Birchbox: The June Box discussion

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
For me, the value of Birchbox is that I get to see brands and products that are new to me.  Whether I like what they send or not, I go to the Birchbox website and see what other products they might have for that brand, and I go to the brand websites and see all the products they offer.  It's about learning about stuff I would never find out about otherwise.  I like the descriptions on of the products on the Birchbox website.  Sometimes they are better than the ones on the actual product website. 

I do not like that everyone seems to get stuff they would never use, but I signed up for Birchbox to be exposed to new things and I knew up front that not all the samples would be something I would like.  Don't get me wrong, I can complain with the best of them, but but it's gotten to the point where I just want to say <<Trade It If You Don't Like It>>.  I have resolved to complain less and start taking part in the Birchbox Trade Forum/Thread.

I really hate that I left the most negative feedback possible on the 2 perfume samples I've received, and both times, a day after I left the feedback, Birchbox sent me an e-mail titled something like "How to Choose an Age-Appropriate Scent" featuring only the perfume I had just left the feedback for.  There were not even any other perfumes mentioned.  Viva La Juicy in my April box and Arquiste L'Etrog in my May box.  Ick.  I'm not interested in "age-appropriate."  I changed my age from 33 to 25 on my Beauty Profile.  I am hoping that made a difference if they send me a perfume sample in my June box. 

I like getting samples and reviewing them.  And what I don't use or plan to trade, I give away.  What bugs me is the size of the samples sometimes (Dr. Jart BB Cream), the April BeFine moisturizer being expired, and the fact that they sent me ALL leftover samples from previous months in my April Welcome Box, except the expired BeFine, which was new that month, I think, but still expired. 

I agree about the value of the box.  I don't care how much it's worth as long as I can use the samples (or somebody else can) and they don't substitute a lifestyle extra for a real sample, like they seem to have done in the past.  Also, I have found value in the Birchbox point system and the fact that any product I see in someone else's Birchbox I can go to the website and other places online and find more information, and then buy a full size if I want to.  I bought the Orange Sanguine perfume by Atelier I saw in the April boxes.  I love it.  I got the 30ml size.

It's about the whole Birchbox experience.  My box might suck, but I get to review the products and get points anyway, and I get to find products I love because I get to see what everybody else is getting in their Birchbox, too.  I would not like a subscription service where nobody knows what anybody else got. 

Originally Posted by kawaiimeows /img/forum/go_quote.gif

how do you really know it's going to be lame based on the weight?

i really don't care about my value of my birchbox (though it can be an awesome plus), i mean if it's worth more than ten dollars then it's already my money's worth, obviously we should be mad if it's worth less. but, last month for example, some people had high value boxes because they had big samples of anti-aging cream worth like $20 plus a full size stila.

i didn't feel cheated or like i didn't get my money's worth just because my box was "worth" less money wise compared to those, because i actually got products i was interested in and want to use. i wasn't interested in a $20 sample of anti-aging cream, even if that box was worth a ton because i had no use for it. and that's why birchbox can't simply just balance out the boxes so everyone gets their money's worth.
 
Originally Posted by luckylilme /img/forum/go_quote.gif


 I wish you would. I'm curious about that pillow box. They have a special going for $5 bucks but I'm scared to make the investment if it's not worth it. #alacheap lol
they send decent products. they don't have various boxes like birchbox. it's like myglam for women of color (everyone gets just about the same thing). the only thing that annoys me about msb is that they put too many hair products in their boxes. i have been a member since april and i have yet to completely dislike a box.

 
Originally Posted by peridotcricket /img/forum/go_quote.gif

For me, the value of Birchbox is that I get to see brands and products that are new to me.  Whether I like what they send or not, I go to the Birchbox website and see what other products they might have for that brand, and I go to the brand websites and see all the products they offer.  It's about learning about stuff I would never find out about otherwise.  I like the descriptions on of the products on the Birchbox website.  Sometimes they are better than the ones on the actual product website. 

I do not like that everyone seems to get stuff they would never use, but I signed up for Birchbox to be exposed to new things and I knew up front that not all the samples would be something I would like.  Don't get me wrong, I can complain with the best of them, but but it's gotten to the point where I just want to say <<Trade It If You Don't Like It>>.  I have resolved to complain less and start taking part in the Birchbox Trade Forum/Thread.

I really hate that I left the most negative feedback possible on the 2 perfume samples I've received, and both times, a day after I left the feedback, Birchbox sent me an e-mail titled something like "How to Choose an Age-Appropriate Scent" featuring only the perfume I had just left the feedback for.  There were not even any other perfumes mentioned.  Viva La Juicy in my April box and Arquiste L'Etrog in my May box.  Ick.  I'm not interested in "age-appropriate."  I changed my age from 33 to 25 on my Beauty Profile.  I am hoping that made a difference if they send me a perfume sample in my June box. 

I like getting samples and reviewing them.  And what I don't use or plan to trade, I give away.  What bugs me is the size of the samples sometimes (Dr. Jart BB Cream), the April BeFine moisturizer being expired, and the fact that they sent me ALL leftover samples from previous months in my April Welcome Box, except the expired BeFine, which was new that month, I think, but still expired. 

I agree about the value of the box.  I don't care how much it's worth as long as I can use the samples (or somebody else can) and they don't substitute a lifestyle extra for a real sample, like they seem to have done in the past.  Also, I have found value in the Birchbox point system and the fact that any product I see in someone else's Birchbox I can go to the website and other places online and find more information, and then buy a full size if I want to.  I bought the Orange Sanguine perfume by Atelier I saw in the April boxes.  I love it.  I got the 30ml size.

It's about the whole Birchbox experience.  My box might suck, but I get to review the products and get points anyway, and I get to find products I love because I get to see what everybody else is getting in their Birchbox, too.  I would not like a subscription service where nobody knows what anybody else got. 
I definitely like the aspect of trying new things as well.  I'm just worried I will end up getting a product I got last month (based on the weight of mybox) espec since you can't review a product twice.  

 
Originally Posted by mjkdior713 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I definitely like the aspect of trying new things as well.  I'm just worried I will end up getting a product I got last month (based on the weight of mybox) espec since you can't review a product twice.  
i might be wrong, but i remember reading in a past thread that since you're not supposed to receive the same item twice, they'll compensate you with points if you email them, i might be wrong about that, but it's worth a shot if it does happen.

 
Originally Posted by kawaiimeows /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Quote: Originally Posted by mjkdior713 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I definitely like the aspect of trying new things as well.  I'm just worried I will end up getting a product I got last month (based on the weight of mybox) espec since you can't review a product twice.  
i might be wrong, but i remember reading in a past thread that since you're not supposed to receive the same item twice, they'll compensate you with points if you email them, i might be wrong about that, but it's worth a shot if it does happen.


This is what the Birchbox FAQ says about this: "We are also truly committed to never sending you the same sample twice! Please contact us if this happens."
 
Originally Posted by kawaiimeows /img/forum/go_quote.gif

i might be wrong, but i remember reading in a past thread that since you're not supposed to receive the same item twice, they'll compensate you with points if you email them, i might be wrong about that, but it's worth a shot if it does happen.
Good to know, thx

 
Originally Posted by astokes /img/forum/go_quote.gif


This is what the Birchbox FAQ says about this: "We are also truly committed to never sending you the same sample twice! Please contact us if this happens."
Ok cool.  Is it likely 2 completely different boxes can weight exactly the same?? 

 
Weight is subjective to the products. This is why posting weights has no bearing because items with liquids are never exactly the same. If you go to the store and pull three identical bottles of say Dove shampoo in a clear bottle you may find one bottle filled all the way to the top, one filled near the top and one filled no where near the top.

 
Originally Posted by zadidoll /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Weight is subjective to the products. This is why posting weights has no bearing because items with liquids are never exactly the same. If you go to the store and pull three identical bottles of say Dove shampoo in a clear bottle you may find one bottle filled all the way to the top, one filled near the top and one filled no where near the top.
Ok, thank you.

 
one thing i have to add...  some of the bb boxes i saw i was getting on my page, and thought i would hate, ended up being my faves..  they turned me on to some products i NEVER would have bought just to try..  i have joked a few times bb knows me better than i know myself, because some of the products i would deem uneccesary, ended up being faves............... 

 
Originally Posted by mjkdior713 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Ok cool.  Is it likely 2 completely different boxes can weight exactly the same?? 
My box weighed .480 exactly and a few other people had boxes that were like .470 and we had different boxes.

 
Originally Posted by Jess Bailey /img/forum/go_quote.gif

my original shipping notice said it wouldn't arrive until Monday, but the box arrived today! weight: 0.4810

450

i'm not over the moon about it, but it could have been worse for me.
that bulgari perfume is great!!!  i think its a good box!

 
Originally Posted by HelloLeilani /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Still no shipping email for me. My glam bag, however, will be here tomorrow. Come onnnnnnnnn BB.
Same scenario for me too. nothing from BB, MG is in my city right now, s/b delivered tomorrow.. can't wait!!

 
Originally Posted by Jess Bailey /img/forum/go_quote.gif

my original shipping notice said it wouldn't arrive until Monday, but the box arrived today! weight: 0.4810

450

i'm not over the moon about it, but it could have been worse for me.
Those bandaids are awesome ! 

 
Originally Posted by Foureaves /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Same scenario for me too. nothing from BB, MG is in my city right now, s/b delivered tomorrow.. can't wait!!
My MG should be here Monday. But still notta from BB.

 
Can I just say I absolutely LOVEEEEEEEE the.....

 lipstain and i HATE lipstick or anything that goes on your lips for that matter... It's kinda sticky at first but I just think it's such a gorgeous color. I got scared by the deep red but it fades into SUCH a pretty pink. I would definitely consider buying this outside of my BB sub. 
 
Originally Posted by Jess Bailey /img/forum/go_quote.gif

my original shipping notice said it wouldn't arrive until Monday, but the box arrived today! weight: 0.4810

450

i'm not over the moon about it, but it could have been worse for me.
As much as I like that fragrance I got it twice last month, I am still surprised that they are sending out some of the same samples as last month

 
Got my box today!  It was the one with the

Staniac, stretch mark cream, face cream, hand wipes, men's cologne and band aids.
It weighed .4763, if anyone is wondering.

I'm happy with it!!  I'm sure I'll actually use all of it.  I'm also pretty excited that I haven't gotten a shipping notice for my 2nd sub yet, because I'm hoping to get something completely different!  Last month I got 2 identical boxes, down to the colors.  It was an awesome box (full-sized Stila, nail polish, Dr. Jart, Kerastase), but I didn't need it twice, especially two sparkly blue eyeliners and 2 bottles of sparkly gold nail polish - not like they're every day products (at least for me).

On a side note, I actually like not knowing what boxes there are out there.  I'm finding myself a lot more laid back and looking forward to my 2nd box than I was last month, where I poured over the GG options and dissected each one deciding which I'd want the most.  Not to say that I'll be able to keep myself away once they get posted
wink.gif
, I'm sure, but for right now I'm just looking forward to it and not worried that I'm going to get something I don't want.

 
Originally Posted by zorabell /img/forum/go_quote.gif

As much as I like that fragrance I got it twice last month, I am still surprised that they are sending out some of the same samples as last month
There are usually a few samples that roll over. They probably got a lot from the supplier and had enough to put them in a second set of boxes that would go to different people. The eyeko fatstick is a repeat from last month too. I kind of like that they do this, that way if you missed out on something you wanted to try you still have a chance of getting it the next month 
smile.gif


 
I didn't receive a shipment notification, and my online account has not updated from May. Nontheless, my box arrived today. Label says it weighs 0.7 and card calls this box 'Jet Set'. 
Clark's Botanicals Ultra Rich Lip Tint in Because I Love You (full size/$19)
 

KELLY VAN GOGH® WONDERLUST® Hair Colour Protecting & Illuminating Tonic 1 oz (full size is $30, but I don't know the ounces)

 

LA FRESH® Eco Beauty Acetone-Free Nail Polish Remover (2 pads; a box of 18 is $9.99)


theBalm® cosmetics Stainiac in Beauty Queen (sample is 0.04 oz; full size is 0.3 for $17)

 

Lifestyle extra:tili Bags Small Collection 1 in Orange Lime (1 qt bag; 12 retail for $8.49)
Sweet! I hope I get the Clark's Botanicals lip tint. Still no shipping notice (or surprise box waiting for me lol). I like that we're starting to see more of the 40 products being sampled this month!
 

Latest posts

Back
Top