Birchbox October 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Hmmm... I like the contents of my Non-goop way better than my Goop box! Not bad in either but a bit surprised the "special" box isn't more special than the normal box. Plus, if the samples' sizes were bigger in the Goop box, I think I be more into it. 

 



 
 


 
I will be getting box number 26!

I did not opt in for Goop, I have a Goop header, and I am pretty sure it's a Goop box? LOL I didn't even want Goop...but I am happy with the products especially the Mary Lou as I have been trying to win it from their Twitter page for weeks!

I specifically said NO to Goop and they sent me one anyway! I just think it's funny...

Also, I don't think the boxes are all the way updated because my October box pic looks like this...



 
This is the same box I have.  I am SO not impressed...

Originally Posted by MrsYaYaMom /img/forum/go_quote.gif

So I caved, I checked my box online and there is only 4 items listed. Hopefully they are still adding stuff. I am not sure what box I am getting, my items don't match up with anything on Zadi's list. My tracking hasn't updated yet. These are my items so far.


Harvey Prince Eau Flirt

theBalm Mary-Lou Manizer

Mox Botanicals Lip Butter

Supergoop City Sunscreen Serum 

I'm really jealous of the Eve Lom stuff. 
 
Originally Posted by fanchette /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I always have to figure out the value of my box, because I'm obsessive and cheap that way (If its ever under 10, I'm out is basically what It boils down to. I knew my box would be over from the DDF but I figured it out anyway....The "per-fekt" flower/lipgloss sample thingie is worth

duh duh duh duh

drum roll

eye roll

12 cents. 

So not impressed.
Please email them with that info! I'd love to see them try to explain how that is a deluxe sample!

 
Originally Posted by bwgraham /img/forum/go_quote.gif

ok i am so confused!~

i opted in for goop.  and received this email

:Hi there,

Your October Birchbox has shipped. This month, we’re joining forces with goop, our go-to source for lifestyle inspiration, to bring you an exciting collection of goodies. While you’re waiting for your goop-curated samples, watch our sneak peek video to learn more about some of this month’s products

but my box page shows this:

October 2012 Hi there,

Since we were kids, October has meant one thing: costumes. (And candy, of course.) From princesses to Wonder Woman, we had quite the parade of getups. In honor of those days, we’re dedicating this month’s Birchbox to beauty changes both big and small. Transformation doesn’t have to mean dying your hair blue or tossing out your entire closet. Switch up your hairstyle, try a bolder lipstick

shade, or go completely sans makeup one day. You’ll be surprised at how minor tweaks can make a big difference.
so does it look like i am getting a transformation box instead of goop??  the email says one thing, box page another.  

ugh.
Mine says the SAME thing. But the essie is listed. Which is nice! Right now it's the only thing listed.. 

 
Originally Posted by Missglammygirl /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Box twins! Someone said that people with box #1 will get a beautyblender. Is that true?
I have no idea, lol. But if it is box 1 then I'm happy with a lip gloss and nail polish. A little confused as I got a goop email but a transformation header on my box page, but whatever, I just wnat to see some movement on my shipping now, and maybe an update of what all I'm getting.

 
Originally Posted by MissLindaJean /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Can't believe I'm doing this...but my first box..dissapointing. This is the first BB I'm receiving that I don't have an interest in any of the items..


Products in Your October Box





but the second account? AMAZEBALLS and makes up for the lacklusterness of acct 1's box..2nd box has ...

Products in Your October Box

your 2nd box is awesome....box envy here!!
 
Originally Posted by Missglammygirl /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Box twins! Someone said that people with box #1 will get a beautyblender. Is that true?
I'm a box #1er too!!! Woohoo, nail polish (um, apparently that's all we're getting! lol)

 
Looks like Im getting Box 36 w/only 4 items. :-( I was really hoping for the beauty blender. :-(

 
Originally Posted by MollyC2153 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Please email them with that info! I'd love to see them try to explain how that is a deluxe sample!

Mine says the SAME thing. But the essie is listed. Which is nice! Right now it's the only thing listed.. 
Box twins again!

 
Also, anyone else find the embryolisse name really creepy? It has embryo in the title. That skeeves me out!

 
Originally Posted by marybbryant /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I am super excited for my boxes this month! 

My Transform box is I think #5.  Its the one I wanted!  It has the Eve Lom cleanser and cloth, the Almika hair mask, the DDF serum and the Chanticaille mascara, and a yummy Luna bar! 

My Goop box has the Mary Lou Manizer, the Ouidad heat and humidy gel, Lucy B perfumes, and the Vitvia skin vitamins. 

I'm really excited for both!  I had really wanted the Transform box that I'm getting, and had wanted to try the skin vitamin things ever since I saw the Sneek Peek video.

These would have been my two dream boxes. Soooo jelly right now. Congrats!

 
Originally Posted by MollyC2153 /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I'm a box #1er too!!! Woohoo, nail polish (um, apparently that's all we're getting! lol)

Lol! a page back someone said we are getting a beauty blender with this... not to sure about that since i got one in july, but I need a new one since my puppy took mine!

 
I just signed up for MyGlam/Ipsy... I'm keeping Birchbox for now but I'm a bit discouraged from this month's box picks. 

 
Originally Posted by Canny Charlene /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Looks like I have box 1!  The page hasn't finished updating but thanks to previous posts I can fill in what else I'm missing like the tea and Luna bar lol.  I don't mind cause I'm getting my Beauty Blender!!!
inlove3.gif
Are you sure...?

 
...I really hope they aren't done with the uploading, because if so, I will be UPSET. I'm thinking they're not, though, since neither of my boxes have box pictures?

Let's see, first, I'm pretty sure the one I opted in for goop is getting a transform box, and the account I did nothing on is getting a goop box, though the shipping notice said transform. The box preview says goop. Great.

THEN, both boxes only have four items. On top of that, in the transform box, one of them is a Luna Bar. Really?

Wow. I've never been this angry at Birchbox. I'm usually one of their biggest supporters. But seriously? If I get three non-makeup items and a Luna bar, I WILL be complaining and potentially canceling my second account.
 

 

Latest posts

Back
Top