho. If you go back to this post of my May jewelry box:

https://www.makeuptalk.com/t/128094/wantable-new-quarterly-subscription/270#post_2087361

...the Zoe necklace (turquoise beads) would be "boho" while the Muccan necklace (spikes) would be rock and roll.

Hope this helped. 

Thanks Miss Trix. I guess I should keep rock n roll as a dislike then. Boho too, though I like some of it, just not enough to get it sight unseen. I'm still not signing up for jewelry any time soon. But I would like to figure out what to call what I like for general knowledge as well as in case I sign up for the Wantable jewelry box later on. I wish they had pictures of jewelry sent out in previous boxes as examples, though I understand they wouldn't want to give someone the impression they might get those exact items. It would be helpful for clueless people like me though.

 

[FellFollow]

I just gave in and signed up for my first Wantable makeup box.  The Besame cosmetics look just lovely.  I was so impressed with the preference quiz.  I love that I can tell them NOT to send me entire categories of items.  Looking forward to receiving my first box and discovering some new brands! 
 

 

[Heather Hicks]

Originally Posted by FellFollow /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I just gave in and signed up for my first Wantable makeup box.  The Besame cosmetics look just lovely.  I was so impressed with the preference quiz.  I love that I can tell them NOT to send me entire categories of items.  Looking forward to receiving my first box and discovering some new brands! 

Me too. Not that I can afford it and my husband will probably read me the riot act when he finds out. But that Besame lip and cheek pot looked too good. Hoping for it, but I liked lots of the other products too. Plus, if I can tell them 'never send me mascara' then all the better!

 

[ohdahlia]

Got my second Wantable box today!  I am really pleased, though I haven't yet received any Besame; I really want to try them, and I hope I get some next time. My camera phone is horrible, so I'll just list the products below:

Spoilers (highlight to see the five products I received, plus my bonus item)

Bonus: Frownies (eye gel pads)

Mascara: Face Stockholm in Black (only OK -- I much preferred the previous month's mascara)

Brazen Loose Brow Powder in Raquel--medium brown with red undertones (love this! It is the best brow powder I have ever used)

Mia BelleZZa lipstick in Carla -- a neutral shade (not very exciting -- I have a ton of lipstick, and most of it is neutral)

Mia BelleZZa gel eyeliner in Blu -- a very pigmented pot (haven't tried this yet!)

FACE Stockholm eyeshadow in Dusk--a brown (liked this MUCH more than I expected to -- this is some of the best eyeshadow I've used)
 

Overall, I was pleased with this box. I wasn't thrilled to get back-to-back mascara, but that's probably my fault. I did not receive any of my dislikes (bronzer, nail polish, tools). I'd love to see a little more brand variety. I have yet to receive Besame or Lisa Watier, and I've gotten four FACE Stockholm products in the last two months.

 

[Heather Hicks]

I am shocked!

 Last night, I caught the Wantable makeup bug. I must have placed my order around 1:30 at night eastern time. Today, at around 1:30 in the morning as well, I check my email and find a shipping notice has shown up. The tracking even works already. Estimated delivery date? The 12th! I'm pretty stoked. Yes, the $40 price tag is a bit daunting. But...I have been getting 2-3 Ipsy's and I just signed up for 2 Birchboxes for July as well. I don't foresee dropping all my Ipsy accounts, but I could possibly see dumping BB to get Wantable if the box itself turns out to be as good as the fast customer service. Plus, I like that I can skip months or return a box if I want to or need to for some reason in any given month. Oh dear. Here I go falling down another addicting makeup rabbit hole! 

 

[smiletorismile]

Originally Posted by Heather Hicks /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I am shocked!

 Last night, I caught the Wantable makeup bug. I must have placed my order around 1:30 at night eastern time. Today, at around 1:30 in the morning as well, I check my email and find a shipping notice has shown up. The tracking even works already. Estimated delivery date? The 12th! I'm pretty stoked. Yes, the $40 price tag is a bit daunting. But...I have been getting 2-3 Ipsy's and I just signed up for 2 Birchboxes for July as well. I don't foresee dropping all my Ipsy accounts, but I could possibly see dumping BB to get Wantable if the box itself turns out to be as good as the fast customer service. Plus, I like that I can skip months or return a box if I want to or need to for some reason in any given month. Oh dear. Here I go falling down another addicting makeup rabbit hole! 

That's awesome! The shipping for them seems to be super fast. My box shipped already too! /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[MissTrix]

Originally Posted by Heather Hicks /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I am shocked!

 Last night, I caught the Wantable makeup bug. I must have placed my order around 1:30 at night eastern time. Today, at around 1:30 in the morning as well, I check my email and find a shipping notice has shown up. The tracking even works already. Estimated delivery date? The 12th! I'm pretty stoked. Yes, the $40 price tag is a bit daunting. But...I have been getting 2-3 Ipsy's and I just signed up for 2 Birchboxes for July as well. I don't foresee dropping all my Ipsy accounts, but I could possibly see dumping BB to get Wantable if the box itself turns out to be as good as the fast customer service. Plus, I like that I can skip months or return a box if I want to or need to for some reason in any given month. Oh dear. Here I go falling down another addicting makeup rabbit hole! 

That's one of many things I love about Wantable, they don't ship all of the boxes at the same time. You will get your next box at the same time next month and the month after, etc. You know exactly when to expect it and it ships FAST! You can even request your box early or buy a second one by redoing your quiz. The options come up at the end of the quiz. Also, their customer service is awesome. If you have any problems, don't hesitate to contact them. They get back to you really fast (comparatively speaking) and they have been excellent about listening to customer feedback and tweaking their business model accordingly. 

 

[SOSRedAlertSOS]

Hey ladies! Exciting news, I just ordered my first Wantable makeup box! I am so pumped. I emailed them explaining that I was really interested in trying their service and that I was curious if they had any type of promotion so that I could get a discount. Well, they got back to me right away, within like 5 minutes! It was amazing! They said they normally don't do promo codes and what not but that she would give me 10% off of my first box!

If this experience with their customer service is any indication of how they run their company, I am seriously impressed! I can't wait to get my first box!

 

[sparklesgirlxox]

Originally Posted by lloronita /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I've been with Wantable since they started and I've loved every box.  They comply very closely with your preferences (which you can change monthly) and send all full-size, high quality products.  It's the last subscription box I'd give up!  I don't think you'll be sorry if you go for it!

Plus their customer service is very responsive/helpful and their box always arrives promptly.

Myself sister and friends tried them and they appeared to not look at any of our preferences at all plus several duplicates in next boxes that were in the first box.  We all cancelled because of it. I think you got lucky with them. They seem terribly disorganized

 

[sparklesgirlxox]

Originally Posted by KellyKaye /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Hey ladies! Exciting news, I just ordered my first Wantable makeup box! I am so pumped. I emailed them explaining that I was really interested in trying their service and that I was curious if they had any type of promotion so that I could get a discount. Well, they got back to me right away, within like 5 minutes! It was amazing! They said they normally don't do promo codes and what not but that she would give me 10% off of my first box!

If this experience with their customer service is any indication of how they run their company, I am seriously impressed! I can't wait to get my first box!

How did  you reach customer service. I didn't know they even had a phone number to call it didn't exist a month or 2 ago and I thought it was strange.

 

[SOSRedAlertSOS]

How did  you reach customer service. I didn't know they even had a phone number to call it didn't exist a month or 2 ago and I thought it was strange.

Oh, I emailed them.

 

[MissTrix]

Quote: Originally Posted by sparklesgirlxox /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Originally Posted by KellyKaye /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Hey ladies! Exciting news, I just ordered my first Wantable makeup box! I am so pumped. I emailed them explaining that I was really interested in trying their service and that I was curious if they had any type of promotion so that I could get a discount. Well, they got back to me right away, within like 5 minutes! It was amazing! They said they normally don't do promo codes and what not but that she would give me 10% off of my first box!

If this experience with their customer service is any indication of how they run their company, I am seriously impressed! I can't wait to get my first box!

How did  you reach customer service. I didn't know they even had a phone number to call it didn't exist a month or 2 ago and I thought it was strange.


Wantable is probably the easiest to reach of all of my subs. They have answered all of my emails within a day or two. They also respond to people via Facebook, Reddit, Twitter, and they even have a rep that posts in this thread.

 

[yousoldtheworld]

Originally Posted by sparklesgirlxox /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Myself sister and friends tried them and they appeared to not look at any of our preferences at all plus several duplicates in next boxes that were in the first box.  We all cancelled because of it. I think you got lucky with them. They seem terribly disorganized

I don't know, many of us have had good experiences with them. I'm sorry you and your friends didn't, but it seems that might have been a fluke, most experiences seem to be pretty positive.

 

[Alicia Loves]

I've only ever had good experiences with wantable and I love the elaborate quiz, which you can change month to month. Sometimes I make it really specific so I'm guaranteed certain products. All of the brands appear to be high quality. I love it! It's a pricey one though. I wish there was a points system you could use toward a free box.
 

 

[meaganola]

*cough* It looks like I might get some overtime Saturday. My first thought when I found out was "Ooh, I can get a Wantable box!" I think I will slot a box into my budget any month when I get a few hours of OT. That will make me feel not guilty about buying more makeup. (Added bonus of working on a Saturday: I won't be out running errands and shopping all day, thereby saving money on top of making it.)