Birchbox October 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Anyone remember if people got the Sprout balm in flavors other than Cocoa? I opened it up to smell and realized they meant chocolate cocoa and not coco as in coconut. Would love to trade (i just smelled it, it's completely unused) if there are other scents floating around. 

 
Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got my box today! Unfortunately, my Caudalie Serum suffered the same "almost all air" fate as others, and a bit of my DDF Cleanser leaked out. And I just took my first bite of the Luna Bar. This thing's tasty. I'm a fatty, though, so I don't mind getting these. All in all, not my favorite box, but it's not the complete failure I originally whined about. I'm mad at myself for my initial reaction. 

I could eat several more of these Luna Bars, haha. Oh, and for those wondering, in case it hasn't been posted, the DDF Cleanser is 4.5 ounces, and the scent is totally not as bad as I thought. Anise/black licorice makes me want to gag, so I didn't have much hope, but the scent the cleanser has is really mild. 
i liked my luna bars too. i didn't like their chocolate ones but i sure did like this lemon one...someone on facebook complained that they were full of sugar and carbs and i couldn't help but think about regina george eating those swedish bars in mean girls, lmao

 
My box supposedly went from New York to New Jersey to Orlando and then back up to Jacksonville...i live halfway between Orlando and Jacksonville...they could have just thrown it in my yard on its way back up....I'm suppose to be getting the dreaded punishment box,#12.
 

 
Upon usage, I don't care that the Per-fekt Gel was a tiny sample. It did me absolutely zero favors. At least the spearmint taste is nice.

 
I got box #31 last night.  I got 2 of the Mox lip balm samples.  Not sure if that was intentional or not.  

Box #31



The supergoop samples are tiny.  Protein bar sounds disgusting.  The Mox stuff smells nice, but it seems to be leaving my lips more chapped than before.  I'll use the MaryLou, but I just got it at the sample stop so it's definitely not exciting.  Underwhelming.
 
i liked my luna bars too. i didn't like their chocolate ones but i sure did like this lemon one...someone on facebook complained that they were full of sugar and carbs and i couldn't help but think about regina george eating those swedish bars in mean girls, lmao
HAHAHAHA I love when all of her clothes stop fitting, cracks me up every time!
 
do you guys complain to BB when the product is all air? last month with my Dr Jart BB cream, I just barely had enough to put on my face once. it's just wasteful/unresourceful to make plastic tubes when the same amt of product could fit in a tiny foil packet.

Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got my box today! Unfortunately, my Caudalie Serum suffered the same "almost all air" fate as others, and a bit of my DDF Cleanser leaked out. And I just took my first bite of the Luna Bar. This thing's tasty. I'm a fatty, though, so I don't mind getting these. All in all, not my favorite box, but it's not the complete failure I originally whined about. I'm mad at myself for my initial reaction. 

I think I have your box, I just haven't gotten it yet. it's an aight box, I've had a lot worse, but these aren't products I'm interested in. my BB profile says 'latest makeup color', and aside from a couple lip products and nail polishes, I haven't really gotten any makeup. I'd love to test the beauty blender, or a dry shampoo, or an essie nailpolish, just as I'm sure someone else would prefer a cleanser and some more lip balm. if next month's box doesn't wow me, I think I'll unsub from BB again. I might as well just see if I like anything in the boxes, and try it out myself instead of spending $10 on empty tubes and cheap protein bars.

 
i liked my luna bars too. i didn't like their chocolate ones but i sure did like this lemon one...someone on facebook complained that they were full of sugar and carbs and i couldn't help but think about regina george eating those swedish bars in mean girls, lmao
Haha Kalteen bars! I have been loving the lemon zest Luna bars for years (bummed I'm getting chocolate raz in my box blech!)okay yeah they have sugar and carbs in them but if you are craving something sweet they are better than say, a candy bar from the vending machine.
 
Originally Posted by lovestarbrooke /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Haha Kalteen bars! I have been loving the lemon zest Luna bars for years (bummed I'm getting chocolate raz in my box blech!)okay yeah they have sugar and carbs in them but if you are craving something sweet they are better than say, a candy bar from the vending machine.
I would rather get a lemon one but hey i guess free is free lol

 
Originally Posted by brio444 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got box #31 last night.  I got 2 of the Mox lip balm samples.  Not sure if that was intentional or not.  


Box #31



The supergoop samples are tiny.  Protein bar sounds disgusting.  The Mox stuff smells nice, but it seems to be leaving my lips more chapped than before.  I'll use the MaryLou, but I just got it at the sample stop so it's definitely not exciting.  Underwhelming
Doubt it was intentional . I guess look as it as a bonus or bounty for trading. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
 
Originally Posted by americanclassic /img/forum/go_quote.gif

do you guys complain to BB when the product is all air? last month with my Dr Jart BB cream, I just barely had enough to put on my face once. it's just wasteful/unresourceful to make plastic tubes when the same amt of product could fit in a tiny foil packet.

I think I have your box, I just haven't gotten it yet. it's an aight box, I've had a lot worse, but these aren't products I'm interested in. my BB profile says 'latest makeup color', and aside from a couple lip products and nail polishes, I haven't really gotten any makeup. I'd love to test the beauty blender, or a dry shampoo, or an essie nailpolish, just as I'm sure someone else would prefer a cleanser and some more lip balm. if next month's box doesn't wow me, I think I'll unsub from BB again. I might as well just see if I like anything in the boxes, and try it out myself instead of spending $10 on empty tubes and cheap protein bars.
I sent them an email letting them know. They need feedback to improve, right? 

My profile also says "latest makeup color," but I'm never really disappointed. I could end up finding a holy grail product in another category this way. To each their own, though.

 
Originally Posted by Lisa N /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I don't know about some of this. I doubt the Joliebox had much to do with it, they bought the company but I'm sure it's probably being run by the same people and isn't being operated by BB NY. And you have to think, BB has people who's specific job it is to get samples from companies, some who do events like Sample Stop, and the other events like they did over the summer. It's not like everyone at BB focuses on each thing going on, or that Katia is stuffing boxes. As far as not seeing Essie yet, that wave probably just shipped later. I'm getting Essie, got the email weds, still no update. I deal with shipping at work. Once it's on a truck, they consider it shipped, but UPSMI may not unload the truck for days. It's free shipping, I'll get it when I get it. I don't really understand why people are mad this month.
ermm... I am positive that when a company buys another company, there are a lot of changes that get made. I basically live in the start up world of Silicon Valley / SF, and nobody buys a company and just lets it function autonomously. Birchbox is still a start-up, and at start-ups everybody is thinking of more than one thing at a time. And I am well aware that Birchbox does not pack their boxes themselves, they contract with a third party company to put the boxes together, so no actualy Birchbox employee ever touches the boxes. 

I am speaking more on the company level, there is no press about wether the executive team at jolie box wanted to sell it to take their money and leave, or if there was a clause in the acquisition to keep their vesting on for additional years to entice them to keep on working. It really could have gone either way, companies don't get bought my other start-ups unless they are sure they themselves can't make the company huge. 

Maybe a lot of birchbox thought and energy was spent in other places this month. It won't ever be confirmed if something went wrong so we can never know one way or the other.

Personally the people who get angry at this stuff are so amusing. I have SO many other things to think about and focus my time and energy on, that if something ships late, I hardly even notice. I keep a little calendar on my wall that reminds me when the boxes charge my card and when they claim to ship. ALSO my boxes all get shipped to my boyfriends apartment because their package handling procedure are a lot more secure than mine, so I don't get to get them until the weekend regardless of when they actually get there, so wether it comes monday or thursday night, no difference to me. 

Originally Posted by gemstone /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Birchbox has also grown a TON in the past few months + is a bigger company than ipsy.  I was just putting this out there as a possibility, but you can continue to fret about it and be rude to someone has an explanation you don't WANT to believe. Personally, I would rather think that there is a good reason than immediately assume the worst (hello all of the people that were convinced box 1 was going to have 2 items?) 
Birchbox has like 100 times the subscribers of Myglam. and people are so quick to forget all the crap that myglam pulled. Freeman mask, Mall Kiosk skin samples... Fake WEN, 10 cent cheap ass china brushes, the nasty nail decals. There are bumps along the way! sheesh.

I still can't believe there was anybody who legitimately believed that because there were only two items listed that that was all they were getting. harhahahha

Originally Posted by dd62 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

There is a picture of box 1 on instgram. I cant wait to get mine!
YES! Big sample of the body wash :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I thought I wanted a big lipgloss, but I counted how many lipglosses I have... i am embarassed... I have much less body wash. (Also Leesha/XSparkage did a whole series on these kheils products, so I have wanted to try them) I want more pictures to show up so I can see what colors of nail polish are going out and wether they are tied to a box or not. 

 
Originally Posted by gypsiemagic /img/forum/go_quote.gifBirchbox has like 100 times the subscribers of Myglam. and people are so quick to forget all the crap that myglam pulled. Freeman mask, Mall Kiosk skin samples... Fake WEN, 10 cent cheap ass china brushes, the nasty nail decals. There are bumps along the way! sheesh.
Can you explain everything but the brushes from China, or give me a link? I only knew of the ordering cheap crap in bulk from China issue, and I've heard that some things had a funny smell. I do not trust Michelle Phan.

 
Originally Posted by gemstone /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Birchbox has also grown a TON in the past few months + is a bigger company than ipsy.  I was just putting this out there as a possibility, but you can continue to fret about it and be rude to someone has an explanation you don't WANT to believe. Personally, I would rather think that there is a good reason than immediately assume the worst (hello all of the people that were convinced box 1 was going to have 2 items?) 
i'm not assuming the worst? i never said 'omg i'm not going to get my box ever omg.' i said i don't appreciate how bad birchbox's shipping has gotten. your alternative explanations are a great defense but can you really deny that there are any problems with their shipping when they've been handing out points to people to make up for it?

yeah birchbox has grown a lot and taken on a lot in the last few months, but why should customers have to suffer just because they bit off more than they can chew.

if you're happy with your service, as it seems you are by your constant defending of any fault that is mentioned about birchbox, then good for you. but i think the beauty box industry has gotten too competitive and vast to settle for second rate service (which is what i have seen some getting, not all).

 
Originally Posted by queenofperil /img/forum/go_quote.gif


Can you explain everything but the brushes from China, or give me a link? I only knew of the ordering cheap crap in bulk from China issue, and I've heard that some things had a funny smell. I do not trust Michelle Phan.
There are apparently a couple of different formulations of WEN. The one in the Glambag was the less-expensive one. The nail decals were, IIRC, just some no-name brand and were very poor quality. The brushes, you already know about. The Mall Kiosk samples was foil packets of the Dead Sea Minerals stuff that is so invasively marketed via mall kiosks. Freeman, there were several different variety sachets that were supposedly planned to be shipped in ONE month, but they got split up over multiple months, not to mention that even full-size Freeman (which I happen to like) is a very inexpensive product. Since the first Glambag had been filled with prestige brands, people were really irritated to receive drugstore-level items (and worse, IMHO, with the mall kiosk stuff). Of course, there was also the tempest in a teapot over relabeled tubes, but people were legitimately pissed that the actual product IN them was something that is only available as a GWP with Pro-Activ, rather than being an item available for purchase. 

 
also, I'm not as mad about the lara/luna bars but this does annoy me: how come the men's box has a fancy drink measure and whisky stones as lifestyle extras, and our extras are "lady food bars"? I think that's a bit insulting. I know they pay more for the box, but people wouldn't mind...I don't know, something other than snack/meal bars? I know the coasters were lame, but at least everyone uses coasters.

 
Originally Posted by calexxia /img/forum/go_quote.gif

There are apparently a couple of different formulations of WEN. The one in the Glambag was the less-expensive one. The nail decals were, IIRC, just some no-name brand and were very poor quality. The brushes, you already know about. The Mall Kiosk samples was foil packets of the Dead Sea Minerals stuff that is so invasively marketed via mall kiosks. Freeman, there were several different variety sachets that were supposedly planned to be shipped in ONE month, but they got split up over multiple months, not to mention that even full-size Freeman (which I happen to like) is a very inexpensive product. Since the first Glambag had been filled with prestige brands, people were really irritated to receive drugstore-level items (and worse, IMHO, with the mall kiosk stuff). Of course, there was also the tempest in a teapot over relabeled tubes, but people were legitimately pissed that the actual product IN them was something that is only available as a GWP with Pro-Activ, rather than being an item available for purchase. 
Ah, okay. I tried to Google the controversies, but I got uninformative results. 

 

Latest posts

Back
Top