Birchbox June 2014 - Spoilers!

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
oh noes... more #4 stuff.  I seem to get that in every box when they are putting them in boxes

And the prices on the addons seem a bit redonkuous to me, especially for the pinch bag set.  Now if it was $10 or if the scarf was $15-20 I may bite.
noooooo!!!!! no more number 4 (or color club). they're good products but damn, every month birchbox?  

 
This is O/T, but I know a lot of us were introduced to Whish products via BB! My Costco has a pack of two large Whish shaving creams + the after shave gel for $20! And a 30 pack of the Whish deodorant/inhibitor wipes for $15 :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />
I saw Whish body wash and lotion at my Costco. $20 for a big and small one of either item. I want the wipes! Which Costco? I may have to take a trip up to the Morena Blvd and get a giant gelato and search for the wipes soon.

We also have Royal Apothic Lip Scrub and Balm I think 3 of each $30. Sisley Face cream $150ish. Crabtree and Evelyn Handcream. Pink Sugar Perfume $20.

 
oh noes... more #4 stuff.  I seem to get that in every box when they are putting them in boxes

And the prices on the addons seem a bit redonkuous to me, especially for the pinch bag set.  Now if it was $10 or if the scarf was $15-20 I may bite.

noooooo!!!!! no more number 4 (or color club). they're good products but damn, every month birchbox?  
For real.  I have now got the Number 4 prep and protect x2 on the same account, the number 4 volumizing shampoo and conditioner and the number 4 clarifying shampoo and conditioner.  I guess I should resign myself to the fact that I will get thr hydrating this month.  Glad I cancelled my second sub.

 
I just don't want any more Color Club. So over it. Or silver CR eyeliner. If it's the purple or teal, that's okay by me though.

 
Am I the only one who likes getting Color Club? I will take a nail polish over a tea any day!
Ditto! I never really have any issues with Color Club, as long as I use a base & top coat. 

And I hate hate hate tea. I cringe every time they add a new brand/kind to the shop, because I know I'll be getting it in a box!

 
Am I the only one who likes getting Color Club? I will take a nail polish over a tea any day!

Ditto! I never really have any issues with Color Club, as long as I use a base & top coat. 

And I hate hate hate tea. I cringe every time they add a new brand/kind to the shop, because I know I'll be getting it in a box!
I'm right there with you ladies! The only time I did not like getting Color Club was when they sent me a polish from the Wanderlust collection 2 months in a row. Had they spread it out over a few months I probably wouldn't have minded as much. lol

 
Ditto! I never really have any issues with Color Club, as long as I use a base & top coat.

And I hate hate hate tea. I cringe every time they add a new brand/kind to the shop, because I know I'll be getting it in a box!
Ditto! Color club is one of my faves. The only tea I will drink is chai lattes and I don't think they'll be sending those lol.
 
I will be happy with just about anything but the no. 4 crap. I've gotten it the last two months and I don't like it.

 
If I get a CC, I will happily swap it for tea. Just thought I'd throw that out there, ladies.
Same here. I don't know what I have to do to get some tea in my box. I always get it in a trade and I check off I want wellness items and lifestyle extras in my box. I think I have at least ten cc polishes though :( /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

 
They usually just send CC from a particular collection to you once. I want to stress the word "usually." They sent Wanderlust collection polishes to some people who had marked nail polish as a just-can't-get-enough (great, now I want to break out the Depeche Mode) in two consecutive months. Different colors, but I had already swapped for the one they sent me the second month, so that was doubly frustrating. But if you received something from Harlem Nights, that absolutely does not have anything to do with whether you'll get something from Gala's Gems.

 
They usually just send CC from a particular collection to you once. I want to stress the word "usually." They sent Wanderlust collection polishes to some people who had marked nail polish as a just-can't-get-enough (great, now I want to break out the Depeche Mode) in two consecutive months. Different colors, but I had already swapped for the one they sent me the second month, so that was doubly frustrating. But if you received something from Harlem Nights, that absolutely does not have anything to do with whether you'll get something from Gala's Gems.
Gahh == I cannot get that song out of my head now.

I had a similar issue with the Baldwin Blue polish last winter.  I traded for it because I wanted to try it (in the hopes of having better luck with it than I did with the Wanderlusts) ... and then got it in my own box the next month.  I want to like CC because I usually like the colors; I just have issues with the formula being streaky.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
They usually just send CC from a particular collection to you once. I want to stress the word "usually." They sent Wanderlust collection polishes to some people who had marked nail polish as a just-can't-get-enough (great, now I want to break out the Depeche Mode) in two consecutive months. Different colors, but I had already swapped for the one they sent me the second month, so that was doubly frustrating. But if you received something from Harlem Nights, that absolutely does not have anything to do with whether you'll get something from Gala's Gems.
Oh okay, that makes sense. I got the Aquamarine in my April box so I'm just hoping I don't get another. Thanks for the response! =]

 
Plus, they LOVE sending CC in pick 2's.  At one point I had 4 London Calling polishes.  And every single CC I traded for another color, I later got in a pick 2.

 
Oh okay, that makes sense. I got the Aquamarine in my April box so I'm just hoping I don't get another. Thanks for the response! =]
Check your profile! They might pull a "you say you love polish, so we sent you another one from the same collection!" But if that happens, they'll send a different shade from the collection, so if you received the blue last time, they would send any of the other three and specifically not the blue.

 

Latest posts

Back
Top