OuiPlease [spoilers]

[MET]

boxesandboxes, on 05 Mar 2015 - 8:46 PM, said:Sorry - sounds a little over the top for someone with only 1 post on the MUT message boards.  It's great that you are very happy with the box but I'm not quite sure about the rest.  

Not to be argumentative but I don't think it's too over the top - she liked her box and the review is the same as other posters.  The only difference is that she mentions her French background and disputed a particular comment (or 2) about the contents not being authentically French.  As for the 1 post - everyone has to start posting somewhere.

Regarding the products, they would be seen/used by French women but that's based on my personal experience = lived briefly in Paris, travelled there at least 20 times in the last few years and work for a major French corporation. 

 

[boxesandboxes]

Not to be argumentative but I don't think it's too over the top - she liked her box and the review is the same as other posters.  The only difference is that she mentions her French background and disputed a particular comment (or 2) about the contents not being authentically French.  As for the 1 post - everyone has to start posting somewhere.

Regarding the products, they would be seen/used by French women but that's based on my personal experience = lived briefly in Paris, travelled there at least 20 times in the last few years and work for a major French corporation. 

Sure. But for someone who joined the site 4 hours ago - I'm just a little surprised at the level and description - especially since I have the necklace and earrrings. Of course, it's great. It certainly sounds like I may be able to trade it easily as there are people out there who find the necklace high quality.   Wish more MUT would just post a review right when they sign up - usually takes a little lurking for most.  Adds to the flavor for sure. 

 

[makeuplover2]

Sure. But for someone who joined the site 4 hours ago - I'm just a little surprised at the level and description - especially since I have the necklace and earrrings. Of course, it's great. It certainly sounds like I may be able to trade it easily as there are people out there who find the necklace high quality.   Wish more MUT would just post a review right when they sign up - usually takes a little lurking for most.  Adds to the flavor for sure. 

  I have been reading this site for years.  Someone posted something acting like people in France would not wear what was in the box.  That got me very angry since I thought the box was 100 percent what I have seen in  France.   I also get many other boxes and love this box.  I have never had a reason to post on here . I do check 2  forums  métier de beauty and now this one for spoilers. Sorry If I ruined your day LOL.  Some people just hate to see others happy.  After getting 2 Nina horrible  boxes this one is delight.

 

[makeuplover2]

@@tinysurprise  No, I think all of the jewelry is cheap looking. Some of the other color combinations are prettier, but they're all  Basic Beadwork, 101.  Not even nice beads. And that bracelet.... I just can't. I don't like the earrings at all, but everyone says they look better in person. Just not my style at all, and my experience of three years living in France leads me to believe that it is not going to be a hot ticket item there.  

 I hope I get the scarf, as I don't care for the sweater, and the cosmetics items seem nice enough, but all in all, this box off as something tailored to appeal to Americans, and I will be cancelling my sub. So there should be an opening!

 YOU Have 4 posts ..  and you obviously have never been to France in your life . ( 100 percent sure) You have no clue as to what you are  talking about.  How dare you  question what I am saying. I like the box you should not come here and post things to ruin it for others who love it.       I am from France and currently have a job in NYC.  This box is very French.   I think some people on here are just plain mean that is why I never posted just read the posts . I was right.  Some people just cannot stand seeing someone happy or just post negative things to be mean.

 

[makeuplover2]

Sure. But for someone who joined the site 4 hours ago - I'm just a little surprised at the level and description - especially since I have the necklace and earrrings. Of course, it's great. It certainly sounds like I may be able to trade it easily as there are people out there who find the necklace high quality.   Wish more MUT would just post a review right when they sign up - usually takes a little lurking for most.  Adds to the flavor for sure. 

 I have been lurking for over 4 years .  I did not want to join a site where people pick on others posts.   Thought that people seemed mean on here.  Now I see that I was right.    I love the necklace and earrings and wear stuff like that.  I am from France.  To get stuff like that at such a discount is a great deal at least for me.  Have a nice day ladies and TRY to enjoy your box   ... I know its hard to be happy /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[boxesandboxes]

 I have been lurking for over 4 years .  I did not want to join a site where people pick on others posts.   Thought that people seemed mean on here.  Now I see that I was right.    I love the necklace and earrings and wear stuff like that.  I am from France.  To get stuff like that at such a discount is a great deal at least for me.  Have a nice day ladies and TRY to enjoy your box   ... I know its hard to be happy /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

it is a great box...

 

[feisty1]

I can't wait for Provence. It was one of my favorite places. MET you have the best job! I only studied abroad but it was amazing. This box brings me happiness so thanks ladies. If I hadn't read this site I wouldn't have tried it. I was going to try French box but chose this one based on reviews from majority of you.

 

[MET]

feisty1, on 05 Mar 2015 - 9:49 PM, said:feisty1, on 05 Mar 2015 - 9:49 PM, said:I can't wait for Provence. It was one of my favorite places. MET you have the best job! I only studied abroad but it was amazing. This box brings me happiness so thanks ladies. If I hadn't read this site I wouldn't have tried it. I was going to try French box but chose this one based on reviews from majority of you.

Lucky you too - studying abroad is an amazing experience and really looks good on the CV/Resume.  I cannot wait for the 3rd box either (granted I haven't even received this one yet /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> )

 

[All the Lippies]

My apologies for offending everyone! I am undoubtedly older than most of you , with different tastes, and perhaps moved in different circles than others when I lived in France.  

I am too blunt for forums I think, and my "tone" comes across poorly.

Again, my apologies, and I won't have a need to comment any further!

 

[makeuplover2]

Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur is where I am from.    Aix is a college town and the streets are filled with all kinds of pubs and artist places.  The necklace that we got is something that I  have seen in that area sold in the market stands.  The area is Known for its lavender fields and olive and wine orchards.    I cannot wait to see what will be in the next box.  I am sure some soap and hand cream. Callissons  are traditional candy of Provence. they are like marzipan with icing on them. Many herbs are from this area too so they might be in the box ( probably not though) Perfume and items made of olive wood  too.  Looking forward to the next box.  Scarf is  big have to figure out how to wear it /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 

[feisty1]

I bought a pair of the cutest sandals at one of the market places. Soo cute. I wore them out and had then resoled twice before they died. Have been looking online to buy them again but have never found them. I need to go back!

 

[boxesandboxes]

Lucky you too - studying abroad is an amazing experience and really looks good on the CV/Resume.  I cannot wait for the 3rd box either (granted I haven't even received this one yet /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> )

Can't wait to hear about what items you got!

 

[MET]

boxesandboxes, on 05 Mar 2015 - 10:28 PM, said:Can't wait to hear about what items you got!

I will be happy with any of the variations and I really want the Hediard product (their chocolate wafers are to die for).

 

[All the Lippies]

@@makeuplover2  I only visited the It south a few times during our time in France. It reminded me a bit of San Clemente CA, where I was born and raised. 

My husband was a consultant for Arianespace; we lived in Paris (16th Arrondissement ) and had a small property in Sologne. 

My favorite region in France is Alsace-Lorraine. I lost weight in Paris, and gained it back every time we visited Strasbourg!

Again, my apologies for offending you.

 

[tinysurprise]

Omg...drama! Where's my popcorn

Even though I am not a fan of this second box, I do feel like all the brands and products are very French. The "younger" items like the tote and the earrings, from smaller, indie designers, which is cool. I Think the woman who curates the box is doing an amazing job with introducing new products and brands. I hope she keeps up the great, thoughtful work. Jewelry and clothing are hard...you can't always please everyone

Sincerely,

Someone who married a Frenchman.

 

[boxesandboxes]

Omg...drama! Where's my popcorn

you might get some really yummy caramels when your box arrives!

 

[makeuplover2]

@@makeuplover2  I only visited the It south a few times during our time in France. It reminded me a bit of San Clemente CA, where I was born and raised. 

My husband was a consultant for Arianespace; we lived in Paris (16th Arrondissement ) and had a small property in Sologne. 

My favorite region in France is Alsace-Lorraine. I lost weight in Paris, and gained it back every time we visited Strasbourg!

Again, my apologies for offending you.

 No problem was misunderstanding.  The 16th is the nicest richest area of Paris... must have been nice.

 No problem was misunderstanding.  The 16th is the nicest richest area of Paris... must have been nice.  I lived about a 3 hour train ride from there. 

 

[PrettyAndWitty]

Sooooooooo disappointed. My box contained the white sweater (the sweater is not my personal taste but ya know whatever it's a mystery box) but in a size medium, I'm an x-small or small. On top of that the front of the sweater is snagged in two places so I can't even e-bay the darn thing. The total value of my box is $401 (the sweater being valued at $200), which I wouldn't ordinarily complain about except that the value of the last box that I received was $370ish (the bulk of that one coming from a sweatshirt from Les Petites) when it was promised to be more than $400.

I received Myriam K and Sothys products in my previous box and this box and two sweaters that I'll never wear. Even though I'm a full fledged Francophile I'm really starting to wonder where the value of this sub is for me. My money might be better spent just finding a local French boutique and buying something that I'm really in love with. 

Sorry to be a negative Nelly. I hope everyone else is thoroughly enjoying their boxes! 

 

[jiblet]

@@tinysurprise  No, I think all of the jewelry is cheap looking. Some of the other color combinations are prettier, but they're all  Basic Beadwork, 101.  Not even nice beads. And that bracelet.... I just can't. I don't like the earrings at all, but everyone says they look better in person. Just not my style at all, and my experience of three years living in France leads me to believe that it is not going to be a hot ticket item there.  

 I hope I get the scarf, as I don't care for the sweater, and the cosmetics items seem nice enough, but all in all, this box off as something tailored to appeal to Americans, and I will be cancelling my sub. So there should be an opening!

I'm in total agreement. I do not care for this box at all. I received grey socks a grey scarf, tea, mascara, and a brown beaded neckkace. Oh yes and more leather/ gold ear rings. Ugh! The only thing I adore is the little bracelet blue red and white ribbon with an old coin as the scene stealer. Love it but it's not worth the price not even with the discount. Oui please is OUT. I am very disappointed.

 

[jiblet]

Sooooooooo disappointed. My box contained the white sweater (the sweater is not my personal taste but ya know whatever it's a mystery box) but in a size medium, I'm an x-small or small. On top of that the front of the sweater is snagged in two places so I can't even e-bay the darn thing. The total value of my box is $401 (the sweater being valued at $200), which I wouldn't ordinarily complain about except that the value of the last box that I received was $370ish (the bulk of that one coming from a sweatshirt from Les Petites) when it was promised to be more than $400.

I received Myriam K and Sothys products in my previous box and this box and two sweaters that I'll never wear. Even though I'm a full fledged Francophile I'm really starting to wonder where the value of this sub is for me. My money might be better spent just finding a local French boutique and buying something that I'm really in love with. 

 You are completely correct. You are absolutely better off finding a local Francophile boutique. Spend your money there.

Sorry to be a negative Nelly. I hope everyone else is thoroughly enjoying their boxes!