Wow I'm actually pretty happy with everything I'm seeing here- although I didn't pick up any of these boxes so I guess I shouldn't really get a say one way or the other LOL
Empties is a LOT more accurate than I was expecting. There are some products in there that I've really enjoyed, and the others are things I have seen mentioned in the past, so I think it's accurate and pretty nice overall for what people were hoping it would be. It could have been a lot worse from what I was seeing people put on that empties FB thread.
Elixirs looks fantastic! I really wanted to snag that box but never got around to it, so I'm bummed I missed out, but happy for everyone that got it! F/W Makeup actually could be a LOT worse. CPM eyeshadow, lip crayon and revecen could have some how ended up in there, so let's at least be happy that it's leftover-free.
I agree that there should have been some sort of neutral palette or shadow in there, but overall for a makeup box, it's not bad!
Green Food...erm. Well yea. Not so great...but again- lately I've been expecting the worst, so at least it's not absolutely terrible!