with these pictures for comparison i would say the long one is better but i really prefer her with short hair. i think in general these were just not the best pictures of her.
she looks amazing before and after.. the long hair is sooo nice, but for some reason her short hair and new styles of clothes and makeup shes sporting is wicked and suit her.
I don't like the new ''boyish'' cut, but when it was choppier it looked beautiful! Of course, the long hair looks pretty too.. but she's gorgeous and can pull of anything!
When her hair is too long, it makes her look like a teen, but with a bob, the shape flatters her face really well and is much better than this new pixie-mullet thing she has going on.