OK, I've had time to experience the box. I really like it, but I'm unlikely to subscribe again unless I can get another really good discount like this month. Here's my thoughts:
The dreaded Dial Wash - actually smells really good! I'm up to my ears in bodywash right now, so it's going to the kids as a bubble bath. They both have super-dry skin, so we'll see how a lotion-infused soap does on them
Nourish Serum - will have to wait its turn til I finish my 100% Argan Oil. If it works well as my new nighttime moisturizer, then awesome! I already know my face responds well to Argan, hopefully having Safflower Seed Oil as the #1 ingredient won't change the effectiveness for my skin.
Cinnamon Hearts - They were fun to give to the kids and watch them flip out over "hot candy" (I'm a mean mommy). Hubby will eat the rest. I DID try them before giving them to the kids, and they seem more mild than regular Red Hots.
Lipstick, Nail Polish - Dupes for lipstick/polish I already have. Going in my "to gift" stash.
Peony Candle - too floral for my taste. It's already packaged up for a trade (that has been delayed shipping for Snowmageddon. Thankfully I have an understanding trade partner! I promise our roads are now clear and I'll be knockin' on the post office door at 9 am tomorrow!)
G+G Jewelry Roll & $25 card - absolutely the stars of the box for me. My roll is well-made, zippers work, no stains or threads and I personally LOVE the color. I'm hanging on to the card until G+G has another mythical "free ship" day, and then I'll make my move. I have a pair of earrings from them I got last summer, and I love them.
All in all, I am very satisfied, for the *discounted* price I paid. I'll keep an eye out for future deals, and I'm considering saving up for a Fall Special Edition box (My b-day is in August, and I seem to remember them promoting that box shortly after. Weirdly enough, one of the things I'm most happy about is that candle, along with a few other things, is getting me the Lulu Frost bracelet in a trade. So it worked out really well for me in the end!
I hope everyone is enjoying their boxes (or will enjoy it once it shows up). And here's to a fantastic month for all you regular subscribers in March!