Birchbox October 2012

[jannie135]

Originally Posted by tulippop /img/forum/go_quote.gif

well I found pictures of box #3 on someone's site and the sample sizes are really disappointing. 

naked princess lipgloss..... 2 of these paper/foil samples



embryolisse



the hair powder....



There's also a luna bar and 1 face mask
My mom was really looking forward to this box but the samples are tiny!  I may switch boxes with her if mine is any better (since I'm getting 2 of the same one). 

I like the variety of samples (which hasn't really been true lately with BB reusing the same brands/items over and over again like tili, luna, jouer) and I love the point/rewards system but these sample sizes are kind of ridiculous.  It's not as bad as the flower/lipgloss I've been seeing but it's enough of a reason to cancel if this is their going to be their M.O. 

Getting fullsized items is great but not expected.  I don't expect any particular item or brand but what I do expect are samples that are big enough to actually try and use a few times to get a feel for the product.  A lot of the sizes I've been seeing for this month are not it.  Nothing here feels deluxe.  Sorry for the rant but BB just didn't make it work this month for us.

Images from http://www.hellocotton.com/to/eWPc#http://someblissfulchaos.blogspot.com/2012/10/october-birchbox.html - Not my blog

Great. Maybe my box will get lost in the mail and they'll reassign a new one for me. *fingers crossed*

 

[queenofperil]

Originally Posted by MyriadVoices /img/forum/go_quote.gif

(although I don't personally find that to be as emotionally-charged as many seem to).

This made me laugh. I remember when I worked at Bath and Body Works, I'd always have at least one customer come up to the counter and witch about something like how expensive everything was, or some other dissatisfaction. Funny thing was, they'd say this while they continued to buy stuff. It's not the same situation here (well, not in every case), but it always baffled me that people would still put money in the pocket of the very company they were complaining about. 

 

[jannie135]

Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif


This made me laugh. I remember when I worked at Bath and Body Works, I'd always have at least one customer come up to the counter and witch about something like how expensive everything was, or some other dissatisfaction. Funny thing was, they'd say this while they continued to buy stuff. It's not the same situation here (well, not in every case), but it always baffled me that people would still put money in the pocket of the very company they were complaining about. 

LoL I know what you mean!!!! I work at Godiva... overpriced chocolate. You should hear people complain about our prices. I have to smile and put up with it, when I just wanna say, "SORRY BUT I DON'T CARE! I'M NOT MAKING YOU BUY IT! IF IT'S SO MUCH CHEAPER TO MAKE IT YOURSELF I'M NOT GOING TO STOP YOU!!!!!!"

I hate retail /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[tulippop]

Originally Posted by jannie135 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


LoL I know what you mean!!!! I work at Godiva... overpriced chocolate. You should hear people complain about our prices. I have to smile and put up with it, when I just wanna say, "SORRY BUT I DON'T CARE! I'M NOT MAKING YOU BUY IT! IF IT'S SO MUCH CHEAPER TO MAKE IT YOURSELF I'M NOT GOING TO STOP YOU!!!!!!"

I hate retail /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

ditto and I've been applying for retail jobs for the holidays.  At least it's pretty mindless work. 

 

[jannie135]

I think my box is being delivered by a drunk turtle.

 

[theredwonder]

Yeah I was a bit miffed with this as I got my shipping notice on Wednesday, it didn't ship until Friday, and I've gotten the hair powder sample before. I DMed @BirchboxOps on twitter, and they said I'll hear from them tomorrow. I'll post here what happens!

I emailed them a few days ago about my repeat hair powder sample and I got a reply saying they were sorry, aware of the problem, and will be sending out a message and awarding 100 points to those affected soon.

 

[l0ser_dust]

This isn't necessarily a complaint per se... But when I got back from a weekend away and saw the Essie color in my BB, I kind of had to LOL. This isn't a complaint but more of a constructive criticism I will tell them that I really wish they would go by! Please please please at least check what shades polishes you're sending out to us! I honestly don't know what I will do with another minty foam green or blackish grey lol... Keep in mind this pic doesn't do justice to the similarities haha... Polishes pictured are all polishes I've ever gotten from BB 

 Just semi annoyed even though I know that this is all a gamble because in my mind that's a possibility of so many other nail polish colors I could have tried out and fallen in love with... I thought the whole point was to sample out products to introduce us to new things! 

 

[queenofperil]

Originally Posted by l0ser_dust /img/forum/go_quote.gif

This isn't necessarily a complaint per se... But when I got back from a weekend away and saw the Essie color in my BB, I kind of had to LOL. This isn't a complaint but more of a constructive criticism I will tell them that I really wish they would go by! Please please please at least check what shades polishes you're sending out to us! I honestly don't know what I will do with another minty foam green or blackish grey lol... Keep in mind this pic doesn't do justice to the similarities haha... Polishes pictured are all polishes I've ever gotten from BB 

 Just semi annoyed even though I know that this is all a gamble because in my mind that's a possibility of so many other nail polish colors I could have tried out and fallen in love with... I thought the whole point was to sample out products to introduce us to new things! 

Even though you're not complaining, and I actually think this is a valid point, it made me laugh. I could never say anything about Birchbox in this regard because if they saw the amount of freaking neutral brownish eyeshadows I own, they'd tell me to shut the hell up. I swear, I'm on some mission to own every neutral between off-white and dark brown that is currently in creation, and I don't even know why. 

 

[MissLindaJean]

This isn't necessarily a complaint per se... But when I got back from a weekend away and saw the Essie color in my BB, I kind of had to LOL. This isn't a complaint but more of a constructive criticism I will tell them that I really wish they would go by! Please please please at least check what shades polishes you're sending out to us! I honestly don't know what I will do with another minty foam green or blackish grey lol... Keep in mind this pic doesn't do justice to the similarities haha... Polishes pictured are all polishes I've ever gotten from BB  :blink:  Just semi annoyed even though I know that this is all a gamble because in my mind that's a possibility of so many other nail polish colors I could have tried out and fallen in love with... I thought the whole point was to sample out products to introduce us to new things! 

Like those blues lol. Yes, the color variety could be better, but I think partly luck of the draw lol. I've gotten the blue Ming, aqua whatever shade, gold, rose gold, and grey. I'm ready for a purple or glittery green. Holos and duochromes would greatly please me, too. /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[l0ser_dust]

Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Even though you're not complaining, and I actually think this is a valid point, it made me laugh. I could never say anything about Birchbox in this regard because if they saw the amount of freaking neutral brownish eyeshadows I own, they'd tell me to shut the hell up. I swear, I'm on some mission to own every neutral between off-white and dark brown that is currently in creation, and I don't even know why. 

haha I can totally picture that! You can probably plan out the Naked 3 palette with your collection... And 4,5,6 

 

[queenofperil]

Originally Posted by l0ser_dust /img/forum/go_quote.gif

haha I can totally picture that! You can probably plan out the Naked 3 palette with your collection... And 4,5,6 

With any luck, I'll get Christmas monies to spend on MOAR BROWN SHADOW. Seriously, the Sonia Kashuk Eye on Neutral Palette is something I need desperately in my life. 

 

[MyriadVoices]

Originally Posted by jannie135 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


LoL I know what you mean!!!! I work at Godiva... overpriced chocolate. You should hear people complain about our prices. I have to smile and put up with it, when I just wanna say, "SORRY BUT I DON'T CARE! I'M NOT MAKING YOU BUY IT! IF IT'S SO MUCH CHEAPER TO MAKE IT YOURSELF I'M NOT GOING TO STOP YOU!!!!!!"

I hate retail /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

HAHHAAH yes.

I did work retail for about 8 years while in hs and college. I have said it many times, but I think everyone should have to do a year in retail and/or restaurants. I think it might encourage the world to be a better place. /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[Missglammygirl]

Originally Posted by jannie135 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I think my box is being delivered by a drunk turtle.

LOL! mine too!

 

[MyriadVoices]

Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I swear, I'm on some mission to own every neutral between off-white and dark brown that is currently in creation, and I don't even know why. 

TOTALLY the same way!!! Also guilty of the same thing for nude polishes, although not quite as badly as with the shadows...

Originally Posted by l0ser_dust /img/forum/go_quote.gif

This isn't necessarily a complaint per se... But when I got back from a weekend away and saw the Essie color in my BB, I kind of had to LOL. This isn't a complaint but more of a constructive criticism I will tell them that I really wish they would go by! Please please please at least check what shades polishes you're sending out to us! I honestly don't know what I will do with another minty foam green or blackish grey lol... Keep in mind this pic doesn't do justice to the similarities haha... Polishes pictured are all polishes I've ever gotten from BB 

 Just semi annoyed even though I know that this is all a gamble because in my mind that's a possibility of so many other nail polish colors I could have tried out and fallen in love with... I thought the whole point was to sample out products to introduce us to new things! 

HA! Maybe they are trying to tell you something (don't know what...)? That is too funny. It does make me more thankful that all the polishes I've gotten from BB have been different, at least!

 

[gypsiemagic]

Originally Posted by Dena Fletcher /img/forum/go_quote.gif

i want to try it! i am on the wait list w/bb.. you made those twistbands?  with what? i LOVE them!

yes i did! super simple once you have all the supplies /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> 

5/8" fold over elastic

scissors

lighter (to seal the ends from fraying, you want to melt, not burn, so use a light hand)

alternative methods to seal the ends are clear nail polish or no-fray product

 

[Dena Fletcher]

Originally Posted by gypsiemagic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

yes i did! super simple once you have all the supplies /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> 

5/8" fold over elastic

scissors

lighter (to seal the ends from fraying, you want to melt, not burn, so use a light hand)

alternative methods to seal the ends are clear nail polish or no-fray product

love love LOVE!!!  i got one many months ago and shelled out $12 for a 6 pack! granted they have lasted me.. and the washing machine method helps, but still! i want more color options.. (oh and ps.. did you get one of the lace printed ones in a bb? they have no elasticity! mine stretched, and stayed that way after one use! boooooooooooo.. and to think i almost bough those.. )

 

[Dena Fletcher]

Originally Posted by l0ser_dust /img/forum/go_quote.gif

This isn't necessarily a complaint per se... But when I got back from a weekend away and saw the Essie color in my BB, I kind of had to LOL. This isn't a complaint but more of a constructive criticism I will tell them that I really wish they would go by! Please please please at least check what shades polishes you're sending out to us! I honestly don't know what I will do with another minty foam green or blackish grey lol... Keep in mind this pic doesn't do justice to the similarities haha... Polishes pictured are all polishes I've ever gotten from BB 

 Just semi annoyed even though I know that this is all a gamble because in my mind that's a possibility of so many other nail polish colors I could have tried out and fallen in love with... I thought the whole point was to sample out products to introduce us to new things! 

hmmmmmm.. the lend to a certain color family i see...  a good one.. but still.............

 

[calexxia]

Odd, the polishes I've gotten from BB don't seem to have a common thread: I got a greyish Zoya, a gold glitter Essie, a rose gold Color Club, whatever Essie shade is in this month's box, a pink Color Club...

 

[jannie135]

Originally Posted by MyriadVoices /img/forum/go_quote.gif


HAHHAAH yes.

I did work retail for about 8 years while in hs and college. I have said it many times, but I think everyone should have to do a year in retail and/or restaurants. I think it might encourage the world to be a better place. /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

OMG I've said the same thing to my friends!!! Great minds think alike!! LoL.

I'm glad you were able to move up in the world.

Holiday season is going to kill me. I've lost my tolerance for annoying people. Especially annoying people with awful hyper children. And annoying parents who are too busy picking out chocolates to notice their kid is licking the display case that I have to clean from one end to the other. x_x

Hopefully my post turtle will sober up and head in my direction soon...

 

[meetcutecrystal]

Has anyone seen a sample size of the Lucy B Roll on Perfume? I haven't seen it on YouTube or Google, at least I don't think I have. I am debating a trade.