Originally Posted by
gluegungeisha /img/forum/go_quote.gif
ugh, i got this box:
stila stay all day® liquid lipstick
Whish Hair Inhibiting Deodorant Swipes
Whish Exfoliating Body Wash
KMS® California FREESHAPE hot flex spray
OC8® Professional Mattifying Gel
i'm not very happy, mainly because i got 2 whish samples, when a few months ago i got the blueberry shave cream and gave it the
lowest possible marks i could. it was sooo gross smelling i didn't even use it. so i have no clue why they would send me
2 more samples of that brand. also, i am so pale that the BRIGHT RED lipstick looks so stupid on me, i'm more of a rose colored lipstick girl. the pore mattifying gel sample is about the size of a quarter and i'm pretty sure i put something in my profile about not wanting hair samples. i don't mean to be so negative, but this box blows!
on the other hand, i have been sooo impressed with ipsy lately, they really have stepped up their game and i am almost never upset over what i get.
i think i am going to quit birchbox, it's been 18 boxes and they just seem to send me smaller lesser quality samples
Past reviews don't have any bearing on future samples. But, FWIW, the Whish Body Wash smells amazing. Though this is coming from someone who liked the blueberry shaving cream. But the body wash definitely is not as sweet and weird scented as the blueberry. Also I think writing off an entire brand based on one product is pretty limiting.