PopSugar Must Have September 2014 *May Contain Spoilers*

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I have been coming on this site since first signing up for Popsugar 3 months ago. While I enjoy the spoilers, theres been a recurring theme that has begun to bother me.  

I am probably in the minority here, but as a consumer I find it really disappointing that so many subscribers that post on here are just trying to find ways to cheat Popsugar out of $10 or sometimes more. I understand that coupon codes are great, but dont you think that when so many people use them dishonestly this adds up to quite a good chunk of change that ultimately might affect the items in our boxes?

In my opinion, if those $10 are the huge difference between getting a box or not, you probably have no business splurging on something that is meant to be a luxury, not a necessity. I love a good deal just like the next person, but I also pay the $39.95 every month other than my first month when I used my new subscriber code. I could easily cancel and resubscribe every single month like so many people seem to do, but what am I really gaining? It's like going to a store, getting to the register, paying in cash, getting $10 back in change that were not owed to you and not rightfully returning it. Its dishonest, plain and simple.

I especially loved how people were freaking out while the site was down, worried that they would not be able to cancel and resubscribe with a new code as easily as they do now.  I really do hope thats the case. Maybe just maybe if people stop cheating the system, Popsugar will make more money and boxes will just get better.

Just my 2 cents.
this is a friendly community of people and i feel it is unacceptable to bash everyone by accusing members of this thread of theft - how dare you make such an generalized accusation - if you have been lurking on this thread for 3 months, than why not contribute something positive or constructive? also, if a member on this thread works two jobs or has a trust fund, it is inappropriate for you to state who should be "splurging" (as you call it) on this "luxury" product or not - ironically it is actually none of YOUR business as to how members choose to spend their money - I find your comments quite disturbing, angry and unwarranted....

if you believe that the morals + ethics of the members of this thread are dishonest, i can not understand why you would waste your time here

 
Well on the codes I have seen, it does specifically state save $10 on your FIRST box. If its not your first box, then you are essentially cheating the system. Don't really see how that is a win for Popsugar at all. Who knows what kind of changes Popsugar has made since this site update, maybe now it will be more difficult to do it.

I also dont get the logic of "well if they are allowing it to happen, they must be ok with it" Well no, not really. If Popsugar was really ok with it then why wouldn't they just reduce the price to $29.98?

I respect your opinion. We will just have to agree to disagree :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
i respect yours too. 

however, regarding one point you raised.. it's called "tiered pricing" (jk, i don't really know what it's actually called in the field..but this is how i call it). they have more than one price for their product to cater to a larger market. so those who are willing/able to work the codes get a different price from those who don't. and this happens everywhere. if some people are buying their product at a higher price, then they don't need to actually lower the price. they just need to have an alternative pricing to get the 'bargain shoppers' as well.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
this is a friendly community of people and i feel it is unacceptable to bash everyone by accusing members of this thread of theft - how dare you make such an generalized accusation - if you have been lurking on this thread for 3 months, than why not contribute something positive or constructive? also, if a member on this thread works two jobs or has a trust fund, it is inappropriate for you to state who should be "splurging" (as you call it) on this "luxury" product or not - ironically it is actually none of YOUR business as to how members choose to spend their money - I find your comments quite disturbing, angry and unwarranted....

if you believe that the morals + ethics of the members of this thread are dishonest, i can not understand why you would waste your time here
For a friendly community, your twisting of my words is anything but. I did not generalize. I stated..."so many subscribers". So please do not say that you find it "unacceptable to bash EVERYONE by accusing members of this thread of theft". I never used the word EVERYONE.

In my opinion, I stated something constructive. I also said this before and I will state it again, I am not angry nor was my post angry. I was stating something I had noticed through out the otherwise pleasant posts on here. I also do not think my time here is wasted. I love reading the spoilers and peoples opinions on the items we receive. Keyword : OPINION. I stated mine and totally get that it ruffled your feathers, but again do not twist my words nor turn this into something it is not.

Have a wonderful evening :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
i respect yours too. 

however, regarding one point you raised.. it's called "tiered pricing" (jk, i don't really know what it's actually called in the field..but this is how i call it). they have more than one price for their product to cater to a larger market. so those who are willing/able to work the codes get a different price from those who don't. and this happens everywhere. if some people are buying their product at a higher price, then they don't need to actually lower the price. they just need to have an alternative pricing to get the 'bargain shoppers' as well.
I totally get what you mean with the "tiered pricing" :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

Just did not think of a subscription box on the same lines of a retail store, but I understand and you are probably correct.

 
I don't think it's "cheating" in the slightest, quite frankly.  As someone mentioned before, Popsugar could VERY easily make it impossible for a current/past subscriber to use a coupon.  It's a ridiculously easy thing to do.

Trust me, Popsugar knows and they don't care.  If they did, they'd do something about it.  They could stop releasing codes, for one.  But they don't.  They like to have subscribers.  

Trying to shame people by saying they are cheaters or that they don't deserve to be buying boxes if they need a coupon is pushing things a little too far.

 
Has anyone ever had a month where pop sugar forgot to send you a box you paid for? My tracking number has just said initiated since 9/8 and I have messaged pop sugar 3 times without a response. I called fed ex and they said that means it was never shipped. I am just a bit frustrated since the only way I can contact them is via email and I'm not getting a response. I've never had this issue before.

 
Has anyone ever had a month where pop sugar forgot to send you a box you paid for? My tracking number has just said initiated since 9/8 and I have messaged pop sugar 3 times without a response. I called fed ex and they said that means it was never shipped. I am just a bit frustrated since the only way I can contact them is via email and I'm not getting a response. I've never had this issue before.
I've never had this problem, but you could create a fake facebook (assuming you don't have a real one, you mentioned only using email), and PM them with your account info and the problem. Also, they might just be slow right now because they are getting so many emails due to the site changing. I hope you're able to figure it out!

 
I totally get what you mean with the "tiered pricing" :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

Just did not think of a subscription box on the same lines of a retail store, but I understand and you are probably correct.
There are people who use lots of coupons when they go grocery shopping and there are people who use none. Going out of your way to find, accumulate and then remember to use then when you shop really says nothing about the person's economic situation, IMHO, it's just a matter of shopping method. For me, the hassle of creating and signing up with a new email address every month just isn't worth the $10 savings, further, I'm a worry wart/rule follower and I'm afraid of getting caught and being banned. LOL I don't use coupons when I go grocery shopping because I'm too busy to find them, clip them and actually remember to buy things I have coupons for. 

The issuers of coupons know that some people use their promotions (discounts) a lot and others don't use them at all. They are budgeting an amount for promotions (discounts) every month. If they needed to change something then they would, starting with their budget, like changing the promotion (discount) to $5 a month rather than $10. I have no doubts that the consistent use or lack of use by certain customers doesn't effect the items or quality of the products. There are much larger factors that would/could effect their budget than $10/box promotions. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I have been coming on this site since first signing up for Popsugar 3 months ago. While I enjoy the spoilers, theres been a recurring theme that has begun to bother me.  

I am probably in the minority here, but as a consumer I find it really disappointing that so many subscribers that post on here are just trying to find ways to cheat Popsugar out of $10 or sometimes more. I understand that coupon codes are great, but dont you think that when so many people use them dishonestly this adds up to quite a good chunk of change that ultimately might affect the items in our boxes?

In my opinion, if those $10 are the huge difference between getting a box or not, you probably have no business splurging on something that is meant to be a luxury, not a necessity. I love a good deal just like the next person, but I also pay the $39.95 every month other than my first month when I used my new subscriber code. I could easily cancel and resubscribe every single month like so many people seem to do, but what am I really gaining? It's like going to a store, getting to the register, paying in cash, getting $10 back in change that were not owed to you and not rightfully returning it. Its dishonest, plain and simple.

I especially loved how people were freaking out while the site was down, worried that they would not be able to cancel and resubscribe with a new code as easily as they do now.  I really do hope thats the case. Maybe just maybe if people stop cheating the system, Popsugar will make more money and boxes will just get better.

Just my 2 cents.
I cancelled because I didn't care for the service.   Don't assume anything.

 
I still can't get their new website to load. I tried another browser, and it wouldn't load there, either. They did send me two emails. One was marketing their new boxes. The other simply said "null." The subject line had indicated that it was in reference to my account. No shipping email, yet :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I will persevere.

 
I'm having weird problems too. I was able to log in using my reset password. Tried to go to my account, and it logged me out. Then any attempt I make to log in, using old or new password doesn't work. I tried to have them send me a new password, but it said my e-mail isn't listed as a customer. It's the e-mail I just logged in with a few minutes ago! I just want to cancel (not to resub or anything, but just to cut some expenses).

 
...I am probably in the minority here, but as a consumer I find it really disappointing that so many subscribers that post on here are just trying to find ways to cheat Popsugar out of $10 or sometimes more. I understand that coupon codes are great, but dont you think that when so many people use them dishonestly this adds up to quite a good chunk of change that ultimately might affect the items in our boxes?...

Just my 2 cents.
The short answer is no. Coming strictly from a business owner's perspective, (that's me). Having a bunch of people consistently buy boxes every month at a discount and sometimes even 2 or 3 boxes is a dream scenario. Marketing costs a small fortune. That's why offering promotions, gift w/ purchase, discounts, points, etc. is so attractive to suppliers. That's why we do it. The more you sell, the cheaper your cost per product / shipping is, the higher your profit margin goes & everyone is happy. In the long run, 10 happy customers getting a good deal & coming back for more is better than 5 customers paying full price. Don't get me wrong, I love the 5 customers who will pay full price, but I love just as much the person who uses consistent promotions (even if they have to ring up several separate transactions to do it). That's bread & butter. I don't want them going somewhere else. It's just good business.

 
For a friendly community, your twisting of my words is anything but. I did not generalize. I stated..."so many subscribers". So please do not say that you find it "unacceptable to bash EVERYONE by accusing members of this thread of theft". I never used the word EVERYONE.

In my opinion, I stated something constructive. I also said this before and I will state it again, I am not angry nor was my post angry. I was stating something I had noticed through out the otherwise pleasant posts on here. I also do not think my time here is wasted. I love reading the spoilers and peoples opinions on the items we receive. Keyword : OPINION. I stated mine and totally get that it ruffled your feathers, but again do not twist my words nor turn this into something it is not.

Have a wonderful evening :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
.
Well, you have stated your opinion and I think the term "cheaters" is a bit angry-negative on your part.

Anyone who uses any of the codes in any context is making a choice to use their time in relation to gaining a savings in their wallet. This does not detract to the contents of any of these subscription boxes, a high percentage of the items are listed with a "suggested" retail price.... The higher price tag items we all reasonably know are not going to sell for even 1/2 that price. I love this month's scarf, BUT a MSRP of $125? I hardly believe anyone would spend even $62.50. $20 to $30 is the reality and on sale it would be $14.99. MANY items in our boxes are free of cost (to popsugar) these are promo items that the companies use as a advertising write off. The companies want their products out there in consumer's hands. It is an advantage for Popsugar to be able to show how many boxes are going out each month..... This is encouraging to those companies to know that their products will be out to so many consumers.

It's much like a magazine subscription, you can pay the high news-stand pricing or subscribe for quite a bit less, or wait for the periodic monthly sales on subscriptions that knock them down to $5 (yes for a twelve month sub, I have many). The magazine publishers need the sales numbers to show to their advertisers how many consumers will have the probability of reading their adverts. There are many tiers as someone has already mentioned.

It all comes down to what it is worth to each person, worth spending your time to obtain a better price. Spend your money to use up less of your time. Just don't start throwing out negativity at large because others make different choices than you.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
For a friendly community, your twisting of my words is anything but. I did not generalize. I stated..."so many subscribers". So please do not say that you find it "unacceptable to bash EVERYONE by accusing members of this thread of theft". I never used the word EVERYONE.

In my opinion, I stated something constructive. I also said this before and I will state it again, I am not angry nor was my post angry. I was stating something I had noticed through out the otherwise pleasant posts on here. I also do not think my time here is wasted. I love reading the spoilers and peoples opinions on the items we receive. Keyword : OPINION. I stated mine and totally get that it ruffled your feathers, but again do not twist my words nor turn this into something it is not.

Have a wonderful evening :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I'll let Merriam-Webster know to update the definition of "twisting words" to include quoting exactly what someone stated. Generalizing is exactly what you did. If you had stated specific members or instances of someone doing what you qualify as cheating that would be the opposite of generalizing.

In MY opinion you've said nothing constructive or informative, are extremely rude and completely tone-deaf if you think coming into a forum as a brand new member and calling the members cheaters, dishonest and bad with personal finances is going to get people to see your side of things. I'm sure this opinion will ruffle your feathers right back but that's the cross I'll bear.

Toodles!

 
I have been coming on this site since first signing up for Popsugar 3 months ago. While I enjoy the spoilers, theres been a recurring theme that has begun to bother me.  

I am probably in the minority here, but as a consumer I find it really disappointing that so many subscribers that post on here are just trying to find ways to cheat Popsugar out of $10 or sometimes more. I understand that coupon codes are great, but dont you think that when so many people use them dishonestly this adds up to quite a good chunk of change that ultimately might affect the items in our boxes?

In my opinion, if those $10 are the huge difference between getting a box or not, you probably have no business splurging on something that is meant to be a luxury, not a necessity. I love a good deal just like the next person, but I also pay the $39.95 every month other than my first month when I used my new subscriber code. I could easily cancel and resubscribe every single month like so many people seem to do, but what am I really gaining? It's like going to a store, getting to the register, paying in cash, getting $10 back in change that were not owed to you and not rightfully returning it. Its dishonest, plain and simple.

I especially loved how people were freaking out while the site was down, worried that they would not be able to cancel and resubscribe with a new code as easily as they do now.  I really do hope thats the case. Maybe just maybe if people stop cheating the system, Popsugar will make more money and boxes will just get better.

Just my 2 cents.
I get what you're saying, and where you're coming from in thought, but I disagree with you to an extent.  Being one of those ladies you think are cheating the system and being dishonest, I'm going to say my peace.  

Before you signed up, last year, boxes were cheaper.  They raised the price by about 5 bucks a month, claiming to have better curated boxes in the process.  Well, that didn't happen.  Boxes are no better than before, and often times worse, and they're charging more money.  They regularly claim a bunch of crap, if they say anything at all, and try to "pull one over" on their customers, including this price increase. 

I do not believe in cancelling and re-subbing each month just to use a discount.  You can easily send yourself a "gift" box without having to re-sub each month, and you can still use the $-off discount codes if there is one. I also don't agree with continually referring yourself to get free boxes.  I don't see anything wrong with sending a gift box. And to be honest, even though I don't agree with the sub/unsub/re-sub way--the company themselves LET people be able to do it, and they KNOW people do it, same with referrals.  If they are going to let people do it, then they can't complain and it isn't dishonest technically speaking.  It isn't like they're playing the system and nobody at the company knows about it.  If they cared or it affected them enough, they'd change the ability to do it in the first place.  

It isn't like people here are sitting around trying to find new ways to get more than what is clearly publicly advertised (discount codes), or new ways to get around having a sub.  There is only two ways...cancel and re-up later, or just buy gift boxes.  

This is just "my" opinion, but I find it rather tacky and rude to post that so many women here are lying cheats, which is basically what you said.  I don't find that any better of character than what you claim women here are doing.  Different issue, both suggest about a persons' character.  

I also don't think it is fair of you to make such harsh comments about what you've seen for 3 months now, when a good deal of us have been here posting and members of PopSugar for WAY longer than 3 months.  It is one thing to notice a pattern to something, and a whole other thing to unfairly judge the actions of those you barely "know".  Ya know?   This kind of comment from people is what makes this website community no fun and makes me not want to participate as much.  Coming in here and seeing somebody call me and others I've participated a long time with online here dishonest cheats isn't what I want to see, and doesn't provide anything positive to the community.  You want to continue paying full price, on principle, when you get nothing better for it, power to you.  That doesn't mean us, or anybody else online, are bad/cheat/dishonest, etc.  

 
I wouldn't be surprised if Popsugar increased their monthly rate for boxes, due to seeing a pattern of free referral boxes/canceling/resubscribing customers. I also believe they have altered the site where cancellation would be a pain for customers, not as a nuisance to the customer, but as in order to retain what they lose through codes/system cheaters and whatnot. What I would suggest to Popsugar to diminish this type of account behavior is to not have codes available except through referral.
 Popsugar increasing the monthly price last year is a major factor in people "cheating" the system now in the first place.  

They perfectly well knew when they increased prices stuff like this would happen more often.  Most people are doing it to get closer to the original box price, because the boxes aren't any better than before--so why should we pay more... I'm willing to bet a large portion of their sales is from customers using these codes as much as they can and buying multiple boxes each month/several months in a row.  

If somebody uses a coupon on 3 boxes in one month, they saved 5-10$ a box, but they also bought 3... even at 10$ off each box, that's still 90-100$ (if you pay tax like I have to), vs. 40$ for a full price box, because they'd only buy one without use of codes.  Popsugar still makes out with more money, more popularity to tout to get more products for their members, and they get box items very cheap or free, it isn't like they're paying anything near retail to provide the boxes. They are making out either instance. 

 
*laughs/cries* I was able to reset my password and log in, with the link provided by the lovely forumite above. Only, my order/subscription isn't showing up in my account, because it was made before the site update. Do I still have a box coming? Probably. Will I get a shipment email? Maybe. Can not be confirmed or denied at this point. /whining

 
I have been coming on this site since first signing up for Popsugar 3 months ago. While I enjoy the spoilers, theres been a recurring theme that has begun to bother me.

I am probably in the minority here, but as a consumer I find it really disappointing that so many subscribers that post on here are just trying to find ways to cheat Popsugar out of $10 or sometimes more. I understand that coupon codes are great, but dont you think that when so many people use them dishonestly this adds up to quite a good chunk of change that ultimately might affect the items in our boxes?

In my opinion, if those $10 are the huge difference between getting a box or not, you probably have no business splurging on something that is meant to be a luxury, not a necessity. I love a good deal just like the next person, but I also pay the $39.95 every month other than my first month when I used my new subscriber code. I could easily cancel and resubscribe every single month like so many people seem to do, but what am I really gaining? It's like going to a store, getting to the register, paying in cash, getting $10 back in change that were not owed to you and not rightfully returning it. Its dishonest, plain and simple.

I especially loved how people were freaking out while the site was down, worried that they would not be able to cancel and resubscribe with a new code as easily as they do now. I really do hope thats the case. Maybe just maybe if people stop cheating the system, Popsugar will make more money and boxes will just get better.

Just my 2 cents.
Do you work for Popsugar?

 
Back
Top