Indie Polish Lovers

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
My honest opinion: It's all in the marketing. A purposefully limited supply creates high demand despite the fact that there are far superior polishes on the market that are much more easily obtained. Combine that with the whole "scheduled restocks" and "limited edition" collections and colors gimmick which gives the illusion of exclusivity. People eat that ish up. I'm not one of them. 
wink.gif

Right, but she's not making any money off the $50 resales on eBay unlike Lynnderella who's selling her stuff via auction now. I think there is just too high a demand. I agree it's marketing but I do think their polishes are magical. If you can find me dupes for the beattles collection I will gladly bow to you :p /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

ALSO since you admit to never having tried the polishes, how do you know what their formula is like? Most of the reviews I've read tend to say the formula is phenomenal. *shrugs*


Who said I never tried them? Just because I don't buy in to it does not mean that I don't own any. I actually own 2 EP's. A Little Fishy Told Me & a green glitterbomb whose name escapes me that I got in a Llarowe mystery bag. It takes more than a marketing gimmick and a decent formula to wow me. I will say that EP is miles ahead of Lynnderella from what I've seen. I'm not a fan of glitterbombs so I pay exactly zero attention to what Lynnderella puts out.

 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Loves Halloween... does not like Nightmare Before Christmas... Does. Not. Compute. XD
Hahaha, I've got a worse conundrum for you--I hate Halloween, and I love the Nightmare Before Christmas.

 
Quote: Originally Posted by pinkgemini /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I am a newbie to the world of indie polishes. Actually I just purchased my first one (holo top coat) on Etsy recently. So nobody kill me when I ask this
smile.gif
, but what's all the hoopla about Enchanted Polish about? This is a genuine question, I'm not saying they are not gorgeous shades from the swatches I've seen, but what makes them sell like hotcakes over other brands? I searched them on eBay last night and several have sold for $50+!!! Enlighten and inform me please.
Enchanted Polish is very pretty, sometimes droolworthy even. No polish is worth $50 to me. $20 max for any polish, and I haven't found one yet that I would even spend that on. While they are gorgeous, I think the limited nature gets to people sometimes, maybe the thrill of the hunt.

 
Hahaha, I've got a worse conundrum for you--I hate Halloween, and I love the Nightmare Before Christmas.
Most people I know consider it to be a Christmas movie. Fortune Cookie Soap is actually doing a Christmas collection based on it this year. Christmas FREAKS ME OUT (in a bad way), but I love seasonal stuff.
 
Quote: Originally Posted by meaganola /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by sleepykat /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Hahaha, I've got a worse conundrum for you--I hate Halloween, and I love the Nightmare Before Christmas.

Most people I know consider it to be a Christmas movie. Fortune Cookie Soap is actually doing a Christmas collection based on it this year. Christmas FREAKS ME OUT (in a bad way), but I love seasonal stuff. I don't like Christmas, either, but I love Tim Burton style stuff.

So I'm not into Lynderella polishes for the most part. They are usually too chunky and pricy for me. But I just saw the first one that I love, called Mystery Man (photo is from a blog that I follow called Oh Three Oh Four):



 
Quote: Originally Posted by sleepykat /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by meaganola /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by sleepykat /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Hahaha, I've got a worse conundrum for you--I hate Halloween, and I love the Nightmare Before Christmas.

Most people I know consider it to be a Christmas movie. Fortune Cookie Soap is actually doing a Christmas collection based on it this year. Christmas FREAKS ME OUT (in a bad way), but I love seasonal stuff. I don't like Christmas, either, but I love Tim Burton style stuff.

So I'm not into Lynderella polishes for the most part. They are usually too chunky and pricy for me. But I just saw the first one that I love, called Mystery Man (photo is from a blog that I follow called Oh Three Oh Four):



 Oooooo... that is gorgeous! I'm a sucker for green/purple combos. 

 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
My honest opinion: It's all in the marketing. A purposefully limited supply creates high demand despite the fact that there are far superior polishes on the market that are much more easily obtained. Combine that with the whole "scheduled restocks" and "limited edition" collections and colors gimmick which gives the illusion of exclusivity. People eat that ish up. I'm not one of them. 
wink.gif



Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  TBH i'm not sure either. maybe it's partly the beautiful colours and partly really good branding. Enchanted Polish is enchanting and their packaging is adorable and gorgeous, like the colour. There's really very little not to like.

As for why it's reached (almost) Lynnderella levels of crazy, I'm not really sure... but I don't understand the hoopla about Lynnderella either. : Then again I don't like glitter.

Honestly if there's a way for Chelsea to go semi-private, she can make bank on it. To put it in perspective, she has 41k likes on FB. deborah lippman has 23k,


Quote: Originally Posted by sleepykat /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Enchanted Polish is very pretty, sometimes droolworthy even. No polish is worth $50 to me. $20 max for any polish, and I haven't found one yet that I would even spend that on. While they are gorgeous, I think the limited nature gets to people sometimes, maybe the thrill of the hunt.
Thanks for the replies, ladies!

 


Hit Polish calendar updated and OMG the Dark Crystal theme bag.  I didn't get her Willy Wonka one because of I ran out of money but I want to see some swatches!!!

 
Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  tiny screams

you know how i was like, a few weeks about dance legend I HAVE TO HAVE THESE DUOCHROMES??



LLAROWE IS GOING TO STOCK THEM *___* http://nails.annagorelova.com/dance-legend-chameleon-collection-fall-2013/

I saw that yesterday! I need to figure out how similar these are to ILNP's Ultra Chromes so I know which shades to order. 

smilehappyyes.gif


 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
I saw that yesterday! I need to figure out how similar these are to ILNP's Ultra Chromes so I know which shades to order. 

smilehappyyes.gif


I'm hoping since they're all minis that they'll be cheaper and I'll order all of them.

Actually, based on the way the swatches look, a lot of the colours seem similar to the EP Beattles polishes sans holographic glitter....which I can also get behind. I hope they'll be thick enough to do nail art with!

 
Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
I saw that yesterday! I need to figure out how similar these are to ILNP's Ultra Chromes so I know which shades to order. 

smilehappyyes.gif


I'm hoping since they're all minis that they'll be cheaper and I'll order all of them.

Actually, based on the way the swatches look, a lot of the colours seem similar to the EP Beattles polishes sans holographic glitter....which I can also get behind. I hope they'll be thick enough to do nail art with!


I didn't see anything about them being minis. Anything that makes them more obtainable is fine with me though. I have heard they are 2-coaters so nail art seems like a definite possibilty if that's true. 

 
Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
I didn't see anything about them being minis. Anything that makes them more obtainable is fine with me though. I have heard they are 2-coaters so nail art seems like a definite possibilty if that's true. 

I was definitely confused when someone said something on the FB thread, but it's pretty obvious it's true. I wish the bottles had something on the front that confirmed the size though

A full size Dance Legend polish, from the Llarowe site:

448ffdb00f51484cb83fb78717e82d06


And one from the swatches from that blog links he posted:

Dance_Legend_Chameleon_collection_Boggs_091_01.jpg


very obviously smaller/not the same bottle.

 
Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  Quote: Originally Posted by MissTrix /img/forum/go_quote.gif
 
I didn't see anything about them being minis. Anything that makes them more obtainable is fine with me though. I have heard they are 2-coaters so nail art seems like a definite possibilty if that's true. 

I was definitely confused when someone said something on the FB thread, but it's pretty obvious it's true. I wish the bottles had something on the front that confirmed the size though

A full size Dance Legend polish, from the Llarowe site:

448ffdb00f51484cb83fb78717e82d06


And one from the swatches from that blog links he posted:

Dance_Legend_Chameleon_collection_Boggs_091_01.jpg


very obviously smaller/not the same bottle.


I can't believe I didn't notice that! 

 
Quote: Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  tiny screams

you know how i was like, a few weeks about dance legend I HAVE TO HAVE THESE DUOCHROMES??



LLAROWE IS GOING TO STOCK THEM *___* http://nails.annagorelova.com/dance-legend-chameleon-collection-fall-2013/

OMG so excited.  I've been completely slammed at work this week and have hardly ventured onto MUT or anywhere else in blogland.  This is the first thing I've seen online since my unplanned embargo, and I LIKEY.

 
I have to confess that I am crossing my fingers and hoping that Hit Polish has a _Labyrinth_ mini collection up its sleeve.  And _The Neverending Story_.  And _The Goonies_, _The Last Starfighter_, and _Explorers_.  But especially _Labyrinth_.  That needs to happen.  I will keep on buying these collections as long as my pre-college years keep getting represented in nail polish form!

 
Quote: Originally Posted by meaganola /img/forum/go_quote.gif
  I have to confess that I am crossing my fingers and hoping that Hit Polish has a _Labyrinth_ mini collection up its sleeve.  And _The Neverending Story_.  And _The Goonies_, _The Last Starfighter_, and _Explorers_.  But especially _Labyrinth_.  That needs to happen.  I will keep on buying these collections as long as my pre-college years keep getting represented in nail polish form!
Did you see her theme box is the Dark Crystal???  I could see any of these happening!  You should totally email her and tell her.  I love Rachel.  I have contacted her a few times with questions and comments and she's very sweet.

 
Did you see her theme box is the Dark Crystal???  I could see any of these happening!  You should totally email her and tell her.  I love Rachel.  I have contacted her a few times with questions and comments and she's very sweet.
Yeah, seeing the _Dark Crystal_ collection was what got my mind rolling down the _Labyrinth_ direction. My favorite perfume company has a _Labyrinth_ collection and is getting ready to launch a _Dark Crystal_ collection very soon! I always feel weird making suggestions like this. I think I figure that if a creative person is going to do something, it's going to be on their radar whether I say anything or not. But I do love making lists and pondering this sort of thing out loud/on forums.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top