I've tried Dove, Neutrogena, Hawaiian Tropic, Banana Boat and Loreal Sublime and all gave me good colore but still left me with that "self tanner smell". Fale Bake is great for a special occasion but not something I'd use every day. Of all of the above, I really like Loreal Sublime for color.
I'm using Bath & Body 24/7 gradual tanning lotion these days. I like the scent (I use use Calm- lotus blossom or the new Happiness). It's a shimmer lotion too and gives me a nice light color and great moisture. About once a week I use Dove in medium to help boost color.
I've tried quite a few facial self tanners but always end up back just using bronzer (Nars).