Birchbox October 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
:( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I've had two damaged products in the past, and the best they've done was essentially "so sad too bad, here's 50 BB points. cheers!" lol

Originally Posted by SeptEllis /img/forum/go_quote.gif

You should let BB know that perfume leaked and damaged/affected the Mary-Lou. Maybe they can send you a scent-free one. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
 
Originally Posted by americanclassic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

:( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I've had two damaged products in the past, and the best they've done was essentially "so sad too bad, here's 50 BB points. cheers!" lol
I called them today and told them that some product leaked out and that my Caudalie Serum bottle was practically empty. I also mentioned that everything was usable (well, the Caudalie had, like, one application), but they're still shipping me another box. *Greedily hordes tea and Luna Bars while laughing and contemplating much needed sleep. MWAHAHA*

 
Originally Posted by quene8106 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

the vasanti in my september box irritated my skin too and i put down sensitive skin in my profile. i tried it 5x with no other products before i came to that conclusion...
I was super worried about that for my own skin, and almost didn't try the product at all. But I'm glad I did, because it made my extremely sensitive skin baby-soft and didn't irritate at all! I guess everyone has different things that make their skin freak out. I bought a full-size of the Vasanti with my points and am loving it. Hope you find an exfoliator that works for you!

 
Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I called Birchbox today and they're sending me a replacement box because of my basically empty Caudalie Serum and leaked DDF Cleanser. Has anyone had BB send them a replacement box? Did you get a shipping notification? And did you get the same box? Sorry for the multiple questions. 
I got a replacement box last month. I didn't get a shipping notification like I do for the monthly box. Yes it was the same box, but I did get a different color of the hair tie thing.

 
I got my horrible box 30 yesterday. I'm not going to try any of it.  In the 6 boxes I received, I only got one makeup product - the Jouer Birchbox pink lipgloss. (and that was TINY) I did, however, receive all kinds of crap, including tit tape, 2 paperdoll coasters (which promptly went into the recycling bin), a fancy Ziploc bag, Shalimar (I'm in my 30s, not 80s).....I bought into their service because I wanted to try makeup, not coasters.

I did cancel my account, but I'm just so angry that I never received any color. Has anyone else had that problem?

 
Originally Posted by gemstone /img/forum/go_quote.gif

My box just arrived and I am pretty happy with it.  I got box 16.




I have seen people complain about the size of the jouer lip treatment, but I have one I got from jouer about a month ago and i have used it almost every day and it is about half full now.  I don't know if it is just me but lip products always last me a very long time, and I usually end up losing it before it runs out (this includes chapstick, lipstick etc.)

Also, the malin+goetz cleanser is listed as a "beauty extra"

We are box twins! As they say. lol  I was content with this months products.  I received the same color Essie and used the lip treatment right away. The Tea bags go to my mom and I like the Malin + Goetz I am interested in "trying" Since that's what this is all about. As far a favored products I have had more luck with Myglam and Glossybox for sure.
 
I received my box (#2) yesterday and I am so happy with it - might be my best birchbox ever!



The sample sizes are all really nice.  The serum can't be closed after it's open, but I decanted it into a little jar so hopefully I will be able to try it a few times without it getting everywhere (thankful to girls on here for the tip!).  The Essie is "Carry On" - the color is a beautiful plum, great for fall and perfect addition to my nail polish collection.  Body oil & lip balm smell good, and I'm looking forward to the Lunabar.  Overall, I'm completely pleased with this box!
I'm really curious though about the nail polish color in my box photo... It looks pretty and I'm wondering what shade it might be!  It looks like kind of a greige or greyish taupe color?  Any guesses?  Sorry the picture is so tiny, but my big box photo is just a plain box without the products.

700

 
Originally Posted by gracewilson /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I received my box (#2) yesterday and I am so happy with it - might be my best birchbox ever!




The sample sizes are all really nice.  The serum can't be closed after it's open, but I decanted it into a little jar so hopefully I will be able to try it a few times without it getting everywhere (thankful to girls on here for the tip!).  The Essie is "Carry On" - the color is a beautiful plum, great for fall and perfect addition to my nail polish collection.  Body oil & lip balm smell good, and I'm looking forward to the Lunabar.  Overall, I'm completely pleased with this box!
I'm really curious though about the nail polish color in my box photo... It looks pretty and I'm wondering what shade it might be!  It looks like kind of a greige or greyish taupe color?  Any guesses?  Sorry the picture is so tiny, but my big box photo is just a plain box without the products.

700

I got the same box as you! I am happy with my nail polish color, although I just bought this season's "recessionista" and two colors are very similar.  I think the color pictured on the website is "master plan."  It's too bad that Birchbox seems to be out of all the nail polish colors!
 
Originally Posted by dotybird /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got the same box as you! I am happy with my nail polish color, although I just bought this season's "recessionista" and two colors are very similar.  I think the color pictured on the website is "master plan."  It's too bad that Birchbox seems to be out of all the nail polish colors!
I was thinking maybe its master plan also.  I googled recessionista - so pretty!  I think we have similar tastes.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />  I just got the rose gold color club in the mail (traded it for my neon yellow) and added french tips with it to the carry on I did my nails with last night.  I think I might have branched out past my skill level (its a little wobbly), but it's a pretty combination!  Maybe I'll do an accent nail next time, sounds a bit easier.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
The outside box was a goop one but the brown box is the same with goop tissue.

Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Did people who got box 3 get a cute goop box, or is it kind of plain? Because the plain box is showing in the preview pictures...
 
Received my BB #1 yesterday - totally dig it and, God help me, I also really liked the Luna Bar. IT WAS GOOD, I swear! I used the serum last night and very much enjoyed it, etc etc. However, when I received my Birchbox yesterday there was a distinct lack of 'YES! BB!'. I don't know, I think the glow has worn off and from what I gather, I'm not the only one.

 
I got a MOX lip butter in my box.. but it was unscrewed and had a small red dot and a fuzzy in it... I emailed them but idk what they will do about it.  Did this happen to anyone else?

 
Originally Posted by MandyLeigh /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Ladies,

I joined just becuase I am so ticked off I had to run somewhere and express it. I've been a long time lurker so I of course ran into the arms of you girls who would understand. I read these threads and felt the anticipation you did while we waited for our boxes.

I actually clicked the link in my e-mail to get the Goop box but it told me I was too late (I just got the e-mail) I couldn't have it.

No biggie, it's the surprise, the new products THAT'S the whole point. I was fine.

When this box arrived I was excited. I got the Goop box! Woohoo.....right? This was my face when I opened it.
wassatt.gif
What. The. Heck. The paper in the box told me how wonderful this opportunity was. I saw blogs and news reports all over about this and how great it would be.

ARE THESE PEOPLE KIDDING? Is BirchBox even paying attention to us?

I don't know what number my Goop box would be but some of what I got I already received before!

A microscopic tube of lip product.

A tiny tub of yet another eye cream that is just one part of a set of stuff

A tiny bottle of oil Birch Box already sent me and it didn't cover half my head the first time. 

A Foil packet of skin Transformer that again I already received.

And a Luna bar I can't eat becuase of reasons I won't boar you with and it doesn't matter.

This is what blogs, news reports and Goop and Birchbox has been so excited about? Stuff they already sent and that?

I really don't mean to be over dramatic here but, it's like a slap in the face. I'm tired of receiving the same stuff over and over..... I could fill up a full bottle of Juicy Couture with the amount of samples of the perfume I have received. The EXACT same scent. Repeats of foil packets and on and on.

I greatly apologize and I also thank you for allowing me to express this here.

What is the best way to get their attention with this? E-mail then? Can I really return this an get my money back?

Seriously this wasn't just disapointment, it's this is a slap in the face wrapped in purple tissue paper.
Do you have multiple subscriptions? Because you're not supposed to receive repeat samples for the same subscription. I don't understand how you've received so many of the same perfumes and foil packets with just one subscription. Can you post a screenshot of your box history that shows all the repeated samples? You should contact them to let them know and they will compensate you since it is their policy to not send repeats.

 
Originally Posted by quene8106 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

did anyone see that instagram pic on the bb account with the chicken on it? someone called out bb for having a birthday party when tons of unhappy subscribers were calling and only getting vmails. whoever runs that bb instagram set that customer straight lol 
I don't have instagram, can you explain this??

 
Originally Posted by Kristin1387 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got a MOX lip butter in my box.. but it was unscrewed and had a small red dot and a fuzzy in it... I emailed them but idk what they will do about it.  Did this happen to anyone else?
This happened to me too... wasn't sure if I should email them or not, so I haven't since I'm sure they're being bombarded with plenty of complaint emails this month. Please let me know if they respond!

 
Originally Posted by katie danielle /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Do you have multiple subscriptions? Because you're not supposed to receive repeat samples for the same subscription. I don't understand how you've received so many of the same perfumes and foil packets with just one subscription. Can you post a screenshot of your box history that shows all the repeated samples? You should contact them to let them know and they will compensate you since it is their policy to not send repeats.
I have received duplicate items myself - specifically the Twistband - so it wouldn't surprise me if others were getting repeats on their main accounts.

 
Originally Posted by macadamia522 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


This happened to me too... wasn't sure if I should email them or not, so I haven't since I'm sure they're being bombarded with plenty of complaint emails this month. Please let me know if they respond!
I will! 

 
Originally Posted by zadidoll /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I have received duplicate items myself - specifically the Twistband - so it wouldn't surprise me if others were getting repeats on their main accounts.
I understand that, but to the extreme she indicated? And Birchbox said to some people that the twistband wasn't considered a duplicate since it was the lace pattern instead of the plain pattern (which doesn't make sense), but she said she has received the same hair oil, face serums, foil packets, and perfumes over and over again.

 
Originally Posted by zadidoll /img/forum/go_quote.gif


I have received duplicate items myself - specifically the Twistband - so it wouldn't surprise me if others were getting repeats on their main accounts.
I thought I had gotten a repeat of that, but it turns out the first time I got an Alex & Isabella hair tie, which just happens to be exactly the same.

 

Latest posts

Back
Top