(SPOILERS) July Birchbox partners with Glamour Magazine

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Originally Posted by tameloy /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I kinda hope my box is wrong...I'm supposed to be getting box 19.
I think it's just the 3s and 15s that were transposed, so you *should* get the box on your profie. 

I'm glad I wasn't in love with #15, because I got #3 for both accounts. Not thrilled over that one either, but at least my 2 August BBs will be free.

 
Originally Posted by PinkCupcake /img/forum/go_quote.gif

i've been reading through these forums for a while and once say that someone said that if you want to stop recieving a certain product then to write down thats what you splurge on in the profiles. So i dont want to recieve nail polish ever, do i write that its what i splurge on? i wasnt sure if that person was joking or not. if someone could clarify this for me then i'd be really grateful :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
It doesn't work that way for me. I always had perfume down as my splurge item, so I got all the high-end perfume samples in my boxes every time. Recently I changed it to foundation, and I finally received a Jouer moisturizing tint sample. I'd say put down your splurge as what you would ACTUALLY splurge on. They'll send you the more expensive of those items, from what I've found.

 
did anyone receive an e-mail saying "why does birchbox have a shop"?  I'm kinda annoyed by it.  The only time i shop in the store is when i have enough points to cover the item, tax and shipping.  If they don't like that, then oh well 
wassatt.gif


 
Originally Posted by quene8106 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

did anyone receive an e-mail saying "why does birchbox have a shop"?  I'm kinda annoyed by it.  The only time i shop in the store is when i have enough points to cover the item, tax and shipping.  If they don't like that, then oh well 
wassatt.gif
I'm glad they're looking for feedback (as they said to leave in the comments.) I can imagine why they want us to shop in their shop more - I think it's one of the reason we get such great brands for so relatively cheap!

 
Originally Posted by thewendyyybird /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I'm glad they're looking for feedback (as they said to leave in the comments.) I can imagine why they want us to shop in their shop more - I think it's one of the reason we get such great brands for so relatively cheap!
yup. i hope that they read and implement these suggestions. the majority of them are about opting out of perfume.  not everyone is looking for a signature scent.  and yes i put perfume as my splurge item and my boxes have been perfume free so far.  *knocks on wood that this will continue forever and ever, lol*

 
Ugh. I was a victim of the box mix up. I was so looking forward to getting box 15 and got 3 with a box 15 index card in it. I called and emailed BB....I hope they fix this because I am a sad sad girl. Not to mention to tinted jouer moisturizer in the box I did get was in BRONZE...and I'm so very pale. I also got the color protecting gloss....but my hair is not color treated. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
 

 
Okay - this is my justifying, rationalizing, preaching to the choir ramble about why I do multiple Birchboxes a month and gamble.  I 'only' - ha ha - had 3 boxes for myself, two after the first month and then added an extra during teen vogue so I could get the regular Birchbox and two teen vogues, ended up giving one teen vogue away.  The fourth box is for a friend and she pays me for it.  She just decided that she wants to quit her box and her MyGlam, so I have an extra box and and extra MyGlam that I should get rid of but I'm enjoying the extras for the trade thread right now.  In fact, since I bring back her boxes every two months to her, I have the past two Birchboxes and MyGlam bags and told her she could retroactively cancel if that's what she wanted and I'd keep them and she wouldn't have to worry about paying me for them, of course.  She's thankful and is happy that she gets to keep her money to save for something she really is wanting to order and might take two of the four, now that she knows what is in each, but from now on the subs are all me.
 
This is what I got in all of the boxes this month.  So for $40, I got 2 $15 eyeliners that I love, 2 $17.50 mascaras (that I'd been wanting and would have bought myself anyway), 4 Tea Forte mintea tins - 3 go for $10, so about $13 worth, 4 pairs of earphones - darn, I was hoping these were usable.  Are anyones?  Do they at least have the same rubber tips as the regular ones, the skull candy ones?  I'm always losing those and was hoping that I could keep these as extras.  The headphones I usually use are about $10 a pair.  I also got 4 perfume samples, 3 different types, lip gloss, the color protection fluid x 2, the luminizing moisture tint, shimmer lotion, sunscreen serum and a nail polish.  A pretty good haul, I think, and definitely worth what I paid. A gamble?  Yes, but that's part of the fun.  Just one box with a $34 blush or a $36 bronzer can make up most of the price of all of the other items in all four boxes and I get tons of samples, to both try, make up gift boxes/bags and trade for items I really want and give others what they really want.   It really ups my chances of getting what I want.  I've been really lucky not to have double boxes all these months (since January), how - I don't know.  Even if I got doubles, some things I really like and want to use up and others I can try one and trade one.  I also am able to review products that I like for points, and this month all my boxes have 6 items, so that's $6 back in the future on purchases, which I will definitely use, bringing my cost to about $4 a box.  Plus Birchbox lets you use anniversary codes for 20% off and use points and includes free shipping, so when I do use those points I really get an awesome deal.  I am a bit crazy but I figured if anyone would maybe understand, it'd be some MakeupTalk gals.  Plus, I don't have a mall or Sephora or anywhere to buy nice makeup here in Belize, the closest thing to it is a variety type store that sells elf and Covergirl makeup at 3 times the manufacturer's suggested retail price and that is probably very old because it's so expensive, no one buys it.  I probably won't do this forever, I can see getting burnt out on too many samples eventually, but I'm having fun with it now.  It makes me a very good friend to have, because I always have something interesting to share.  My husband asked me this morning, "Do you have a moisturizer, not a sunblock?  My skin is really dry" and then "of course you do", shaking his head. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> The only bad thing for me about this is it's exposing me to brands that are amazing and expensive that I'm starting to love.  But I always have a serum, lotion, cleanser, body lotion, new mascara/eyeliner, travel shampoo/conditioners, etc. on hand, so that's nice.  Just wanted to share my boxes this month - sorry for the novel! 
rolleyes1.gif

 
Originally Posted by ordinarysarah /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Perfumes are my favorite part of my boxes. :/
aww. i'm not bashing on people that get perfumes. i just wish that they had an option to opt out of it. nothing more.  i don't want them to get rid of them all together b.c i know that perfumes are some ppl's fav part of boxes.  i am a mascara junkie and i'm dying to get my hands on a sample of blinc. i also get annoyed when i put that i have ethnic hair on my profile but i never get their ethnic hair products like hair rules or miss jessies. i got amika this month and that was just okay. nothing special to me.  

at the end of the day, they really need to cater to our profiles and give us what we really want. if we keep getting samples that we don't want or are the opposite of what's in our profile, then we're not gonna shop in their friggin store. that's probably what is hurting their pockets as we type. point blank.

 
Originally Posted by quene8106 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


aww. i'm not bashing on people that get perfumes. i just wish that they had an option to opt out of it. nothing more.  i don't want them to get rid of them all together b.c i know that perfumes are some ppl's fav part of boxes.  i am a mascara junkie and i'm dying to get my hands on a sample of blinc. i also get annoyed when i put that i have ethnic hair on my profile but i never get their ethnic hair products like hair rules or miss jessies. i got amika this month and that was just okay. nothing special to me.  

at the end of the day, they really need to cater to our profiles and give us what we really want. if we keep getting samples that we don't want or are the opposite of what's in our profile, then we're not gonna shop in their friggin store. that's probably what is hurting their pockets as we type. point blank.

I totally agree. In fact, I responded to that email they sent about the box, and told them exactly that. I have on my profile that I like natural looking and minimal makeup, am not adventurous with my color choices, and have fair skin. Yet, they sent me a bold liquid eyeliner, a blue nail polish, and a tan tinted moisturizer.

I also told them that I have purchased many, many items from their shop--most of the time, they have been items I wish I'd received in my box when I didn't. Example: Clark's Rich Lip Gloss, Dr. Jart+ Water Fuse BB Cream, Minteas, Modcloth Headband, Harvey Prince Eau Flirt. They definitely need to fine-tune that side of the business, and yes, that is exactly what is hurting their pockets. You're totally right!

 
Originally Posted by quene8106 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


aww. i'm not bashing on people that get perfumes. i just wish that they had an option to opt out of it. nothing more.  i don't want them to get rid of them all together b.c i know that perfumes are some ppl's fav part of boxes.  i am a mascara junkie and i'm dying to get my hands on a sample of blinc. i also get annoyed when i put that i have ethnic hair on my profile but i never get their ethnic hair products like hair rules or miss jessies. i got amika this month and that was just okay. nothing special to me.  

at the end of the day, they really need to cater to our profiles and give us what we really want. if we keep getting samples that we don't want or are the opposite of what's in our profile, then we're not gonna shop in their friggin store. that's probably what is hurting their pockets as we type. point blank.
I don't know, I just think this sort of thing isn't for everyone, you know? Like, if you're more specific or picky about what you want, then you'd probably be happier just spending the 10 dollars like you want. The service doesn't promise to send us our favorite items for ten dollars - they promise to send new samples for us to try (with no guarantee that we'll love them) for ten dollars.

I do think that there profiles could use some work, but at the same time, it's a pretty ambitious goal in itself. They're one of the few, if only, services that even has that feature or pretends to use it. Plus, a lot of what is it the profile can be considered subjective. Take, for example, the question about what style you are. What might be "classic" to me could be "trendy" to you.

I don't know. I think that there's no way to give everyone what they really want, not at this price point, anyway. It's a service that is meant to let us try new things, as sweetiegirlll pointed out. It's just not suited to everyone!
sunshine.gif


 
Has anyone received a color besides Blue Ming in their boxes? I'm supposed to get mine tomorrow and I was just curious. In the pictures it looks like it could be close the Zoya's Bevin which I got a few months ago...or maybe Blue Ming is lighter?

 
Originally Posted by TinaMarina /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Has anyone received a color besides Blue Ming in their boxes? I'm supposed to get mine tomorrow and I was just curious. In the pictures it looks like it could be close the Zoya's Bevin which I got a few months ago...or maybe Blue Ming is lighter?
It seems like everyone is getting Blue Ming, though it's pretty different from Zoya Bevin! It's much bluer/brighter. Almost like a turquoise, I'd say! Try googling swatches and you'll see what I mean! =)

 
Originally Posted by TinaMarina /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Has anyone received a color besides Blue Ming in their boxes? I'm supposed to get mine tomorrow and I was just curious. In the pictures it looks like it could be close the Zoya's Bevin which I got a few months ago...or maybe Blue Ming is lighter?
It's not close at at IMO, it is closer to Essie Mint Candy Apple:



 
My headphones work great! Nothing wrong with them at all. I used them at the gym and to watch a movie on my laptop. I could hear just as well as with my Apple headphones. I'm pleased with them. They are cheap so I don't have to worry about losing them.
 

 
Originally Posted by thewendyyybird /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I don't know, I just think this sort of thing isn't for everyone, you know? Like, if you're more specific or picky about what you want, then you'd probably be happier just spending the 10 dollars like you want. The service doesn't promise to send us our favorite items for ten dollars - they promise to send new samples for us to try (with no guarantee that we'll love them) for ten dollars.

I do think that there profiles could use some work, but at the same time, it's a pretty ambitious goal in itself. They're one of the few, if only, services that even has that feature or pretends to use it. Plus, a lot of what is it the profile can be considered subjective. Take, for example, the question about what style you are. What might be "classic" to me could be "trendy" to you.

I don't know. I think that there's no way to give everyone what they really want, not at this price point, anyway. It's a service that is meant to let us try new things, as sweetiegirlll pointed out. It's just not suited to everyone!
sunshine.gif
yes i agree with what you're saying. there are some things that i have never even heard of before subbing with bb that i love, such as the stila lip glazes, the eye serum, tarte, cynthia rowley bandaids, caudalie, ojon, dirt scrub etc. but there are some items that i'm like 
wtf.gif
. if i want something that i discovered from bb i'm going to try it out at sephora and if i like it, i'm buying it from there. i'm in NYC and there are tons of sephoras in manhattan, plus i don't have to pay for shipping and tax (NYers have to pay 8.975% tax for bb products -_- /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />) so it's economical for me in my opinion. it takes at least 2 months just to get at least 100 points, unless you get a crazy amount of referrals or they really screwed up your box. that's the reason why i don't shop in their store. call me a tightwad if you want, but i'm currently underemployed and i always try to find ways to get a good deal out of $.

 
Originally Posted by princess2010 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

My headphones work great! Nothing wrong with them at all. I used them at the gym and to watch a movie on my laptop. I could hear just as well as with my Apple headphones. I'm pleased with them. They are cheap so I don't have to worry about losing them.
Ooh, good, that's great to hear!  I was hoping that I could stash mine different places so when I'm running out the door and I can't find a set I can get them out of the drawer, the top of the fridge, or other hiding places.

 

Latest posts

Back
Top