Popsugar Must Have October 2014 *May Contain Spoilers*

Advertise with us
Jeffreestar cosmetics
Shop deals on ebay
shop deals on amazon
Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
chachithegreat said:
They're clearly trying to branch out by giving this box to bloggers that don't normally blog about this stuff. I understand their reasoning, but I'm so irritated that I had to sit through that video. 

I really love the candle, and the picture frame. Yes, I'm boring and basic, but I'm excited to get shit I'm actually going to use and not have to put up on the trade board.

I am excited to try Dean and Deluca since I never have. Interested in trying Butter London eyeliner, even though I sure as hell don't need more eyeliner.

Based on the conversation on the board about using bar soap earlier, I actually used the soap bar we received in one of the boxes a year or two ago maybe? And loved it, so maybe I'll use the soap after all. I just am not quite sure how to keep it from getting gunky. I took it out of the shower and put it in a disposable gladware thing.
Click to expand...
I hate blog videos, I don't care who the blogger is.  I just don't care about all the side chit chat they do, their speed, awkwardness etc.  Nothing against the bloggers ever, just I am not capable of sitting through a whole video and hearing it, lol.  

I let them load up, and then watch them on mute, and skip parts to the next thing of interest.  I'm slowly getting pretty good at reading lips haha!  I could understand about 70% of this spoiler video even on mute.  

I think I'm going to like this box.  Maybe a couple things might go for Christmas presents, but over all I think I'll like it.  I hope my malt balls aren't melted though.  

 
Everything in the box is cute, but nothing in it wows me. It all kinda just is. I don' think I would use much of any of it so I am rather happy I didn't order the box. I was/am still waiting for something to make me pull the plug and order it though. 

I want a box this month!!!!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
normajean2008 said:
I hate blog videos, I don't care who the blogger is.  I just don't care about all the side chit chat they do, their speed, awkwardness etc.  Nothing against the bloggers ever, just I am not capable of sitting through a whole video and hearing it, lol.  

I let them load up, and then watch them on mute, and skip parts to the next thing of interest.  I'm slowly getting pretty good at reading lips haha!  I could understand about 70% of this spoiler video even on mute.  

I think I'm going to like this box.  Maybe a couple things might go for Christmas presents, but over all I think I'll like it.  I hope my malt balls aren't melted though.  
Click to expand...
Glad to know I'm not the only person who mutes those things!

I am thankful that people can put themselves out there like that.  I'm a wimpy introvert who couldn't imagine doing that.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
I hate animal prints, and don't care for bar soap or nail decals. That's roughly half the box there, and I can't see paying $40 for the other four items, especially since I have an overabundance of eyeliners right now that I have yet to get around to using. Glad I cancelled after the website refresh mishap. Hopefully next month will be better.

 
Tinyytiff said:
Hi all!

This is my first post on these forums, but I've been reading from afar and wanted to join in on the conversation.

Soo, I am a little bit upset because I am subscribed to some small subscriptions boxes, but I decided I wanted to splurge and got a 3 month subscription to Popsugar! I've looked at all the past boxes and was so in love with the jewerly and scarfs and everything in them! I've been checking everyday for spoilers of the October box since it will be my first and now they're posted. I am just completely underwelmed. The stuff is cute and all, but kind of just seems like junk (other than the candle and eyeliner). I know I got the $40 worth, but I also thought Popsugar's boxes were supposed to value to over $100 worth of items! According to some of the blogs I've read the most expensive item was the $24 candle.

I'm not trying to sound unappreciative, I just was looking forward to so much better :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I really hope the next two months are better....

Am I wrong for thinking this?
Click to expand...
You don't sound unappreciative :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I think my thing is in the past if I didn't like the big ticket item, it ends up being a bummer box. Like last month, I didn't like the scarf...so the box was a bust. It wasn't worth it for cards, pencils, hairspray, and headphones.

In a box like this, that has several $15-20 items instead of one big ticket item and several $5-10 items, I'm more likely to like SOME of the items. If I don't like the candle, it's not like I won't like the whole box.

I don't know if that makes sense, but my favorite PSMH boxes always have a wide variety, not one or two big ticket items.

 
crowsgirl15 said:
You don't sound unappreciative :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I think my thing is in the past if I didn't like the big ticket item, it ends up being a bummer box. Like last month, I didn't like the scarf...so the box was a bust. It wasn't worth it for cards, pencils, hairspray, and headphones.

In a box like this, that has several $15-20 items instead of one big ticket item and several $5-10 items, I'm more likely to like SOME of the items. If I don't like the candle, it's not like I won't like the whole box.

I don't know if that makes sense, but my favorite PSMH boxes always have a wide variety, not one or two big ticket items.
Click to expand...
Yeah that does make sense! It would suck to have the main item be something you don't like!

 
Meh on the box, tbh - was hoping for a better selection of items since it's my birthday month, but I think all the subscription boxes this month have been average/just "okay".

Won't use the nail decals, really hate malt balls, and I don't burn soy candles. :/ I have accumulated too many bar soaps from various subscription boxes and I only use liquid soap/shower gel lol. And... I still have my Butter London eyeliner from Sample Society sitting somewhere, unused. 

The only thing I'm really excited about is the photo frame because I've gotten Isaac Jacobs frames from Fancy and loved them. The socks are cool though - I'll never say no to a pair of socks. XD 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Sooo... does anyone know what the candle actually smells like? I watched the video, and it went something like this: "OMG it smells so good! This smells like...OH MY GOSH YOU CAN WRITE ON THIS!" And we never actually found out exactly what smell is so OMG-worthy. Haha...

I have been stalking the spoilers for this box like a lion ready to pounce on a gazelle for the past few days! To be honest, I was a little worried this month would be a dud, because sometimes it seems like there's a pattern of an awesome box with nice, high-value items (like September) being followed by a few months of really underwhelming boxes. I'm not exactly blown away this month, but I do think it's a nice selection, it feels like it's actually been curated rather than just thrown together, and everything in the box is totally giftable if you don't want to hang onto it.

I'm the most excited about the socks and the nail stickers (because both are fun things that I like, but wouldn't necessarily buy for myself), and least excited about the soap, because I just have a personal thing against bar soap...it grosses me out! So that will definitely be given away. Everything else is fun, and I'm excited to (hopefully) have the box in my hands soon!

 
ikecarus said:
The only thing I'm really excited about is the photo frame because I've gotten Isaac Jacobs frames from Fancy and loved them. 
Click to expand...
For ikecarus and anyone else who's into Isaac Jacobs frames, I was googling around trying to find out how big the frame in our box is, and I came across some Isaac Jacobs frames on sale at lastcall.com ... Not the ones in the must have box, but they do have some cute ones on sale for $8.50-11, down from $18. Figured I'd post the link in case anyone was interested!

 
hmm.

This box is so weird for me. I don't feel like it has a very high value at all from the looks of it. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

The socks are OK. Not really into animal print but I'll wear them.

I usually don't like nail wraps, but I LOVE Halloween and I'm totally into these ones. Excited to try them out.

The frame...eh. I don't really do pictures around my house really, so I don't know if it'll get used at all.

One of the only chocolate candies I hate are maltballs. So no thanks on those.

The candle is nice. Unfortunately I'm not getting the vibe that it has a Fall scent, which really saddens me. How are you going to give out a candle in an October box that doesn't have an autumn scent? :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I despise bar soaps, but my mom loves them so I will pass that on to her. 

The Butter London Liner is nice, however I received a full size BL liner from Sample Society earlier this year and that box is only $15 a month, so this doesn't feel super luxurious or valuable to me, really.

While I think that this box is a bit of a letdown for me, I do think that it might be great for others. It's just that most of the items this month aren't really up my alley in terms of personal taste. 

Plus last month's box was a really great one for me, so this one just pales greatly in comparison. 

 
MissJexie said:
hmm.

This box is so weird for me. I don't feel like it has a very high value at all from the looks of it. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

The socks are OK. Not really into animal print but I'll wear them.

I usually don't like nail wraps, but I LOVE Halloween and I'm totally into these ones. Excited to try them out.

The frame...eh. I don't really do pictures around my house really, so I don't know if it'll get used at all.

One of the only chocolate candies I hate are maltballs. So no thanks on those.

The candle is nice. Unfortunately I'm not getting the vibe that it has a Fall scent, which really saddens me. How are you going to give out a candle in an October box that doesn't have an autumn scent? :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I despise bar soaps, but my mom loves them so I will pass that on to her. 

The Butter London Liner is nice, however I received a full size BL liner from Sample Society earlier this year and that box is only $15 a month, so this doesn't feel super luxurious or valuable to me, really.

While I think that this box is a bit of a letdown for me, I do think that it might be great for others. It's just that most of the items this month aren't really up my alley in terms of personal taste. 

Plus last month's box was a really great one for me, so this one just pales greatly in comparison. 
Click to expand...
That is such a good point! When I saw this box I was like "how could anyone not like this?!"...but then, I haven't used a single thing in last month's box (except the sea salt chocolates...those got used). I was so bummed by the extra long scarf, the headphones with a bad mic, hairspray I won't use, pencils, a $25 gift card to a place that has almost nothing for under $25...but then people loved it! I was shocked!

I like getting boxes because they're a fun way to try new things...and I'm learning that bummer boxes for me aren't bummer boxes to everyone!

 
I think I must be in the super minority because there are very few Popsugar boxes I love, and this one missed, again.

Candle - Ok, it's kind of gimmicky to me, but if it smells good then fine. I do also wish it was fall scented as I've been good and haven't bought any candles for the season yet.

Maltballs - Depends. I might like them, I might hate them, not sure on these yet.

Eyeliner - I do not have a gray eyeliner yet, so win on this.

Socks - I hardly ever buy socks for myself, so getting them in a box is great. I do like the print on these, so I will be wearing them this winter.

Frame - ehh I have another of these frames from a Fancy mystery box, and I haven't used it. I like that this frame is completely clear though.

Nail decals - I'm excited, I don't have a Halloween mani planned yet, and I skipped my chances at getting themed decals in my Julep box this month, so I will be using these.

Soap - I have too much soap. I will never need to buy soap for the next 5 years. Soap bars are not my favorite though.

Overall, this box feels light on the value. I think it could have used one more item to really make me like it, instead of just thinking of ways to get rid of the things I know I will never use.

 
 I really hope those socks will fit my 10w paddle-boats, normal women's socks never do,and I love socks. I'm excited about the BL eyeliner, it will be my first makeup item from that company. Hoping the candle doesn't smell like food and has no overwhelming, eye-watering cinnamon scent. It seems like a nice, well rounded box, but it lacks a real wow factor.

 
Hmm. I can't decide whether or not to sign up for this box. I don't really think it's worth it for me but I might do it if I can find a promo. I haven't been keeping up with this thread, tbh. Everything in the box seems nice, I just don't know if it's worth it personally.

 
Meh.

Bar soap: meh,..boyfriend will use it, loves bar soap,

Candle: meh, cute idea will make a nice gift for house warming party or hostess gift,

Malt balls: meh, I'll try them, but I don't generally like malt balls. BF will eat anything, now pumpkin spice oreos, those are yummy!!

Socks: ok, I wait until the very last possible chance before pulling out and wearing socks for the fall and winter (except for the gym). I wish they were athletic socks but I'll wear them with my boots, if they don't slide too much. They'll get worn. They're kinda cute-ish too.

Butter London: ok, good brand, but eyeliner...I don't mind it if it's not the same shade I got in my Sample Society box a while back.

Nail stickers/wraps: Ugh, meh, personally not for me, I find them a little young. I might send them to my niece or trade them. 

Picture frame: meh, might be a good gift like the candle. I might save it for my sister, she's getting married soon, she'll have pics she wants to display.

So I'm left with socks, maltballs, soap and eyeliner. Meh. I don't mind getting an item or two to swap, or gift saves me some shopping, but I wish it was more like last year's October box.   

 
I have been following this site for a while and finally signed up to post. I have been an early Popsugar subscriber, but this is really a disappointing box for me. I am not into Halloween nor animal prints so the socks and nail art are so out of touch for me. I have way too many candles from Popsugar and do not need any more. I actually just unsubscribed before I was charged for October thankfully. Maybe I will order next month's box if there are better items. I am really bummed that the box from France is actually more my style, and they don't plan on bringing it here. I would love to have that box.   :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> 

 
rachelnyc said:
Sooo... does anyone know what the candle actually smells like? I watched the video, and it went something like this: "OMG it smells so good! This smells like...OH MY GOSH YOU CAN WRITE ON THIS!" And we never actually found out exactly what smell is so OMG-worthy. Haha...

I have been stalking the spoilers for this box like a lion ready to pounce on a gazelle for the past few days! To be honest, I was a little worried this month would be a dud, because sometimes it seems like there's a pattern of an awesome box with nice, high-value items (like September) being followed by a few months of really underwhelming boxes. I'm not exactly blown away this month, but I do think it's a nice selection, it feels like it's actually been curated rather than just thrown together, and everything in the box is totally giftable if you don't want to hang onto it.

I'm the most excited about the socks and the nail stickers (because both are fun things that I like, but wouldn't necessarily buy for myself), and least excited about the soap, because I just have a personal thing against bar soap...it grosses me out! So that will definitely be given away. Everything else is fun, and I'm excited to (hopefully) have the box in my hands soon!
Click to expand...
I have received a few of these candles as gifts and they come in a variety of scents not sure which scent pop sugar is sending but I have received the gardenia candle, pomegranate candle, and vanilla fig candle. All 3 of those scents were really nice not too strong but pleasant and clean smelling.  Some of the other scents they offer are: lemongrass, belgian berry, parklands, and persian fig.  I guess its a surprise which scent we get but from the ones I've smelled in the past I bet they are all lovely!  Fun box!

 

Latest posts

Back
Top