Birchbox November 2012

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
I'm getting Box 3 and am excited!  Maybe not as high of a value as some others (though I don't know how big the Miracle Skin sample is, and the full size is pricey), but I want to try every single item.

And if anyone has extra texture spray or mascara, I'm your girl!
 

 
So I haven't gotten my box yet, but I just cheated and looked and OH MY GOD

this is my fifth month with BB...I LOVED my first two, but then my second two were pretty terrible (I was a victim of the lipgloss flower)

  This month I will not only be receiving the mascara (my current one is running low so this is perfect, I need a new awesome brand to try). BUT I will also be receiving the stila . I was SO bummed about not receiving the mary lou manizer last month and this totally makes up for it. 
 
I'll also be getting the dry shampoo powder which I'm  interested to try, I usually love PSSSSSt dry shampoo though so itll have to be awesome to convert me. I'll also be getting the tiny Jouer rollerball which is a cute touch. 
 
Lastly the soy joy...I'd rather the chocolate but honestly I can't complain this box is sick! yayayayay for good boxes! well worth the money

 
I'm happy. In my account that hasn't shipped yet I'm getting box 21, and on my account that has shipped, box 5. I'm not excited about the hair powder, or the soy joy, but the rest I will use! I'm getting two mascaras, which is fine because I can give one to my daughter, and the luminizer and a cupcake. I'm also getting the volumizing spray, so yay. just for those who want to know, box 5 weighs in at .6860. I had originally hoped for a lipgloss but glad I didn't get one since I'll be getting two in my ipsy bags. Way to come back from last month, Birchbox. You have managed to keep my money...for now.
My box 5 was 0.75+ lb o_O I wonder why the discrepency
 
Originally Posted by DragonChick /img/forum/go_quote.gif


The Shea Terra is amazing stuff. I've bought from their site several times after getting the body creme in my Glossybox a few months back. They also have way more scents on their site than what is on BB's site. And they also have a 30% off coupon that varies from month to month, but they send those via email.
Thanks!  I'll have to check out their website.

 
Originally Posted by plutorayz /img/forum/go_quote.gif

I got my box a whole 3 days earlier than projected. Amazing- they've stepped it up apparently.

I got the Jouer fragrance cornucopia (notes of gardenia,jasmine, and honeysuckle- quite possibly my favorite scent of anything bb has given me), the lulu organics dry shampoo, the modelco lip gloss, the sumita eye liner (the cap was on and totally fine luckily) and the soyjoy (given to the mister). However, totally thrilled that I got TWO FULL SIZED MAKEUP items, totally surprised. Maybe they're responding to the competition they've got from ipsy/myglam? Pic's  a bit blurry, sorry.

   

bb's pic shows it as  https://d2yookngm6r3u8.cloudfront.net/Box/1480.jpg
I love the modelco lipgloss because it's not sticky at all and gives such a pretty sheen!  I just checked my birchbox account and it looks like I'm lucky enough to receive one as well (I was thinking about buying it last night, so I'm glad I waited to check my box contents)
 
Another meh.  That seals it.  I was looking for mostly skin care and this one...uhm...none.  I got Box 4.  Which is too bad because I want to like Birchbox, but...the things I get make my shake my head.  PLUS, my husband gets the BBM box and he got a Varvatos sample (not that I terribly mind because I like the smell of it and will use it on my own) but it's sort of a duplicate for us.  He'll keep his BBM box and I'll start looking for a new sub...have ipsy (but they're mostly makeup, which is alright) and Sample Society.  Any suggestions for ones that would have good skin care samples?  I don't mind a box full of etc. but this one ONLY seems to send me etc. items.  

I'm glad I got the Oscar Blandi spray though.   :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />  The rest of it....nah.





 
I'm getting box #8 - I'm excited about getting the ModelCo lip gloss and happy to try a Shea Terra product.  The Harvey Prince perfume and Oscar Blandi texture & volume spray will probably go to my trade list.  Overall I'm happy because I already have the MST Vanish and I don't need more mascara, face masks or bath products.

 
I'm new to BB. Can someone please tell me where I can go to see the list of boxes? I clicked "November's boxes" and it kept bringing me to a site with a list of the November's products and not the list of boxes

 
Wow my Nov tracking just vanished! No number...has this happened to anyone else?

 
Yay, after reviews, I will finally be at an even 400 points on one account!  After I do box reviews, I'll be placing an order to cash in my points (tea!  Adorable bobby pins!  Sparkly baby blue nail polish!), and then I'm shutting that baby down.

Also, free-shipping-with-$25-purchase is back!  It's good until December 31st, so they're clearly targeting holiday shoppers.  And the Pick Two deal is good for *any* $25 purchase, not just from a certain month's shop.

(And has anyone actually received the lip gloss yet?  I'm wondering what the scent is like.  I am tempted to put it on my swap list as an ISO, especially since I'm getting the other thing -- which I will absolutely not use -- from this company, and it seems like a lot of people would be willing to swap one for the other, but scent in this sort of product is really important to me.  I've had to toss similar things I've otherwise liked because the scent made me queasy!)

 
Originally Posted by lady41 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Wow my Nov tracking just vanished! No number...has this happened to anyone else?
it happened to me. I had a tracking # that had no update and then it was gone and the October tracking was in it's place and I just checked (again) and now there's no tracking #.  UGH!

 
Originally Posted by Joiseygirl /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Hi all! I've been lurking the past 4 months, which is how long I've been a BB subscriber. Never posted bc I have received the crappiest box offered each month and didn't want to complain. It was getting a little depressing getting little sample packets, tan towels (really?), and band aids each month when I was seeing full sized products, but I figured I'd give it time.

So this month I get the Sumita liner, and low and behold there's no cap and the pencil is all dried up and has what looks like a white powder growing on the dried up liner tip. I've seen this before on liners that Ive forgotten about for years and when I found them this funky white stuff had grown on the liner tip. There's no way I'm going to use this on my eyes!

I emailed BB and am awaiting a reply.

I guess the saddest part is that I'm in Jersey (username gives it away!) and have damage to my home and went 10 days without power after the hurricane and nor'easter so seeing this in my mailbox today really got me out of the funk I've been in trying to get my house in order. I open it and see two full sized items (liner and lip gloss - not my color tho so I won't use) and the liner is unusable, like many destroyed things in my home!

On the upside, I LOVE THE rollerball perfume oil and will be looking to swap whatever I can for as many of these as I can
biggrin.gif


Thanks for listening to my little rant and I'll be more vocal here from now on
redface.gif
I'm from Jersey too. Where in Jersey are you from? have you heard back from BB regarding the eyeliner?

 
Originally Posted by Jennifer Love /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Another meh.  That seals it.  I was looking for mostly skin care and this one...uhm...none.  I got Box 4.  Which is too bad because I want to like Birchbox, but...the things I get make my shake my head.  PLUS, my husband gets the BBM box and he got a Varvatos sample (not that I terribly mind because I like the smell of it and will use it on my own) but it's sort of a duplicate for us.  He'll keep his BBM box and I'll start looking for a new sub...have ipsy (but they're mostly makeup, which is alright) and Sample Society.  Any suggestions for ones that would have good skin care samples?  I don't mind a box full of etc. but this one ONLY seems to send me etc. items.  
Actually, I would just change your profile.  I have one with the following info (not my real info.  This one was set up as an experiment to see what it would get) that gets a whole lot of skincare (this month, it's box 13:  three skincare products, a fragrance, a hair product, and a highlighter):

  • Intel -- beauty blogs
  • Knowledge -- semi-proficient
  • Splurge -- face cream
  • Signing up because -- experiment, receive relevant how-to's and tips
  • Styles -- classic, low-maintenance
  • Hair -- fine, normal
  • Hair color -- brown
  • Ethnicity -- Caucasian
  • Skin coloring -- light
  • Skin type -- dry
  • Skin concerns -- aging, sensitive, sun-protection
  • Age -- 50
  • Income -- $36k-$61k
  • Heard about -- Zoya
  • Other interests -- natural and organic
 
Originally Posted by BagLady /img/forum/go_quote.gif

it happened to me. I had a tracking # that had no update and then it was gone and the October tracking was in it's place and I just checked (again) and now there's no tracking #.  UGH!
The same exact thing happened to me! My sneak peek isn't even showing up yet on my profile. Guess I'll just be surprised when my box gets here!

 
Originally Posted by libbs07 /img/forum/go_quote.gif


The same exact thing happened to me! My sneak peek isn't even showing up yet on my profile. Guess I'll just be surprised when my box gets here!
Yea my account isn't show the sneak peek/box contents either. I'm desperate to know lol although before i found makeuptalk I didn't realize you could see what you were getting before you received it. :)

 
Originally Posted by Kyuu /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I think BB started sorting the gift boxes into a different section? My gift box from last month finally has its own URL and I got this:

https://www.birchbox.com/shop/birchbox-1/gifts/gift-23

And from what I've seen, this one is the one they're sending out currently as the welcome box: https://www.birchbox.com/shop/birchbox-1/gifts/gift-25
that is a fantastic welcome box!  I'd be all over that!

Also... it's so nice to have such a more positive tone this month!!  Way to go Birchbox - lots of happy customers here.

 
Originally Posted by FoxxyNiki /img/forum/go_quote.gif

Just received by box today!!! Here's what I got:

Archipleago Pomegranate Body Soap - smells really nice but I don't usually use bar soap in the shower.

Marula Omega Rich Pure Marula Oil - small sample but will definitely try to use it. Glad to have a face oil instead of a hair oil for a change (although I love those also!)
ModelCo Fibre Lashxtend Mascara - FULL SIZE! Pretty sure this is full size, first time I've ever received something full sized in my BB, so even if I end up hating it, I am excited!
Oscar Blandi Pronto Texture & Volume Spray - excited to try to use this, although I am thinking that it will take some practice to figure out how to really get it to work.
John Varvatos Arisan cologne for men - obviously, least excited about this, but I'm sure I will find some nice boy to give it to :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
 
All in all, pretty happy with this box. I think this is my favorite box to date.

Box twins! I am super psyched, for this box.

I really wanted the mascara (Full Size!) and hair texture spray most of all, so the Marula oil was the icing on the cake. I already use argan oil, and am running low, so I am really looking forward to trying it.

The soap I am probably allergic to, and the men's cologne is a terrible thing for them to put into our boxes. I was going to complain about the latter, but I think since they gave me a full size mascara, I will let it slide.
 
wowwwww this is the best one i'm getting to date. my tracking number hasn't updated yet so hopefully they don't switch the box up on me before i get it!

 
 

Latest posts

Back
Top