Matte nails - yay or nay?

[LoriTG]

Yuck! I only like shiny nails and shiny lips. Sorry.

 

[beautyisme]

so I got the nyc matte topcoat, and always end up using a shiny topcoat over it because matte can be hard to pull off.  However I do like a matte top coat over red polish!

 

[KimberlyP]

Those are gorgeous! I do like matte polishes once in a while.
 

 

[MichelleATX]

Love that manicure! I might try to do that once the kids are back in school. I have just one matte nail polish, China Glaze's Stone Cold, but I'd love to find more. And I just got Orly's matte top coat but haven't used it yet. Anyone know what matte polish they used for the black color in the picture?