Memebox Spoilers!

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I originally bought both these boxes but cancelled them when I panicked at the thought of them having lots of CPM2 leftovers (I'm looking at you Revecen purple primer- how many can a girl need?). I might have a twinge of memebox envy just now but thankfully the 2 items I would most have wanted from the boxes -the Benton set- I already purchased during the cybersale.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Black Friday boxes looks nice. Good to see no more CPM2. Though not getting any box envies as it still shouts warehouse clearing to me. At least they did say it is items that previously appeared in boxes in the description so no lies there.

 
Both are fairly nice boxes, now I wish I picked up #4 as well. 

 
Im actually super happy with cleanse&tone (except no cleansing oil) and black friday 4+5 the expensive multi purpose cream and serum + benton does it for me. Whatever else they throw in I look at as a plus. Far better than 19$ petite/blackout for instance!

 
Really like the Cleanse & Tone, was expecting an oil cleanser, but happy to try the clean it zero instead.

BF4&5 look good too.

 
My problem with cleanse and tone is that 4 of the products have a retail value of less than $10 combined. It feels like it needs one more large product, a full size Banila cleanser would have been perfect.

 
I just received Oh My Lips and Pouch Essentials. I saw someone posted a spoiler photo of oh my lips. Has anyone posted one of Pouch Essentials yet?

Sorry for the ridiculously terrible photo quality. I'm stuck using my phone until my new camera arrives today. =D

I'm really new to MemeBox, but Pouch Essentials looks decent to me. It's a broad range of products. I am a little bummed to see the Rosemine lip balm in both Pouch Essentials and Oh My Lips (mint tea vs rose fairy, but still. meh).

nHCjzFt.jpg


ydehb5W.jpg


 
I just realized that the value of Pouch Essentials is absolutely terrible. 4.5 ml of the Hanskin makes it worth $6.57. I'm going to guess the Witch's Pouch is half size, so $7.50 (although I think it's probably more like a third). So that makes the box total $39.57.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ouch, yeah, the value on this sucks, and it's really makeup heavy which isn't going to thrill a lot of people (although maybe folks were expecting that considering the theme?). But that Hanskin sample is absolutely coveted, and yay for Witch's Pouch!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeah! Even at its tiny size, I'm happy to have the Hanskin. I've read great things. And only using a drop at a time, even the small bottle will last quite a while.

I haven't heard of Witch's Pouch before. It looks like a mini Benefit chacha tint. I got a warm coral-y, orange-y color. But the description sounds more like a gloss/stain/stick hybrid.

 
Pouch essentials looks good. I'm not sad I didn't buy it, but it looks good. Also...WITCH'S POUCH YASSSSSS!

 
The ridiculously low value of pouch essentials/ cleanse and tone/ oh my lips makes me pretty upset. The fact that they're all low-value boxes in one bundle...sigh.

Pouch essentials is awful for me. There may be a couple of items that I'll enjoy, but I have 2 of the hanskin that I haven't even touched yet. I already have the witches pouch item as well, and the rosemine lip balm coming in the lips box

Ugh these were some of my last boxes coming to me (other than brighten and correct/mask) and overall it's a general let-down feeling. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

Although THANK YOU @IndeliKate for posting the pouch spoilers! You're a peach! <3

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Maybe I'm just easy to please but I'm pretty happy with C&T. I feel like the Banilla Co is supposed to be the "oil" component, even though it is a balm. I'm currently going through a full size, but it'll be nice to have travel sizes. Excited about the toner, I've gotten the Tea Toc things three dang times now, and I'm not crazy about foaming citrus cleaners but I'll give it a shot. And I can always use another sheet mask and cleansing cloths. 

I got the BF#5, and I hate that I got the Steam Cream because that stuff clogs my pore like crazy. Will be trading that away asap. And I hate lip balms that come in tubs like that, so that'll be going too. I'll keep the hand cream and the BB to try... But what is that Hologram Collection thing???

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm happy with them. Very very glad about the Neogen toner. That is the star of the box for me!

Also I really like Ernesti cleansers, so happy to try it in another variation. The box needed one more full size product to make it great though. The essence mask is one time use and the wipes are only a pack of 10.

Agree with @@MissJexie that there should have been an oil cleanser. This would have been the box to do it.

The Lips box exceeded my expectations. It's a very fun and useful little box.

I will use all but one of the products. It's the best lip box by far. (in my opinion)

Is the Mizon essence not a pack of 30 sheets??

 

Latest posts

Back
Top