Birchbox March 2015 (Spoilers)

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Ugh all three of my boxes are a bust this month, I'm getting 2 of the JPP highlighter and 2 of the Mirinesse glossy kiss, I'll keep one of those but both highlighters will be up for swaps. Oh well, and more number 4 and HP, ugh to both. Oh well, you win some you lose some.

 
I'm pretty bummed that I'm getting a 5-item box when there are SO many 6 and 7 item boxes this month. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> The only item I'm excited for in my box this month other than my sample choice is the Cargo blush. I seriously can't believe i'm getting a Jouer lipgloss. I feel like I've been getting those irritatingly tiny Jouer lip gloss samples for YEARS now. :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> Stink that as long as it's a different shade it counts as a different product.

With the large variety of lipglosses being sampled this month, it would have been nice to get one I haven't tried multiple times. Ah well.

 
@@Rachel S I wouldn't worry too much - it isn't even the 8th yet!    I don't have anything but that same reddish background for march too and I didn't do what you did

it is perfectly normal not to have any updates this early in the month :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />  But I hear ya!  I want to know what I am getting too!
I'm not worried as much as just anxious to see what I'm getting :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> I don't have tracking yet, which is unusual for me, and I still can't do the cheat.. but I went through the boxes up to like 34 when it stopped working for me and narrowed it down to one (assuming I get my chosen sample). I just hate the suspense lol

 
I'm getting the Its a 10 PYS box that's been posted a few times, with the Liz Earle and JPP.  I'm not sure about the Roloxin, it might get traded, and I'm going to need to see the highlighter in person to decide if its a good color for me.  Sometimes the warm bronzy pink highlighters don't work well on my skin since I have some pink undertones.

 
On my non ace account I'm getting:

Amika blowout spray (pys)

Smashbox lipgloss in pink lady (eh)

Harvey Prince Sincerely (blech)

Macadamia hair mask (love!)

Jelly pong pong highlighter (I'm interested)

It's an ok box. 3/5 (maybe 4/5 if the lipgloss color works on me) isn't bad!

 
My no-PYS box loaded finally. 

Looks like I'm getting the Jouer lip gloss, No. 5 clarifying shampoo, Cargo blush, Amika blowout spray, and StriVectin scrub. 

I'm a bit bummed because I was really hoping to get the JPP luminizer and didn't pick a PYS because I don't heat-treat my hair at all. I have a HG blush but I'll use the Cargo - same case with the gloss. Here's to hoping it's not correct, but if so, I have had awesome boxes up until now. 

Capture.JPG

 
Big disappointment for me. I didn't get any of the 3 PYS options. I'll maybe use one thing in this box. 

It includes perfume, again. At this rate I'll hit the 6 or less before summer. 

Emryolisse Lait-Creme Concentre (garbage to me)

Beauty Protector Protect and Detangle (may use, but I general do not like this brand)

Mirenesse Glossy Kiss (oh, great, another lip product...I don't subscribe to Ipsy for a reason)

Harvey Prince Sincerely (f/u perfume sample)

Jelly Pong Pong Glow Getter Highlighter (I just can't even...more makeup?)

Looks like I'll be swapping basically everything. I'm really bummed out.

BB.jpg

 
Cheat worked for me! I'm getting one of my top choice boxes from the its a 10 options. #13 I'm so happy I didn't get shampoo/conditioner.

Embroyolisse cream: I've gotten picky about face creams lately, this looks promising though.

It's a 10: so excited. I love leave in cream and this has great reviews. It is too pricey for me to buy before trying.

Mirenesse lip rouge: interested but I hope it isn't really drying since it is matte. Anyone try it yet? I might look at reviews.

Fekkai hair mask: yes! I like fekkai so far and I would love to find a great hair mask since I've only found one I like so far. (Hask macadamia)

Jelly pong high lighter: I like highlighters and the application of this one looks interesting.

Excited to see the sizes.
If the cheat is right, this is the same box I am getting.

I am very excited to try everything, except maybe the highlighter. I hardly ever use highlighter and I have a bunch just sitting around untouched.  But I am still interested to try it.

This looks like it'll be a great box! :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" /> 

 
My box FINALLY loaded. The body creme sounds interesting.

*Apparently the rest my screen shot was lost  when I hit post*

I'll be receiving the Number 4 shampoo and conditioner, Mirenesse Glossy Kiss, Amika Bombshell blowout spray, Mereadesso All-in-one tinted moisturizer, and Elite Therapeutics Rosemary Eucalyptus body creme.

 

 ​
 ​
 ​
 ​
 ​
 ​


number4_reconstructingmasque_900x900.jpg



Number 4 Hair Care

Number 4™ Reconstructing Masque
$58.00INCLUDES FREE SHIPPING



 
Last edited by a moderator:
Big disappointment for me. I didn't get any of the 3 PYS options. I'll maybe use one thing in this box.

It includes perfume, again. At this rate I'll hit the 6 or less before summer.

Emryolisse Lait-Creme Concentre (garbage to me)

Beauty Protector Protect and Detangle (may use, but I general do not like this brand)

Mirenesse Glossy Kiss (oh, great, another lip product...I don't subscribe to Ipsy for a reason)

Harvey Prince Sincerely (f/u perfume sample)

Jelly Pong Pong Glow Getter Highlighter (I just can't even...more makeup?)

Looks like I'll be swapping basically everything. I'm really bummed out.
Box twin (nonACE) interested in some - already have homes for others :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
so many boxes i wanted lol but last month i had 7 items and an awesome box so i gotta take turns! so not so excited for mine but def a lot of hair products 

Screenshot (34).png

 
My no-PYS box loaded finally. 

Looks like I'm getting the Jouer lip gloss, No. 5 clarifying shampoo, Cargo blush, Amika blowout spray, and StriVectin scrub. 

I'm a bit bummed because I was really hoping to get the JPP luminizer and didn't pick a PYS because I don't heat-treat my hair at all. I have a HG blush but I'll use the Cargo - same case with the gloss. Here's to hoping it's not correct, but if so, I have had awesome boxes up until now. 
That's the same box I'm getting.

It's also irritating that I've already received the No.4 product but it's slightly different in the name. I get that it counts as a different sample but I've already received plenty of Jouer lipglosses and No.4 hair products...I want to try something new! 

I did pick the blowout spray, but they really should avoid giving the PYS choices in the boxes of those who didn't choose one, otherwise it kind of defeats the purpose of passing on the choices in the first place!

 
My cheat is finally working, but I'm disappointed that my PSY isn't there (hair oil).  I got a confirmation email verifying my selection.  Instead I seem to be getting the It's A 10 leave in.   :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
Last month the cheat showed me a completely different box than what I actually got once they loaded box contents on the 10th, so it could be you aren't seeing your box.

 
I'm getting the Its a 10 PYS box that's been posted a few times, with the Liz Earle and JPP.  I'm not sure about the Roloxin, it might get traded, and I'm going to need to see the highlighter in person to decide if its a good color for me.  Sometimes the warm bronzy pink highlighters don't work well on my skin since I have some pink undertones.
I want your Roloxin if you don't!  Dying to use that product!

 
That's the same box I'm getting.

It's also irritating that I've already received the No.4 product but it's slightly different in the name. I get that it counts as a different sample but I've already received plenty of Jouer lipglosses and No.4 hair products...I want to try something new! 

I did pick the blowout spray, but they really should avoid giving the PYS choices in the boxes of those who didn't choose one, otherwise it kind of defeats the purpose of passing on the choices in the first place!
Also, it takes them away from those who are disappointed because their cheat selection is gone when they try for it.  Doesn't seem to make sense!

 
so many boxes i wanted lol but last month i had 7 items and an awesome box so i gotta take turns! so not so excited for mine but def a lot of hair products 
I have the same selection except a lip gloss instead of the blush.  It's not too exciting but I'd use most of it. 

 
Looks like I'm getting 

Its A 10

Mirenesse Lip Rouge

Paula's Choice Moisture Renewal

Michael Todd Moisturizer

Jelly Pong Pong Highlighter

Not excited about getting 2 moisturizers but I'll take it.  

 
Interesting box for me this month! Not a fan of the Bee Kind brand. I love masks and body butter/lotion though and I did like the smell of the Whish shaving cream! Plus I wanted the Highlighter!

BB.PNG

 

Latest posts

Back
Top