POPSUGAR Must Have February 2014 (SPOILERS!)

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Quote: Originally Posted by IffB /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  The truth is I have too much stuff already, and should probably stop getting surprise boxes and using the funds on awesome online sales - like the one Piperlime was having a couple weeks ago with an extra 50% clearance items.

But for now, it is still fun for me to wait for the next PopSugar box, so we are not breaking up!
I agree, I have too much stuff, but it is too much fun!

I am excited about this box the more I think about it. I don't usually like nail polish, but I LOVE this color, and can't wait to use it. I think I will probably use the jewelry roll as a clutch or save it for a present. Body wash, while not super exciting, is always useful, and I like useful.

 
One could also argue that trying to shame someone for speaking their mind here by claiming they are acting like "North Korea" isn't particularly democratic or reasonable or kind, either. You cannot have it both ways.  I have seen other posters run out of forums here for providing a dissenting opinion. Then suddenly democracy isn't so important.

There is a more constructive discussion we could be having. I attempted to turn lemons into lemonade, but clearly that's not happening.

 
 
I really like this months box.  Everything will get used and I like red hots.  My only thing was last years February box was my FAVORITE BOX EVER!  I know a lot of people were upset with the hanky panky undies but that was a new find for me.  i loved the wrap and book.  The lippie and jewlry cleaner were great.  I don't know.  I just was comparing it to last years.  but I really like it and everything will get used. 

 
I think it would be easier for them and for our expectations if there was a set format for each month. For example every month you get: 1 beauty item (anything from skin care to make up) 1 item for your home (decor, kitchen tool, etc.) 1 fitness item/health item (recipe books, water bottles, exercise dvd, etc) 1 entertainment item (earphones or other media accessory, books, dvd, movie passes, etc.) 1 fashion item (scarf, hat, sunglasses, jewelry, hair accessories, etc.) 1 random extra (this is where the popcorn, candy, nail file type stuff comes in)
You know some of the older boxes they had must have food, must have fashion. I agree with what you are saying, I love this idea. Sounds like a great formula
 
Just got mine! And while my opinion is the same as when I saw the spoilers, the lip duo really surprised me. I wasn't in the market for any lip products so I wasn't too excited about it, but upon opening it and using it just now, it smells wonderful and goes on really smoothly and all thought I'm not a gloss person, I actually like the consistency of it and don't find it to be sticky and gooey. I was also surprised because I wasn't crazy about their mascara from the same company in the December box (aside from the built in mirror). Anyway, still sticking to my decision to cancel for now.. I'll be keeping an eye out though :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
my box is already out for delivery today! I do applaud them for their quick shipping. I just got my January glossybox yesterday...

 
Quote: Originally Posted by afwife8405 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  I think it would be easier for them and for our expectations if there was a set format for each month. For example every month you get:

1 beauty item (anything from skin care to make up)

1 item for your home (decor, kitchen tool, etc.)

1 fitness item/health item (recipe books, water bottles, exercise dvd, etc)

1 entertainment item (earphones or other media accessory, books, dvd, movie passes, etc.)

1 fashion item (scarf, hat, sunglasses, jewelry, hair accessories, etc.)

1 random extra (this is where the popcorn, candy, nail file type stuff comes in)
This is EXACTLY what I wish they would do!!!  I would be a forever subscriber if they did it this way.  Also, I would feel much more comfortable sending gifts if there was a set format that we could feel comfortable sending to people.

So far, I've ordered 2 gift boxes.  Dec 2013 & Feb 2014.  Both sent to the same person, who wasn't super excited about either of them.  I feel bad for gifting dud boxes that didn't wow her.  It's a shame because she probably would've subbed if she really loved the stuff.  Lesson learned for me, no more gifts until they start using a more reliable format for all their boxes.

 
I think they'd do better to post a spoiler every month of their big item. That way people know at least one thing to expect. Would I have subbed for the jewelry roll? No. But I would have subbed for a spa wrap or fiction book.

 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissJexie /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Dang I took a nap and came back to read a bunch of posts and now that I'm done I just feel really irritated, which is a first for me here on MUT.

I get VERY insulted when people say, "don't tell me you can't afford ___. If you're paying for a subscription box you can afford it."

I budget my money down to the very last dime. I gave up quite a few things in order to try out Pop Sugar, and I did so because being poor sucks. And it sucks when people tell you that you're not allowed to have anything nice or treat yourself to anything nice because your poor. I received a bit of money as a gift from my mother who insisted I spend it on something fun and not on bills. I have a strict budget that allows a couple of the smaller subscriptions, and the other subscriptions I get (like memebox) are complimentary from the company for reviewing purposes. I have always been very jealous of the Pop Sugar boxes as they were always filled with fun and pretty things that I could never afford on my own, so I decided to sign up.

Pop Sugar has since sent me chocolate and popcorn galore. Wrapping paper, etc. January was a fine box but just not up my alley. I never complained about it or said the company was terrible, just that it wasn't for me. This box also falls into that category. It's definitely not Pop Sugar's fault that everything isn't tailored to me, but it's just strange that almost every box before December (when I signed up) was something I would have loved.

I am REALLY getting sick and tired of the "Stop whining" and "I'll whine when I want" debates on these threads. It always seems to happen on the PSMH threads the most. People come here to MUT to express their opinions with like-minded people, and heck, even non-like-minded people. But I would REALLY appreciate it if people didn't tell me what I can afford or what I can't. I would also really love to be able to express my like or dislike for something without the happy police getting angry about it. Not everyone is going to be sunshine and rainbows about every box. When I spend $40 on something, I understand it's a surprise, but when it's NOT A GOOD SURPRISE FOR ME, I'm allowed to be bummed out, even if it's a great surprise for you.

I don't love the negative nancy attitudes all the time either, but I understand people have a right to be bummed out, even if they signed up for a surprise box. We all want a good surprise, and we keep subcribing hoping the surprise will eventually be a good one.

This is going to be my last month with Pop Sugar because it's no longer in my budget and I haven't been happy with most of my boxes, and honestly these threads always make me feel stressed and uncomfortable with expressing my opinion for fear of being told to shut up and like it because I bought a surprise box and that's what I got.

See y'all in the other threads. Sorry to stir up anything, but I feel like I had to say something.
icon_neutral.gif

I agree with you a lot. This is my first PS box, and it will probably be my last, as I just can't bring myself to pay full price...I've seen some great stuff in past boxes, but the "crapshoot" of $40 when I don't know what I might get...eh.

After reading your post, I did think to myself "Oh hey, that birthday money my Grandmother sent me basically paid for this box (at the 50% off) AND my Gorjana earrings  I just got" (35% + free shipping, can you tell I like bargain shopping?)

My only other thoughts are that I wish I had let this month's box (especially as it will probably be my only one) be a total surprise. When I opened it, I probably wouldn't have been thrilled with the body wash or candle, but I feel like reading all these posts has really put a damper on what excitement I might have had.

 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissJexie /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Like I said, I think this would be a great box for some, and not for others. I was really hoping it would be more "valentiney." Like a nice piece of jewelry, a box of fancy chocolates or an indie brand of chocolate in a pretty box etc. I totally got my hopes up that it would be more of a "single ladies valentines day" kind of box since they encouraged us to gift it. More spa/chocolate/jewelry/romance novel kind of box.
You should have been in charge of the box! Yes, I think that's more like what I was looking for. I would have LOVED some jewelry...I don't have a BF to buy any for me

 
I think my biggest problem with this box is the crazy shipping.  It left New York on the 4th, bound for me in DC.  It checked into New Jersey and left and was scanned a day later...in Ohio.  Then it left Ohio and was scanned 24 hours later 20 minutes away in another Ohio city.  It left that facility yesterday at 6 PM and is...somewhere now.  The estimated delivery date is the 11th.  For a box that shipped from New York.  Parcel post (slow boat USPS) would have gotten to me in 2-3 days.  FedEx SmartPost?  An ENTIRE WEEK.
 
...not to mention the fact that, at one point, it was all of a few hours' drive from me before it was shipped to a location an EIGHT HOUR DRIVE from the locaiton in NJ and six and a half hours from me..
 
My two boxes arrived today, which is the fastest they have ever arrived. It's been a year since I've had popsugar, but it seems as though shipping as been improved, even if the boxes haven't.

I live in Sacramento, mine comes from Gilroy (always has), but before it would take much, much longer to arrive. I was almost always last to receive mine it seemed.

 
Got my box (and my Bijou Box at the same time!!!!). Better in person. Still a bit disappointed but I'll use everything. The face serum is a lot smaller than I though as the box was double the size of the bottle. 

 
Quote: Originally Posted by greer /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Got my box (and my Bijou Box at the same time!!!!). Better in person. Still a bit disappointed but I'll use everything. The face serum is a lot smaller than I though as the box was double the size of the bottle. 
I am suppose to my Bijoux box too!  I am really curious as to what the other 2 pieces are & it is killing me!

 
Quote: Originally Posted by indianaredhead /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  I am suppose to my Bijoux box too!  I am really curious as to what the other 2 pieces are & it is killing me!
Eeks, I can post spoilers but didn't want to just in case!

 
Quote: Originally Posted by greer /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by indianaredhead /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  I am suppose to my Bijoux box too!  I am really curious as to what the other 2 pieces are & it is killing me!
Eeks, I can post spoilers but didn't want to just in case!

 do it do it!!

 
I don't think this box is my fave but it's ok. I am going thru a break up right now so I really wanted to get a lovey dovey box. Hmmmm I think that may have tortured me though. haha. 

Here's my breakdown and mind you I AM VERY FRUGAL so I will not buy something unless I am getting a bargain OR I really need it. (then I will pay whatever) 

Heart candy: $2  - I will eat this bc I love sugar candy and the packaging is so cute, but I don't think it is that high of a value. Movie night with my girlfriends? 

Jewelry Roll: $7 - I will absolutely use this and have actually been wanting one because I travel a lot. I also love the hot magenta color. Score!

Dial soap: $1 - I am sure we all have feelings about this one so I will let it be. Will probably donate it to our local homeless shelter since I am inundated with body washes and they are always asking for personal products like this. Sharing the love.

Candle: $2 - I just got a ton of Illume candles from their sale and a similar sized candle was approximately this price on sale. I like the scent and will use it but would never pay the retail price for it. 

NCLA polish: $4 - I have not tried NCLA polishes so I am excited to try them, but I do have about 2-3 similar colors in other brands. It's ok, it's a versatile color. 

Model Co lipgloss/lipstick: $5 - I was actually going to buy this with my last Model Co order and it was on sale plus I had a discount code so it would have been somewhere around this price. Pretty. I have a ton of lipgloss but I will certainly try it out. 

Face Serum: $7 - I know this is supposed to be one of the high ticket items, but I just can't pay that price for a serum (moisturizer is another story). I have also gotten a face serum in every sub for the past two months so I have a ton of mini samples to go thru. With that said, I do notice the difference when I use them so let's try this one out. 

Gorgana & Griffin GC: $25 - I am excited to get this bc they are having a sale right now. 35% off and free shipping with the code SWEETHEART. If I find something under $50 and use the code and GC, the item will basically be free. 

So the value of the box for me without the GC is $28. I payed around $30 so that is not bad. WITH the GC it takes it over what I payed for and I get to have another surprise in the mail. 
roflmao.gif


So, maybe it's not the most amazing box ever, but I will use most of the items and I like them alright so really no complaints. The dial soap is just kinda goofy to me. Who knows, maybe I will try it....

I did buy one for my sister who lives in a dorm where they are not allowed to have candles, so she won't be able to use that, but I hope she loves everything else.

NOW QUESTION: What to buy on Gorjana & Griffin? Are you all taking advantage of the Valentines day sale? or are you waiting for something better? Free shipping and 35% off is pretty good IMO. The only better sale I saw was the after Xmas sale where things were 80% off. I wonder if the GC's expire??? Anyone??? I don't see an expiration date. 

HOPE YOU ALL HAVE A WONDERFUL V-DAY! 
wub.gif


 
Quote: Originally Posted by greer /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  There's a Bijoux Box thread, will post my picts there!
ahhhhhhh! SHould I spoil it for myself????? 

 

Latest posts

Back
Top