Oooooh, I didn't realize that it was the same. I've never ordered from CS, I just get their stuff in my Ipsy bags. Not that CS is horrible, I actually think that the shadows are pretty well pigmented, but it's nothing that I want to see pop up in my Birchbox. I agree with everyone else though, I think that there's starting to be too much overlap in the boxes. I see that Birchbox has DermaE this month, which Ipsy had last month. Ipsy sampled Coola, which Birchbox had done. Now the Cailyn and the Coastal Scents... too much similarity!