Rainbow Honey Mystery Box

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Yow, now that I'm counting, that's more than half of the polishes they've sent out! Perhaps an email asking them to branch out into other colors for the bags might be in order. They do produce enough other kinds of colors to be able to have more options!
Could it be they are trying to target a generalized demographic with the bags?  There has been quite a few blue shades as well and looking at them all aside from the Petit Four which is yellow, they are similar (blue or pink). At least since I started the bag in April.  I know I personally would love a purple or green shade but because they often can give lobster hands or may not be suited for a general skin tone selection.. are the mystery bags reflecting this? 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Could it be they are trying to target a generalized demographic with the bags?  There has been quite a few blue shades as well and looking at them all aside from the Petit Four which is yellow, they are similar (blue or pink). At least since I started the bag in April.  I know I personally would love a purple or green shade but because they often can give lobster hands or may not be suited for a general skin tone selection.. are the mystery bags reflecting this? 
But other nail polish subs seem to have more variety, even if all the subscribers get the same colors (ex. squarehue or cmm).

 
Yep, I just cancelled my RH sub for this exact reason. All the pinks and top coats. I wear my pink polishes the least and I just was looking for something different.

 
Don't get me wrong, I love pink and glitter, but I'd definitely like to see some interesting different colors. Like orange. Or green. Or some different finishes. I'm still in love with the mystery bag though.

 
Don't get me wrong, I love pink and glitter, but I'd definitely like to see some interesting different colors. Like orange. Or green. Or some different finishes. I'm still in love with the mystery bag though.
I just wrote up my blog review for it, and I think the love is waning for me. I was a little more negative about it than I originally thought. Pink every month, the same fruity scents every month this summer, and perfume and cuticle or lip balm combo every month is getting boring. I think I'll wait to see what happens next month, but if there's another pink or fruit scent I may cancel.

 
I cancelled my subscription last month (mainly because I was having major issues with the formula) and hoped to just buy bags I liked after I saw spoilers. It's disappointing to see that they are sending so many repeats and that the fragrances aren't that great either (they were one of my favorite parts of the bag!) 

Hopefully with fall coming they will continue sending the fun (new!) glitters that made me want to subscribe in the first place (and their formula improves a little) and I can continue buying! 

 
I do have to say I am loving the Royal Fruits cuticle balm.  It's my new go to scent.  It does smell a lot like Midori and reminds me of Strawberry/Banana Bubble Yum. 

 
All the pink is honestly why I haven't signed up yet!  I got the "Midnight Fountain" shade in my Ipsy bag awhile back and LOVED IT.  I don't actually have a lot of pink glitter, but I was lucky enough to get the June bag as a gift, and that pretty much set me up for the next few years on pink glitter!

However - I LOVE fall scents and colors!  I'm so excited to see if they really adapt to a seasonal setup, because if they start doing green/gold/orange glitters with pumpkin-y/apple-y scents, I'm all over it!

 
Wow. There really has been a lot of pink. I mean, it's my favorite color, but I think I'm set on pink glitter for life now.

I had canceled my sub for August to get the bag free with purchase. Since I'm already.canceled, I may stay unsubbed for the moment and wait for spoilers before I go for September. See if they switch things up before I commit to another bag.

 
I wrote this to them last night - I will let you know if they respond!

Hi there

I love rainbow honey's monthly subscription and plan to stay sub'd for a while!  That said, can I make a suggestion?  I would love to see other colors besides pink - I know you've sent out a few teals and blues, but it just seems that there have been a lot of pinks in our bags.    I've been sub'd since the 2nd month, and there has been a lot of pink nailpolishes/glitters in our bags - I counted eight pink minis  nailpolishes that I have :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />   Can we have some deep forest greens, plums, coppers, browns, blacks - glitters, creams, unusual finishes?   Especially with the fall/winter months coming around as well.

For scents - are you planning some fall and winter scents - like apples/cinnamon, pine-cones, pumpkin?  I loved tea biscuit - and that is a great fall scent, btw!

thank you for taking the time to read my suggestions!
 
I wrote this to them last night - I will let you know if they respond!
I think that every color you mentioned in this e-mail would be incredible! I have only been with rainbow honey for two months now and there seems to be a lot of blue and pink. I get it, those colors are appealing to most people but come on, let's get a little variety! Would definitely love to see some deep greens and copper, maybe even grey and silver...

 
I have always received excellent customer service from RH, even when a friend received horrid service.  My products were in great condition and my bags shipped promptly.  

However.......

I moved from Oklahoma to Florida on Aug 10.  I used my usual ship dates to decide whether or not to change addresses prior to the actual move.  Using this method, I decided my typical ship date for RH was on the 10th of the month so I gave them the new address.  I did a change of address at my old house just in case, but wanted all my subs closer to their normal time.  I received shipping info on 8/4, which would send my RH to Florida several days before I got there.  I was deathly afraid of "Return to Sender", so I immediately sent an email begging them to pull the shipment.  Carolyn responded quickly, saying she caught it just in time and would send it out on August 8.  On August 11, I sent an email verifying the shipment had been sent, since there was no tracking update.  Once again, Carolyn responded immediately, saying she would follow up and get back with me.  I waited until 8/16 (remember, this was supposed to ship 8 days prior) to send another follow up, since there was still no tracking update.  I didn't hear back from Carolyn until yesterday, 8/19.  She told me they shipped it, but it was returned because of a missing label.  Never mind the fact that tracking didn't show any activity, whatsoever!  I finally got tracking updated, and it looks like they just dropped it off/had it picked up today!  I'm not looking for free product or discounts or anything other than an "Oops!  We dropped the ball!  Our bad!"  Carolyn, however, has not offered anything remotely like an apology.  This is how it started with my friend, so I'm afraid cancellation is in order.  This makes me super sad because I really liked RH and the quality of CS I've become accustomed to has always been supreme.   :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

ETA:  spelling error!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have always received excellent customer service from RH, even when a friend received horrid service.  My products were in great condition and my bags shipped promptly.  

However.......

I moved from Oklahoma to Florida on Aug 10.  I used my usual ship dates to decide whether or not to change addresses prior to the actual move.  Using this method, I decided my typical ship date for RH was on the 10th of the month so I gave them the new address.  I did a change of address at my old house just in case, but wanted all my subs closer to their normal time.  I received shipping info on 8/4, which would send my RH to Florida several days before I got there.  I was deathly afraid of "Return to Sender", so I immediately sent an email begging them to pull the shipment.  Carolyn responded quickly, saying she caught it just in time and would send it out on August 8.  On August 11, I sent an email verifying the shipment had been sent, since there was no tacking update.  Once again, Carolyn responded immediately, saying she would follow up and get back with me.  I waited until 8/16 (remember, this was supposed to ship 8 days prior) to send another follow up, since there was still no tracking update.  I didn't hear back from Carolyn until yesterday, 8/19.  She told me they shipped it, but it was returned because of a missing label.  Never mind the fact that tracking didn't show any activity, whatsoever!  I finally got tracking updated, and it looks like they just dropped it off/had it picked up today!  I'm not looking for free product or discounts or anything other than an "Oops!  We dropped the ball!  Our bad!"  Carolyn, however, has not offered anything remotely like an apology.  This is how it started with my friend, so I'm afraid cancellation is in order.  This makes me super sad because I really liked RH and the quality of CS I've become accustomed to has always been supreme.   :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
Sadly, I will probably receive my RH before my Boxycharm, which shipped later than normal.  It has been in limbo since 8/10, transferring between my home town and Tulsa.  Tulsa sends it to home town, home town forwards it on (back to Tulsa), where Tulsa sends it back to home town.....

sigh

 
I have always received excellent customer service from RH, even when a friend received horrid service. My products were in great condition and my bags shipped promptly.

However.......

I moved from Oklahoma to Florida on Aug 10. I used my usual ship dates to decide whether or not to change addresses prior to the actual move. Using this method, I decided my typical ship date for RH was on the 10th of the month so I gave them the new address. I did a change of address at my old house just in case, but wanted all my subs closer to their normal time. I received shipping info on 8/4, which would send my RH to Florida several days before I got there. I was deathly afraid of "Return to Sender", so I immediately sent an email begging them to pull the shipment. Carolyn responded quickly, saying she caught it just in time and would send it out on August 8. On August 11, I sent an email verifying the shipment had been sent, since there was no tracking update. Once again, Carolyn responded immediately, saying she would follow up and get back with me. I waited until 8/16 (remember, this was supposed to ship 8 days prior) to send another follow up, since there was still no tracking update. I didn't hear back from Carolyn until yesterday, 8/19. She told me they shipped it, but it was returned because of a missing label. Never mind the fact that tracking didn't show any activity, whatsoever! I finally got tracking updated, and it looks like they just dropped it off/had it picked up today! I'm not looking for free product or discounts or anything other than an "Oops! We dropped the ball! Our bad!" Carolyn, however, has not offered anything remotely like an apology. This is how it started with my friend, so I'm afraid cancellation is in order. This makes me super sad because I really liked RH and the quality of CS I've become accustomed to has always been supreme. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

ETA: spelling error!
That must be so frustrating. Is Carolyn their only CS person? I've never heard of anyone contacting them and speaking with anyone else. Maybe there is some way to let the company know. You're not the first person here to say she refused to apologize to a customer.

 
That must be so frustrating. Is Carolyn their only CS person? I've never heard of anyone contacting them and speaking with anyone else. Maybe there is some way to let the company know. You're not the first person here to say she refused to apologize to a customer.
There's an e-mail address for Dee - dee AT rainbowhoney DOT com - and she was copied on my final communications before canceling my account, but she never replied in the e-mail thread we had going back and forth.  Just Carolyn.

Until my problem really escalated into an actual issue, Carolyn always copied the "customerservice AT rainbowhoney DOT com" address while writing from the  "info AT rainbowhoney DOT com" address.  Always.  However, when it became clear she wasn't taking any of the blame for the mistakes and actions on her end, and I was going forward with canceling my subscription, she quit copying the "info AT rainbowhoney DOT com" address on her replies.

I don't know why it was added initially, or why it was taken off later on.

I wasn't mean, or rude, or snotty.  I was not happy but I didn't take things out on them.  I've owned a small business and I've had to deal with my fair share of shipping woes as the vendor over the years.  (With very time-sensitive items such as birth announcements and holiday cards.)

My first shipping delay inquiry began with:  "Just want to start off with - this is in NO WAY your fault....."  (That mystery bag was shipped in the correct time frame, and the USPS lost it / track of it - it was shipped by RH 7/3 and USPS quit tracking it on 7/7.  I first contacted RH about it on 7/12, as I'd had the same problem with my bag the month prior.)  The first e-mail I received back asked me if I'd contacted the USPS myself and gave me their phone number.  In my opinion, that should have been RH's responsibility as the shipper and I told them as such.  I would never make my client do the initial contact and legwork -- especially if the last tracking of the item showed it still in my state, never having made it to theirs.

After the back and forths, and finally receiving my package on 7/16 (after being shipped on 7/3), this was my last note to them.  I never heard from them again after I sent it.

I do hope my experiences the last few months can help other Rainbow Honey customers in the future -- and possibly cause a change-up in your shipping methods.

 
This subscription has just ceased to be fun and exciting for me.  Having a chronic illness and being house and mostly bed-bound right now, subscription bags and boxes provide a little extra pick-me-up (and *sparkle*) here and there.
 
I cancelled my subscription because with the lack of support / apology (until yesterday), a portion of the burden of time being placed on my shoulders, and no attempt to ever make amends throughout . . . well, it just ceased to be fun for me anymore.
 
I love your products and I loved opening my Mystery Bag each month.  (It's precisely the reason I upgraded from the Mini to the Large after my very first one.)  I hope Rainbow Honey's future will have much more sparkle ahead.
 
Even the apology I'd received the day prior wasn't followed up on with me - by Carolyn or anyone else.  On July 15th - the day before my package actually arrived - Carolyn wrote:  "Regarding your concerns below, I want you to know that I have forwarded all of your emails to the appropriate departments for review and sincerely apologize again for all the trouble." -and- "As for it taking 14 days to travel just a few states over in modern times is unacceptable! I'm still waiting to hear back from USPS about that."

And that was it.  Radio silence from that point forward. 

I went from a new mini-bag subscriber one month to upgrading to the large-bag the following month (for three months).  I placed at least three separate "regular" orders during that time, so I was a multiple-purchase customer.  Heck, I even placed an order with them AFTER I had canceled my subscription (during the Mixed Tape release).  I also referred people to RH through FB and my website.

In my own business, I would have considered someone like myself an ideal customer.

But beyond it taking two weeks-ish for my monthly mystery bags to get from NJ to ATL each month, with not so much as "hey, here's a mini cuticle balm for your trouble!" (when I asked for, and expected, nothing and told them as such - but watched other people on forums getting full-size products for their own delays) . . . . . I also had a regular order that I placed on 6/11 and it did not ship until 6/21.  That was not the USPS's fault.  That was RH's.

I ordered Nail Honey, in addition to other items in that order, and even though it was marked in stock in the store apparently it was not.  I didn't learn that until I wrote them on 6/20 (NINE DAYS after my order) to see if I'd missed a tracking notice and get a status update.  Carolyn said that Nail Honey item had been out of stock, but just came back in, and that she'd contact the warehouse so it would ship that afternoon.  She said I would receive a tracking notice "soon".  Not only did the tracking notice never materialize even after I received the delivery - the shipment wasn't sent off that same day as promised either.  A label wasn't even printed until the next day - and it took 4 more business days to reach me after that.  Once again, no apology - no attempt to make things up whatsoever.  It was what it was.

I've seen more problems with them creeping up lately and it certainly doesn't make me happy -- but it does make me feel less singled out.  I didn't understand why they were just acting that way with what felt like "just me".  I was never rude, never demanding, never had my hands out...  I just wanted my stuff in the same month I ordered it.  I don't think that's too much to ask.  I had to take the initiative to contact them during a backorder, and they expected me to take the initiative and contact the USPS myself for lost shipments.  Ain't nobody got time for that.   ;) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />   Perhaps they just want customers now who don't go through the Kearny to Deep South shipping route.

That all said, I was relieved to see all the pink and fruit items in this month's bag.  Made the blow a little easier to take.  As I've mentioned previously, I think breaking up with a boyfriend in junior high was easier than breaking up with RH.  I was a very sad panda for a few days after...   :unsure:

 
I'm troubled by this because I'm of the mindset that if it's not your fault, you shouldn't apologize and you shouldn't feel the need to. I read comments about people having problems with a company, and my first instinct is to say I'm sorry, but I reel it in, and don't just because it's not my fault, I didn't cause the issue. I'm not trying to belittle your guys' experiences with Rainbow Honey, just trying to explain a different viewpoint that Carolyn possibly shares. In the instance of a problem with USPS, as long as they correctly labeled and sent the package, if it's lost by USPS, it's not Rainbow Honey's fault, and thus why they probably don't apologize for it. I do wish they had tried to make it right for you two, even without an apology, but it sounds like they didn't. It does seem that Carolyn is their only customer service representative, and I have to wonder if they've outgrown their shoes a little, and are just barely keeping up with CS and orders. I have noticed my mystery bags seem to take a little bit longer to ship each month. It sucks that Rainbow Honey lost you wonderful ladies as customers, but I think with every big company some customers fall through the cracks, and aren't properly helped the way they should be.

 
I'm troubled by this because I'm of the mindset that if it's not your fault, you shouldn't apologize and you shouldn't feel the need to. I read comments about people having problems with a company, and my first instinct is to say I'm sorry, but I reel it in, and don't just because it's not my fault, I didn't cause the issue. I'm not trying to belittle your guys' experiences with Rainbow Honey, just trying to explain a different viewpoint that Carolyn possibly shares. In the instance of a problem with USPS, as long as they correctly labeled and sent the package, if it's lost by USPS, it's not Rainbow Honey's fault, and thus why they probably don't apologize for it. I do wish they had tried to make it right for you two, even without an apology, but it sounds like they didn't. It does seem that Carolyn is their only customer service representative, and I have to wonder if they've outgrown their shoes a little, and are just barely keeping up with CS and orders. I have noticed my mystery bags seem to take a little bit longer to ship each month. It sucks that Rainbow Honey lost you wonderful ladies as customers, but I think with every big company some customers fall through the cracks, and aren't properly helped the way they should be.
I don't fault them so much with using USPS as I do acting like it's a new problem each time someone encounters it - and not even entertaining the discussion of different shipment methods (at least for the routes they know are having troubles).  It's kind of the same thing with Julep right now.  Jane's response made it sound like slow delivery is a new growing pains thing with them.  I've been with Julep a year and that's not new news to me.  Companies need to have someone monitoring the pulse of social media as well as the e-mail inbox because if more than one person sees it as a problem, it's a problem.  Fair or not, they take the money and have an end of the bargain to meet.

As mentioned in my previous note, I started off my communication with:  "Just want to start off with - this is in NO WAY your fault.....

I know USPS losing the package for 8-10 days is not their fault.  Telling the customer to go find it -- when all that was needed was a quick phone call as the vendor (her job, or someone's job at RH, IMHO) to the USPS to start a claim.  I didn't expect her to drive to Kearney, dive head first into the package bins, and deliver my envelope on a velvet pillow with golden tassels.  But we went back and forth for a week before she finally did make that call.  And guess what?  Miraculously the same afternoon she made the call, the package was 'found' (still in NJ) and scanned into the system.  It kinda works like that.

I can dig up a recent article on the USPS dealing with California to Hawaii if anyone is interested -- the (anonymous) postal worker in it describes the situation which goes on at most hubs now.  Rather than deliver within windows, they are starting to take a page from DHL's playbook and let the bin fill up -- then process and ship out again.  Of course they are not scanning during this time because they'd have to 'fess up just how long that package was at their facility.

Now where I did have a problem was my normal order.  That was not a USPS issue - that was solely RH's issue and theirs alone.  I did not place it during a special event / promo or big sale.  Just a random "hey I need..." order.

I ordered it on 6/11 and never received anything beyond the initial receipt.  Allowing for USPS delay, I did not contact them about the order until 6/20.  I never received a tracking notice so I had no idea - 9 days later - whether it had even been shipped or not.  Because I have ordered from them several times, I knew that I should have received something by then.  Nothing was marked as backordered or out of stock on the site.  That's when I got an e-mail back saying the Nail Honey was backordered.  [ I would like to note here that this was only the second time I had written RH with an issue.  My previous mystery bag was extremely late but that was resolved rather quickly and easily.  It wasn't like I'd become a 'pest' to them at this point. ]  The other items in my order were not shipped without the Nail Honey.  I wasn't notified it was backordered.  I wasn't notified there would be a shipping delay.  It took me contacting them to even know an issue had existed.  I was told a note would be sent to the warehouse and it would be shipped that day - the Nail Honey had just come back in stock - and a tracking notice would be sent that day.  My order didn't actually have a label created and ship out until over 24 hours later on the following day.  I never did get a tracking notice.  I had to find out the tracking once my order was actually in-hand and I had a number on the package to enter.  After they shipped it off, it only took 4 days to get to me via USPS First Class, which is completely acceptable - especially on the Eastern seaboard.

Had that been the only issue I'd ever had with them, it wouldn't have even been a blip on my radar.  I have enough to deal with - I don't have time to play "Track That Package!" every day.  (Between subs with Julep, Ipsy, and Glossybox sometimes it's just better not to know and be surprised.)  This order was noticed, however, because it was sandwiched in between other missing Mystery Bags.

All that said, subscriptions that go out en masse have a different standard for me.  An actual order from actual stock should receive much more detailed status reports and shipping updates.  That may only be my opinion -- but in cases of actual orders (and not Mystery Bags), I'm not trying to get as much as I can for as little as I can along with 3000 - 300,000 of my closest internet friends.  I am a customer with their company making the orders they need to stay in business.  And there are very few companies online, big / medium / small, that would call it acceptable to never even notify a customer their order was on backorder - and put that burden on the customer to find that fact out on their own (by their own initiative) nine full days later.

I didn't expect an apology from them that the USPS was being a PITA.  I did expect an apology for the backorder-flub.  And that it took them a week to even bother contacting the USPS to locate their package - I feel telling me to do all the work myself, first, deserved an apology.  If you don't, d'ffrent strokes...  They don't have to apologize, that's true.  But it sure goes a long way into keeping a customer loyal (who in the same timeframe racked up over 20,000 Ipsy Points from referrals).

Plus if RH is going good for you, great!  Keep with them and reward them for that.  I'm not trying to tell anyone to stay away or leave.  I'm only not subscribing with them out of principle at this point.  I love their polishes / products!  (I've placed an order since I cancelled my Large Mystery Bag sub.  And will always continue to order or swap for their cuticle balms.)  I just don't feel my treatment deserves a guaranteed monthly payment.  It's the only voice I've got since they didn't even bother really talking to me...

(Made a couple of quick edits because I've been up all night with insomnia.  Sorry, sorry.)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
While I agree you shouldn't have to apologize for things that are outside your realm of responsibility, my complaint was that Carolyn assured me my package would ship on 8/8.  My tracking number I had been given previously, had no updates.  When I followed up with Carolyn, she assured me it shipped as requested and she would follow up on her end. This was on 8/11.  When I didn't hear back from her, and still didn't get a tracking update, I followed up again on 8/16.

She didn't respond until 8/18, which was still acceptable as my email was sent over the weekend (I don't expect companies to respond unless it is during regular business hours.)  She told me it had shipped using the original tracking number I had been monitoring, but was returned due to a missing label.  Tracking does not show it had ever been picked up until yesterday.


USPS Tracking
 

cs-promo.png
Customer Service ›Have questions? We're here to help.
 


Only applicable to visual users. 

Tracking Number: 9400110200828271776058
in-transit
  • Expected Delivery Day: Friday, August 22, 2014


 
Product & Tracking InformationPostal Product:
  • First-Class Package Service
Features:
  • USPS Tracking

DATE & TIME
STATUS OF ITEM
LOCATION
August 19, 2014 , 9:04 pm

Departed USPS Facility

KEARNY, NJ 07099 

 Your item departed our USPS facility in KEARNY, NJ 07099 on August 19, 2014 at 9:04 pm. The item is currently in transit to the destination. Information, if available, is updated periodically throughout the day. Please check again later.
August 19, 2014 , 5:50 pm

Arrived at USPS Origin Facility

KEARNY, NJ 07099 

August 19, 2014 , 4:35 pm

Accepted at USPS Origin Sort Facility

CLIFTON, NJ 07011 

August 5, 2014

Pre-Shipment Info Sent to USPS





ETA:  typo!   :D /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Gah!  That didn't copy the way it was supposed to but you can see pre-shipment was made on 8/5 when the label was created, then nothing until 8/19.

 
Gah!  That didn't copy the way it was supposed to but you can see pre-shipment was made on 8/5 when the label was created, then nothing until 8/19.
Even if it was sent back due to a missing label, there would have been scan information on it. Unless it was the actual shipping label that was missing, which might explain why it was generated on the 5th and no scans until the 18th.

 

Latest posts

Back
Top