PopSugar Special Edition Fall 2014

Advertise with us
Shop deals on ebay
Current body
Jeffreestar cosmetics
Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
It's always interesting to see the initial reactions to box spoilers.   I'm actually OK with everything in the box except for the gummy bears (it seems weird to put a $6 bag of candies in a $100 box. . .we've had more expensive treats in the regular monthly box) and possibly the scarf.  

I agree with other commenters who would have loved to see a wallet or piece of jewelry.  I haven't liked any of the perfumes PS has sent us and this one seems to be a bit 'edgy' given that it was inspired by a lap dance (I mean. . huh!?).  Indie Lee is a great company with quality products, so I'll enjoy the cleanser.   My beef with the scarf is that it's so predictable and we're getting one in the monthly box, plus the pattern on this one looks a bit hmm. . 1990s Talbots, perhaps?  I hope it's one of those "pictures don't do it justice" items. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
I'm so excited for this box! I am very happy with all the contents. I have to patiently wait to get it into my hands to really know. I was so disappointed with the Summer box until I had it in my hands, then loved everything. I love everything here, so I hope it doesn't disappoint in person.

Also, I can't wait to smell like sweat and semen!

 
I think the gummies are a bit weird .. but then I think the idea of the box is fall and style .. it's but just a seasonal box. And the gummies seem to fit that ...

Living in a warm climate makes it unwise getting fall or holiday boxes, but so far it was one item like a scarf and then the rest were more neutral .. like peppermint pretzel for the holidays which you can enjoy in Florida just as well as in N.Y. This time, the two big items of the box are both things that are cold weather items .. which to me is not well planned (especially with another scarf coming in the Sept box). It makes me wonder if I shOuld refrain from future purchases of fall/holiday boxes. One item to trade or gift is fine .. the two most valuable items not all that usable for idk .. 30-40% of the recipients .. not ideal.

Anyways .. we're hoping to move back to an all seasons region soon and I'll just wait till then to wear all the scarves etc. Though I do believe they should think about whether they want to offer boxes for the entire country or just parts.

 
I think this box looks great! I was looking forward a home item though.  Hopefully the perfume smells better than the description sounds.  I am ready to see pictures of people's boxes.

 
I wish someone had pictures of the box! I"m also curious what the scarf fabric and dimensions are...

 
My main problem with the LE boxes is that they don't usually seem to have enough in them to make them worth so much more than the regular PS boxes. This box seems like it just has a scarf and hat instead of just a scarf. Not really worth an extra $60 to me.

 
I do wish the lipstick was a different brand though... YSL, Chanel, even Urban Decay/Smashbox would have done the trick.

I've decided Fall LE boxes will be the only LE boxes I purchase.. maybe the holiday one as well.

Yeah, I agree, it feels like something is missing. The clutch or a throw blanket would've been nice. I was really hoping for the blanket though.

 
This box will be a lesson to my self-restraint.  I gave in when I clearly shouldn't have.  Between this box and the September box I'll be up to a whopping SIX scarves from these guys.  That's a bit absurd.  

As for the hat, I really despise beanies -- between my large head and curly hair they have disaster written all over them.  But even that aside, how much of the country actually needs/wears a beanie in the fall (or winter for that matter)?  (I live in Atlanta and even through our most recent sno-mageddon, I didn't need a winter hat.) Granted I would expect something like that in a winter box regardless of where I live.  I just don't think it's appropriate for a fall box.

Arggh, I'd be mad at popsugar, but I'm really mad at myself.  I think I knew on some level that this box would be a letdown.  (Why else would they wait SO long to send out a hint and then send out one that was so vague?)  

Ok, my rant is done.  If anyone wants that scarf and/or hat and/or really anything else that's in this box (or heck, the entire box), send me a message.  It's not scheduled to arrive here until the 11th, but I can have it on your way shortly thereafter.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I received mine today. Here's a pic:

image.jpg

The scarf is 100% viscose, the hat is too big and that's coming from someone with curly voluminous hair, the perfume is stick sweet and is hurting throat from the sample I sprayed on my hand. The face wash, candy and lipstick are good though. This just doesn't feel like a fall box, more like a random extra expensive monthly box.

 
ladyrox said:
This box will be a lesson to my self-restraint.  I gave in when I clearly shouldn't have.  Between this box and the September box I'll be up to a whopping SIX scarves from these guys.  That's a bit absurd.  

As for the hat, I really despise beanies -- between my large head and curly hair they have disaster written all over them.  But even that aside, how much of the country actually needs/wears a beanie in the fall (or winter for that matter)?  (I live in Atlanta and even through our most recent sno-mageddon, I didn't need a winter hat.) Granted I would expect something like that in a winter box regardless of where I live.  I just don't think it's appropriate for a fall box.

Arggh, I'd be mad at popsugar, but I'm really mad at myself.  I think I knew on some level that this box would be a letdown.  (Why else would they wait SO long to send out a hint and then send out one that was so vague?)  

Ok, my rant is done.  If anyone wants that scarf and/or hat and/or really anything else that's in this box (or heck, the entire box), send me a message.  It's not scheduled to arrive here until the 11th, but I can have it on your way shortly thereafter.
Click to expand...
I agree. It is wintery to me. I expected a scarf, but a scarf and a hat? I definitely feel like I wasted $100 and I'm also annoyed at myself.

 
Count me in as disappointed.  I thought I had seen PopSugar itself advertise for their Fall box by printing something like, "Remember, last year's Fall box had a Stila palette," and they also mentioned another item.  I really took that as a hint and thought I was going to get a palette I could use for a Christmas gift.  If I am accurate about that, I believe that was deceitful on PopSugar's part to post that as a hint.

The box just seems, for the most part, like a jumble of items that weren't selling well elsewhere.

Here's the link to the PopSugar website I mentioned above:

http://www.popsugar.com/POPSUGAR-Must-Have-Special-Edition-Fall-Style-2014-35413906

The quote to which I referred is this: "Last year's Special Edition Fall Style box featured brands you love, like Stila and Cynthia Vincent, and we can't wait to surprise you with what's in store this year."

I don't consider the brands included in the box to have the same level of recognition as Stila.  I assumed any makeup would have the same level of popularity as Stila.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
PopSugar never said anything about a palette. The talk about the Stila one from last year was all on here. I did expect some sort of palette, but not because PopSugar insinuated it.

 
I agree with those saying this box just feels like a regular monthly box.

I'm sick of all the scarves, even though I work outside and it can get cooooooooooold in the winter. However, this scarf will match perfectly with my winter coat and boots, so at least that works out. The only time I wear hats is when I'm running, so definitely not a beanie. I have yet to wear the last two hats PS has sent out in previous boxes. But hey, maybe this one will work out! 

Meh on the perfume.

I will eat those gummies up, so I'm excited for those, haha. Oh, I am excited to try the cleanser. That's the one skincare item I rotate around and love to try new brands, so I'm definitely interested in trying it out, especially since I'm almost out of my current cleanser.

What else? Depending on the color of the lipstick, that could be a win. I've been wearing lipstick a lot more often these days, so I hope it's a good color!! 

So I'm not excited about the hat or the perfume, but everything else should be used up....still feels like a regular box though. Wish there would've been a clutch or piece of jewelry instead of the hat and perfume. 

 
I think I'm glad I skipped this one. I had a bad feeling about about the scarf/hat/mittens speculation. I sometimes sell the things i don't love on eBay, but I'm not sure anything from this box would fetch much $. I hope those of you who got it do like it though! Fingers crossed for a really great winter LE box!

 
I got mine and I'm actually pleasantly surprised as I was rather unhappy about scarf and cap.

The cap is gorgeous .. So soft and cozy. Definitely way too warm for our fall, but it will be great for windy days on the beach or the mountains. I love it. It's big, but that way it covers my sensitive ears well. Not sure I look the greatest in it, but better than my old one.

The scarf is very thin .. So it's definitely wearable on cooler days around here . Especially up in the city. And I love the colors. It it's very similar to the blue - white- black one we got a few months ago though. Different print, but same thickness and colours. I'm happy with it.

I love the perfume. Reminds me of cupcakes ;) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> .. very sweet, but still pleasant to me. So much better than the coconut one they sent recently! It's tiny though.

The lipstick is a fantastic warm red that is almost the same color as my hair. Perfect for me.

Haven't tried the cleaner which leaked a bit, but it will be used. So will the gummies.

All in all I'm very content and don't regret getting the box. I do agree though .. a small piece of jewelry would have completed the box .. even if just a simple bracelet. And 2 scarves in one month is questionable .. they should have just thrown in that blue clutch - wallet from one of the inspiration pics instead!

 
I've not gotten my box yet so I'm going to withhold final judgment until I can see everything in person. Having said that, while overall I do think things look ok (kind of like a slightly ramped up monthly box) I feel like it's missing *something*. Maybe the makeup palette we were talking about or a clutch/wallet or even a nice piece of jewelry. I really can't believe they sent just a single lipstick - and not even a well coveted one at that.

Makes me wonder if the September box is going to be a little on the weak side. I see them sending us the scarf and a netflix coupon or something lol

 
After the spoilers, I stopped at TJMaxx and had to buy a $39.99 cobalt blue leather large wristlet, my new wallet. I am sure that I will get the Tarte palette soon, too.... Right there, better use of less than $100....for my taste.

Why can't I learn? I always get much more enjoyment from a monthly box with a coupon. The September scarf is more of a must have for me.

No use in whining, since no one forced me to gamble $100 on the hopes a high value interesting surprise and I am getting a box o'boring. I have so much darn face cleanser that I should start showering with it, too! One fabulous piece of jewelry and a more posh makeup product would have made it all ok.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Latest posts

Back
Top