Birchbox February 2015 (Spoilers)

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Got the eye make up remover on one sub ( I actually wanted this and all samples were available when I picked) and the Rent the Runway box on my second sub. Yay! Do any of you know if all boxes will have the Rent The Runway $30 credit or just the specially curated boxes?? 
They said in the Spoilers video that all boxes will get it, but I wonder if there's a minimum to use it..

 
You're correct! Welcome boxes are just for gift subscriptions. You should receive a regular monthly box.  :) /emoticons/[email protected] 2x" width="20" height="20" />

I'm seriously debating reactivating one of my other accounts.. I just feel like it's a good month to have two boxes again!
I dunno, cos when I had my first subscription it WAS NOT a gift, and I got a welcome box. I had a lot of confusion when it came to PYS and stuff with my main account, and they explained to me that all new accounts get a welcome box, and then at the 10th they are billed again, and get the box for that month in accordance to their profile. 

So unless things changed? I couldn't care less, either way. I just made the second account so I could have a surprise this month, because I already know what will be in my mains box. 

 
I did not get a welcome box when I signed up, just a normal one.

And chancing it yet again, so far my boxes have been oddly good so im hoping it keeps up?

 
I got a welcome box but I was gifted a sub. It was the "customer favorites" version. Staniac, Lord & Berry glitter eyeliner, beauty protector spray, Catherine maladrino perfume and Not Soap Radio give me lemons body wash. That was in Dec.

 
That is hilarious that a "customer favorites" box would include the Lord & Berry liner. HAHAHAHAHA. I think the only other product I hear as many complaints about is the Gilchrist & Soames. 

 
When I first added a second box for myself back in November I didn't get a Welcome box. However, 2 of my girlfriends both signed up that same month(on a monthly sub) and they ended up with "Welcome" boxes. There was a ton of confusion with their box contents changing back and forth from November items to these welcome items. It made me think it really all depends on what time of the month it is and what they have in stock. I added my second sub around the 5th and they ordered at the end of the month.

 
When I first added a second box for myself back in November I didn't get a Welcome box. However, 2 of my girlfriends both signed up that same month(on a monthly sub) and they ended up with "Welcome" boxes. There was a ton of confusion with their box contents changing back and forth from November items to these welcome items. It made me think it really all depends on what time of the month it is and what they have in stock. I added my second sub around the 5th and they ordered at the end of the month.
I had my second sub change contents in Nov. I was able to review stuff I never got so I ended up with double points.

 
Mine was in Nov, too and it kept changing back and forth from a Nov to a Welcome. I subbed late in the month and got a welcome, so I think the timing plays a part, too. I was able to review 3 sets of items, I think, so lots of points, but lots of confusion.

 
i never got a welcome box but i did sign up on the 1st of the month in october, so maybe it just got billed and shoved in with all other subscriptions?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Proper bar soap??? I hope this is not a replacement for Not Soap Radio bc that was one of the reasons I chose the curated box!

 

Latest posts

Back
Top