- Joined
- Sep 7, 2013
- Messages
- 8,060
- Reaction score
- 7,814
Memebox Spoilers!
- Thread starter ramblingsofkai
- Start date
Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:
- Joined
- Aug 13, 2013
- Messages
- 15
- Reaction score
- 39
I opened K Style first, so at least my disappointment never got worse than the first box of the 3. I actually like the OMG box. And MCWL 4 is disappointing as far as lack of any new cuteness but I can use/gift most of it (though I wouldn't wish the dung eyeliner on anybody). K Style was a tie for most disappointing next to Bloggers for me.
- Joined
- Aug 19, 2014
- Messages
- 423
- Reaction score
- 551
@@biancardi that is exactly what I was hoping for out of the OMG boxes. Novel/unique/omg ingredients.
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2014
- Messages
- 192
- Reaction score
- 162
This emptying the warehouse into boxes that were purchased months ago is just gross, IMO. I have this sinking feeling about what I'm going to get in my boxes that should be shipping by the end of the month. I don't know what Memebox's business plan is, but this is pretty crappy to do to their customers, especially when they've been holding onto the money for the boxes for months.
I'm glad I cancelled cute 4! I'd have gotten many duplicates! ^^
After seeing all these boxes, I'm even happier to have bought the thanksgiving boxes! ^^
After seeing all these boxes, I'm even happier to have bought the thanksgiving boxes! ^^
I'm just done with any cute,k-style and omg. What a way to ruin a series that couldv'e been the best ever.. The MCWL 1 were one of the BEST boxes out there and made alot of people interested. But you've just ruined it all..
I'm super scared my petite treasures and lovely boutique will be just the same. More leftovers. More CPM stuff.. Like, I'm filing a complaint about that K-style box, maybe even MCWL. I didn't sign up for that shit. I woulda bought CPM2 if I were interested.
I'm super scared my petite treasures and lovely boutique will be just the same. More leftovers. More CPM stuff.. Like, I'm filing a complaint about that K-style box, maybe even MCWL. I didn't sign up for that shit. I woulda bought CPM2 if I were interested.
Feel the same way. Now wondering what other crap they are going to shove in the boxes still to come before the end of the year. If its more disappointment, I will be going elsewhere in the new year
Same, they better step up their game. Those leftovers should've gone in another jackpot kinda box, so you knew what you were possibly getting. So not fair to force these products onto us. And they probably have more, so I'm seriously concerned about how much more they will be putting in our boxes. I will throw up if I see more Shara shara, cheek room, hope girl or revecen. It's not funny no more, memespies..
I'm actually excited for MCW4. I've been wanting to try the Appletox, and it certainly is cute! I'll get a couple of repeats, but that's okay.
In regards to the repeated items, I agree that KStyle4 is ridiculous since it has multiple items that were all in one other box, but items have been repeated in boxes many times before now. The vitamin cleanser was in MCW2 and Cacao, the Snow White eyeliners were in MCW1 and CPM1, and the LJH Tea Tree essence, the foam berry cleanser, and the Bounce Cheese Cream have all shown up in multiple boxes. This is not really a new move on Memebox's part.
I'm not trying to start an argument at all! Just trying to ease concerns about future boxes, really--I don't think this means that future boxes are doomed.
ETA: I do think that MCW4 is a cuter box than MCW3 and even MCW2!
In regards to the repeated items, I agree that KStyle4 is ridiculous since it has multiple items that were all in one other box, but items have been repeated in boxes many times before now. The vitamin cleanser was in MCW2 and Cacao, the Snow White eyeliners were in MCW1 and CPM1, and the LJH Tea Tree essence, the foam berry cleanser, and the Bounce Cheese Cream have all shown up in multiple boxes. This is not really a new move on Memebox's part.
I'm not trying to start an argument at all! Just trying to ease concerns about future boxes, really--I don't think this means that future boxes are doomed.
ETA: I do think that MCW4 is a cuter box than MCW3 and even MCW2!
Last edited by a moderator:
I think there's a difference between one repeat item (like in Dry and Sensitive) and a lot of repeat items (like K-style and MCW). Those two boxes look like no thought was put into them at all and they just grabbed random items they had a lot of and tossed them in the box. And they aren't even repeat items that people have loved or asked for, just stuff they overstocked because they grossly overestimated the demand for CPM2. That's why I have concerns about future boxes. Not every box needs to blow me away and have an extremely high value, but I don't want a collection of random "stuff".
Yeah we kind expected bits of CMP2 to pop up in different boxes, but 3 in one is too much
I agree that the multiple repeats from CPM2 in KStyle4 is excessive, I just don't think MCW4 is really in the same boat (I know it still has several repeats, but they are at least from different boxes). That's just how I see it, though! I still have hope for my upcoming Memeboxes 
/emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
/emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
well I'm happy with the Thanksgiving boxes, OMG and MCW are mostly usable for me, but I really feel for the people who ordered K-Style. What a shitty thing to do. People didn't want that crap box to start with and then to go and offload the worst if it into K-Style is awful!
I'm on a break now, I don't trust them anymore. The lack of communication is one thing but to reuse a bunch of awful products in what should have been a decent box is beyond a snub to their customers. I'm going to wait til he beginning if the year to see if they get their crap together.
I'm on a break now, I don't trust them anymore. The lack of communication is one thing but to reuse a bunch of awful products in what should have been a decent box is beyond a snub to their customers. I'm going to wait til he beginning if the year to see if they get their crap together.
Oh and someone needs to talk their other half in to reviewing the manly mask. If loooove to read THAT review!
- Joined
- Oct 3, 2014
- Messages
- 663
- Reaction score
- 312
I'm very disappointed - nothing cute about it at all, and I feel like I've seen it all before
Last edited by a moderator:
- Joined
- Sep 7, 2013
- Messages
- 8,060
- Reaction score
- 7,814
oh, I agree - it isn't cute. But at least it has products that I will use or feel good about gifting and not be creeped out by weird dollies -lol
I wish they would have put a bunny spray or one of the princess fruit glosses in there - oh well.
As has already been mentioned, it seems that these may have been the last boxes in the MCW/OMG/KStyle series, which I think is a good thing. I was honestly surprised when they released a second MCW. I bought all four MCW boxes hoping for something as good as the first, but I'd really rather see what else Memebox can bring to the table at this point.
