I'm not sure if I want to resubscribe, so I looked back at the previous months to see how much everything got used:
August - I do use the Kaleidoscope a lot, and love it. Only used the lipstick once for swatching and never again. Kabuki brush is sitting in my makeup bag. The liner feathered on me like crazy so I had to toss it.
September - Those cream eye shadows were a disaster, I swatched and never used them again. I can't find any creative uses for them, because they're terrible as a base, too.
October - The serum is still unused, sitting in the box it came in. I do intend to use it though.
November - I use heated curler, so this curler is kind of useless for me. The eye pencil is being used a lot, there's only about half of it left now (it was probably my most used product from an LMdB box). The lash serum I always keep forgetting about, but I do use it sometimes.
December - Love that blush Kaleidoscope! Always get compliments when I wear those colors on my cheeks.
January - Great makeup remover, I plan to purchase more of that generic version on Amazon.
February - Nail polishes and lippie. Everything got swatched once and never used again. I forgot they even existed, and now that I remember, I don't have the urge to start using them.
March - Concealer + eye patch. Love and used both.
April - Powder. Love it, and use daily. The color matches me really well.
May - Both are great colors on me, I should use them more often.
Based on this list, it sure looks like I should subscribe, but I'm just worried that they will send out more lippie colors that I just can't wear. I know that it's all about having fun experimenting, but I'm at a point in my life where I know what I like and what suits me, and a deep brown lipstick is not one of those things.