So... It has come to my attention that there is no such thing (at least none that I can find) as a directory that lists fandoms and the indie makeup companies that offer themed collections for those fandoms. This is an attempt to fix that. It's also a constant work in progress! If I'm missing something -- either a company or a fandom -- please let me know, and I'll add it. This list is being compiled largely because I'm sure I'm missing things! (I'm specifically excluding Victorian Disco at this time due to turnaround time, though. It's getting into the months for many orders.) Company links under the fandoms will take you directly to the page for the collection.
[and there's a page cut here]
Alice in Wonderland
Anime/manga
Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Angel
A Christmas Carol
A Christmas Story
Comics (Marvel, DC, Boom, etc.)
Doctor Who
Fairy tales
Firefly
Fringe
Game of Thrones
Hannibal
Harry Potter
History
Hunger Games
The IT Crowd
Lord of the Rings/The Hobbit/etc.
Merlin/Arthurian Legend (some might be for the show, some might be based on VERY VERY VERY OLD things. Just covering my bases in advance!)
Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil (oh, *yeah*!)
Music
The Neverending Story
Orange Is the New Black
Princess Bride
Sherlock
Star Trek
Steampunk
Supernatural
Twin Peaks
Video games
The Walking Dead
Wizard of Oz
And a special mention to Espionage Cosmetics for their
nail wraps. They cover such a wide range of geeky interests -- Power Rangers, nebulae, Mystery Science Theatre 3000, many comics, Star Trek -- with this line that I'm just going to point you in their direction.
In addition, Notoriously Morbid has a subscription (well, the first two months, it wasn't a sub, and then Things Happened, and now it's a sub!) called the Vanishing Cabinet that offers a small themed collection each month. So far, they have done collections based on The Craft, Firefly, the works of Neil Gaiman, and the works of Tim Curry. Each one has featured four shadows and a lip product, although the Firefly collection had your choice of nail polish or lip gloss.