Down the Indie Rabbit Hole

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I love liquid lipsticks, so I have bookmarked the Sweetpea & Fay site to browse when I am more sensible!

Here is the last set of swatches - I apologize if there are any mistakes in this post, I have already taken my nighttime meds and they tend to make me loopy. Also, by the time I took these, the natural light was failing and it totally ruined the swatch of Key Lime. My bad! But the color from the indoors photo is very true to color, so you should still get a good idea. The reason it took so long is because I simple cannot find three of my tubes. Pandora, Platonic and Bombshell have all just up and vanished. I think they are in a purse, somewhere, but I haven't the foggiest which one. So sorry! :blush:

Anyways, these are the more "untraditional" colors I own. Of them all, Melancholy and Space Cadet are the easiest to wear. Space Cadet is nicely textured, more cool-toned than Storque (but not too cool-toned) and the color is a dupe for LC's D'Lilac. Melancholy is difficult to apply due to the dry texture, but it is a lovely deep purple and can be worn on the lighter side (similar to the indoors picture) or the darker side (more what you see in the natural light). Bon Bon, is for me, the most difficult to wear, color wise. It is a very cool toned grey and wearing it with the wrong clothing/makeup makes my teeth look super yellow. I usually pass on this color unless I want to tone down something that is a little too warm. The hardest to wear, application wise, is Smoking Gun. The swatch on the Impulse website makes it seem like a beautiful dark navy, but I have found that it is nearly impossible to replicate that color. What you get is either much too light (see swatch) or much too dark (lip swatch, below). The only way to get a true navy lip, from what I have played around with, is mixing and layering with a lighter color. Bon Bon is a good one, or the new color Tart might work, although I don't own it to test that theory. You can see how much I had to work the color out on Melancholy and Smoking Gun. The other three are just a clean swipe. (Bon Bon and Key Lime from the tube, Space Cadet with my finger from the palette.)

So yeah - Impulse's lip swatches are a bit deceiving. They admit this right on the website, sooo... I don't even know. I just buy them and figure WTH, I can make it work somehow.



This is my lip swatch of Smoking Gun. I did it for a gal on Facebook who wanted to see what it would take to build up a really deep blue color. A couple things to note - in the areas it looks black, that is bad lighting. The lip color does look blue, you can see it in the very center of my lower lip where my lights were actually hitting just right (this was taken indoors, at night, with no flash). The edges are lighter than the rest of my lips due to the cleaning I had to do to make them even. All in all, it took about 15-20 minutes to achieve this deep of a color.



I hope that is helpful - I am more than willing to do more lip swatches if anyone is interested. I have neutral/leaning yellow undertones and my lips are naturally quite pigmented, so they do tend to change the color of more sheer lipsticks - a problem I haven't have with any of Impulse's lipsticks. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
THANK YOU MUCH!! Adding metro to my basket! And maybe space cadet too!

 
You're all very welcome! I am basically addicted to these lipsticks, so I am glad to put it to some use, ha ha! ;) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

With that being said, my Aromaleigh order shipped yesterday, so I am *really* excited to try some of these loose shadows. On the whole, I only use pressed, but I might become a convert due to this thread!

 
So my empty 5g jars arrived today and I transferred my Hello Waffle samples (two sample sets of the Painted Flowers collection on the left) into them and it makes my Hello Waffle collection look massive! And I still want more - I think I have a problem... :blink:

I'm planning on making boxes to put the Painted Flowers collection similar to how I made a box for the Musician collection.

Hello Waffle Collection.JPG

Also, Chinovi cosmetics has a 30% off sale for orders $10 or more (excludes the Paper Runway collection) with code 500LIKES - ends 10pm PST tomorrow (July 11th).  http://chinovicosmetics.com/

 
Whoo! I have tracking on my Notoriously Morbid Out to the Black order! I wasn't expecting that for another week or so!

 
I placed an order from Shiro for my Swap Buddy.  I know they just had a big sale, so shipping may take a while.  Do they send something when they ship, or does a package just show up?  If one of you Shiro fans could let me know, I'd appreciate it.  Thanks!

 
I placed an order from Shiro for my Swap Buddy.  I know they just had a big sale, so shipping may take a while.  Do they send something when they ship, or does a package just show up?  If one of you Shiro fans could let me know, I'd appreciate it.  Thanks!
Yes - Shiro sends an email saying that your order is complete and they include a tracking number :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I received the shipping info for my Aromaleigh order - so excited!

Also, the Notoriously Morbid Free Day Friday is free shipping on orders $10 and over and includes a free mini of Pale Rider or Tea Tosh (make a note in the comments saying which one you want) - code: JULYFDFFS

Ends 12:00am EDT on 7/12

 
My Aromaleigh order came today! I haven't cracked into them, but I am already excited because they sent several extra samples that the one I requested! :D /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I can't wait to see how they all look on the skin!

@@chibimorph where do you get the empty jars? I can't find any with sifters locally, but don't know where to order online. Any suggestions that can come in bulk but aren't too expensive?

ETA: Also, this thread is worse than the Enablers thread. I totally just placed ANOTHER order, because I can't pass up the words "free shipping". :blink:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
ETA: Also, this thread is worse than the Enablers thread. I totally just placed ANOTHER order, because I can't pass up the words "free shipping". :blink:
I totally agree.....on every single level.

I am dying to put in an order with My Pretty Zombie and Lunatick Cosmetics.....DYING.

Also, I have a question for you lovely ladies. I have been on the fence about Limecrime for a while now. I discovered them far after the big repackaging blowup and have heard a ton of bad things about this company. I have also heard that their lip velvetines formulas are to die for so I just dont know what to make of them. Have they gotten better? Is there an alternative to the velvetines? Have you been wronged by Limecrime or have a true pro or con stance on the company? I'm not trying to start a war, I just really would appreciate the feedback.

 
Oooo that green looks pretty!

Doromouse from hello waffle was super glittery! I put it on this morning and had to take it off because that was wayyyy too disco ball for the insurance office, even on a Friday ;) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
I totally agree.....on every single level.

I am dying to put in an order with My Pretty Zombie and Lunatick Cosmetics.....DYING.

Also, I have a question for you lovely ladies. I have been on the fence about Limecrime for a while now. I discovered them far after the big repackaging blowup and have heard a ton of bad things about this company. I have also heard that their lip velvetines formulas are to die for so I just dont know what to make of them. Have they gotten better? Is there an alternative to the velvetines? Have you been wronged by Limecrime or have a true pro or con stance on the company? I'm not trying to start a war, I just really would appreciate the feedback.
 Here is my honest advice for anyone considering making a purchase from any company, regardless of "scandal" or what not. If you want the product then you should not let anyone else's opinions about the company or product in question make your decision. It is your life, and your money and if you think that the product is worth the money you are willing to pay for it, that is all that matters.

As for my personal opinion - no, I would not support Lime Crime. Their shadows are nothing special and their lipsticks are hideously overpriced - basically you are paying for "cutesy" packaging and quirky names. The formula is terrible and as more and more companies offer similar items, I think Lime Crime's cult status will be affected.

That said, the Velvetines are a good product, the best that they offer IMO. However, they are EXTREMELY dupeable, off the top of my head is Kat Von D's new Everlasting Love Liquid Lipsticks which are a dollar cheaper. So, again, depends on how badly you want to own a "cult" item, I guess.

I have two lipsticks, one shadow palette and two Velvetines. I personally won't purchase from Lime Crime again. Hope that helps you, but again - do what YOU want to do, not what someone on the internet tells you. ;) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

ETA: That came off really patronizing, and that was not my intent at all - obviously everyone can make their own choice without blindly following the crowd :lol: But I was thinking of my own experience, and so the wording didn't come out right - sorry about that!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thank you so much Shalott!
I didn't find it patronizing at all. It was very genuine and honest. :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I really appreciate it. I agree that everyone should order based on their wants and not strictly read into things online and I don't judge others for supporting companies I wouldn't myself. I didn't know that Kat Von D has a similar lip product...hmm. Thanks again for this thread, Ive learned so much from you all :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
Last edited by a moderator:
My Aromaleigh order came today! I haven't cracked into them, but I am already excited because they sent several extra samples that the one I requested! :D /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I can't wait to see how they all look on the skin!

@@chibimorph where do you get the empty jars? I can't find any with sifters locally, but don't know where to order online. Any suggestions that can come in bulk but aren't too expensive?

ETA: Also, this thread is worse than the Enablers thread. I totally just placed ANOTHER order, because I can't pass up the words "free shipping". :blink:
Coastal Scents sells jars: http://www.coastalscents.com/make-your-own/packaging/jars.html

 
@@Shalott In this particular instance, I got jars from Amazon as an add-on item (these jars don't come with sifters). However, I really want to try the jars that Coastal Scents sells because they're cheaper per unit - however, I hate paying for shipping and Coastal Scents has free shipping at $50 (I had been waiting for a brush sale, but I recently got a bunch of Real Techniques brushes so I'm waiting for the next time the brushes are 50% off to get jars, too). I know people also buy jars from TKB Trading (which supplies a lot of indie companies).

@ I think my main issue with indie company controversies related to repackaging in particular is safety (similar to the level of sanitation issues like fingerprints in jars). These are small companies with basically no formal regulation so we're relying on the owner's word that everything is safe and handled carefully - so we're expecting integrity from the business. However, things like repackaging bring this integrity into suspect - and also, with repackaging we don't know exactly where the product actually came from which is another safety issue.

But in other happier words - I just received shipping info for my Shiro CotM order!

 
I'm so glad I found this thread!  I was looking for indie companies for the summerswap.  I've heard some indie companies mentioned here and there, but this thread has a lot of information, ideas, and deal sharing.  I just placed an order and (I know I shouldn't have, but I have a hard time resisting pretty, shimmery things) I grabbed a sample for myself to try out too.  If they are even half as pretty as they look in the pictures, I'm in trouble!  Thank you all for sharing your experiences, knowledge, and swatches!

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Latest posts

Back
Top