Where to pay extra for skincare?

Makeuptalk.com forums

Help Support Makeuptalk.com forums:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Jan 12, 2006
Messages
1,357
Reaction score
0
Do you believe it's better to pay more money for a cleanser or a moisturiser and why?

I believe that a cleanser is only on your skin for a few minutes so doesn't really have a major impact and that you should spend a little extra on a good moisturiser because this is what contains all the vitamins etc and gets absorbed in to the skin.

What are your views?

 
I use Olay Complete but I also love Clarins moisturisers.

I got told by a friend that you need to use products together from the same brand as they work in conjunction with each other.

I don't think that's necessarily true though

 
I think both are important to your regimen. However, I don't think you need to spend alot if you find something that works for you.

 
Originally Posted by Nessicle I got told by a friend that you need to use products together from the same brand as they work in conjunction with each other. I find some truth to that, but I don't follow it. (Your friend didn't by chance work for Mary Kay, did she?).
At any rate, I don't use the price as a determining factor. I think there are even some generic skincare products that do just as good as department store brands.

 
ha ha Melissa! No she didnt! lol!

She's a beauty therapist and is always harrassing me about looking after my skin and says that they work in conjunction with each other. I too believe there's maybe some truth in it but not that it necessarily makes it more effective to use exactly the same brand of moisturiser if they have same or similar ingredients

 
i've never used high-end cleansers or moisturizers, so i can't really say, but i would like to think price doesn't matter because i can't afford better skincare now LOL

i just read in the beauty book...

Quote:
you don't have to use skincare products from the same range, but it can improve your skin. many ranges are designed to work together, with ingredients adjusted accordingly. this insures that you get enough good ingredients like moisturizers and vitamins and reduces the risk of doubling up on potentially irritating ones like AHA or retinols. if your skin feels fine when you mix and match, stick with it. hope that helps!
 
I use Proactive so the products do go in conjunction with each other but a different moisturizer and get great results. I think it depends totally on your skin. Some of my friends use the high end stuff because that is the only thing that worked for them while others could use a dove bar and cheap moisturizer and be fine. I say if you find what works for you and your budget stick with it. Of course there is the daunting task of finding what works but hey that’s why we're here right? I’ve never heard of a beauty therapist that sounds interesting.

 
i don't think higher priced skincare is necessarily better (in my experience anyway) but I do think it's more important to find the 'perfect moisturizer' than it is to find the 'perfect cleanser' for the same reasons you stated. A bad moisturizer IMO is much more likely to break you out, irritate skin, or leave your face an oily mess by the end of the day.

 
I agree with the ladies and say you have to find what works for you. I currently use the same products for skincare (Clinique) but haven't always. I had good success mixing and matching as well.

It all depends on the ingredients and your skin's reaction to them. My skin is so sensitive. I have to use very few products on it and watch the ingredients.

 
I think you get what you pay for to a certain extent. Heres some food for thought:

Most skin care lines are loaded with fillers, usually animal by products and petro chemical duraritves. These are not good for you but 98% on the market is made of them. It is a cheap way to fill the bottle.

If it is a botanically based product, they can claim to have aloe and certain ingredients in it if they put any part of the plant in it. The active part is the part you need to get the effect. It is the most expensive part of the plant. You need to be sure it is the active part.

Another thing is:

If you are paying $20 a month to two months for a product then you might have been able to get a better product for $40 that last 6-8 months.

Ok...I hope this helps...

Ann Phelps
smile.gif


PS...I learned from a doctor with no connection to skin care that when some chemicals are mixed you can get a chemical reaction of burning, break out, ect..just as in nature you can also get the same reaction from mixing the wrong botanicals (Think volcano.). I do not think mixing lines is really safe, but I have been guilty of it too
smile.gif


Ok, here is an article that better explains animal by products aka fillers...

Does anyone know what a rendering plant is? There is an excerpt from a book that explains it very well.

Animal By-Products

We hear this catch phrase all the time "animal by-products" but who really knows what they are and where they come from? It is a nasty little secret that the cosmetic companies DON'T want you to know. I recently found out myself when I read the book, Mad Cowboy, by Howard F. Lyman. In his book he writes:

"I am a forth generation dairy farmer and cattle rancher. I grew up on a dairy farm in Montana, and I ran a feedlot operation there for twenty years. I know first-hand how cattle are raised and how meat is produced in this country.

When a cow is slaughtered, about half of it by weight is not eaten by humans; this includes the intestines and their contents, the head, the hooves, the horns, as well as bones and blood. These are dumped into giant grinders at rendering plants, as well as the entire bodies of cows and other farm animals known to be diseased.

There is simply no such thing in America as an animal too ravaged by disease, too cancerous, or too putrid to be welcomed by the all-embracing arms of the renderer.

Another staple of the renderer’s diet, in addition to farm animals, is euthanized pets – the six or seven million dogs and cats that are killed in animal shelters every year. Added to the blend are the euthanized catch of animal control agencies, and road-kill. (Road kill is not collected daily, so in the summer, the better road kill crews generally smell it before they can see it…)When this gruesome mix is ground and steam-cooked, the lighter, fatty material floating to the top gets refined for use in such products as cosmetics, lubricants, soaps, candles, and waxes.â€

…and that my friends, is the cold, hard truth about where the “animal by-products†come from that the cosmetic industry tries to pawn off onto the American public.â€

You can learn much more from the mentioned book, or simply visit the internet and do a little research on rendering plants. This information is provided as an educational tool.

(I also seen it first hand..I worked at a chicken factory when I was a teen and my mom worked in a rendering plant. It was nasty. Also my daughter had a nasty growth when she was little. Doctor removed it said it was not cancerous but probably came from something in her skin care. I then starting being careful of what I put on her but had no idea what he meant until years later.)

Ann Phelps
smile.gif


 
nowerdays, quality products come in different price ranges (cheap-expensive)

i don't think more expensive= better quality all the time. i think it comes down to

what product yields the best results possible for ones skin.

however, if you are someone that suffers from chronic skin conditions, such as acne or

rocea(spelled wrong i know), spending money on a good dermatologist in the long run

would be better.

 
Now I agree that they come in differant price ranges and more expensive is not better but it does pay to do your research and label read. Now most lines in department stores are the same in some generic names because companies trade and sell formulas. (I know ours is one of the few who don't)

I also agree that if it works for you go for it and stick to it...but there are high quality works and bland works out there. You also can be getting good results from something that can be bad for you in the long run. There are certain ingredients I personally choose not to use, then again there are some in the products I use, others will not.

Also I have tons of clients with skin conditions that ditched what the derm... gave them so there are healthier cheaper alternatives there as well. The best thing to do is research, research, research.

I spent my whole life with my hands bleeding from eczema and I was so picky because we spent thousands from equipment to doctors to every miracle product and nothing worked. One lady shared some information with me, I did some research, and I spent less than $24 on a bottle of cleansing gel and foot cream and have not had it back since.

Knowledge is power...your bodies your temple...

Ann Phelps
smile.gif


 
I think that if you're going to spend alot on skincare then go for a moisturiser, I've never used an expensive cleanser because to me it just goes down the skin, but cream cleansers can be worth the price if that's what it takes to thoroughly remove make-up. In terms of moisturisers I use a drugstore brand because it's more affordable for me but a high end moisturiser does feel so luxurious and 'worth it'.

I think sometimes it's neccesary to use the same brand of products if it's a treatment like Proactiv but if it's just a regular cleanser, toner & moisturiser then I believe it's ok to mix and match.

 
I read not too long ago on Paula's Choice that it's definitely NOT bad to use different products from different lines as my MK rep had told me. I didn't think so, but my HG products as of yet are all MK. Thinking about giving Chanel a try though since that makeover in May... ANYWHO! Unless there's hardcore proof that one moisturizer/cleanser that's more than another is BETTER than another lower priced one, it doesn't bother me. More doesn't mean better all the time... IMHO!

 
I dont think they had to be outrageously expensive. However, I strongly believe in using a cleanser and a moisturizer in the same brand. I use clinique's cleanser, toner, and moisturizer. I have been using it for about a year and love it. I have gone to different, cheaper brands just for a change. But I ALWAYS come back to my clinique. I think it works better than the cheaper brands. Just my opinion though.
 
I think it would depend on the person. For the longest time I tried out all the different drugstore brands and none really worked for me. And then I tried Clinique 3 step and it worked out perfectly. So for me.. I'd rather pay more than have to constantly shop around for different products from different brands etc etc for a skincare routine.

 
I think it all depends on your skin & what works...I don't feel the need to use face products from the same range...by mixing brands, you can tailor it specfifically to your skins requirements & your monetary budget! I have found more expensive mosturisers are more effective for my skin, so I will pay extra for that...though, my dermatologist was always telling me that to look for cleansers that have the least ingrediants in them (rather than a long list of 20 items) as, they contain less harmful things to the skin.So I'm happy to pay less for say, a cetaphil cleanser.But everyone is different...

 
Well if I pay more for something I do have high expectations for. But thats not always the case. Right now Im thinking changing my skin routine. Rounding it off, Im paying $90 for skin care that doesnt really do anything for my acne-prone skin! Pretty dumn huh? Thats why I quit BB since their cleansers suck. Im pretty guilty of being prejudiced when it comes to prices for face products. But I found that a cleanser from Biore works better than BB cleanser with coconut,apricot extract and bla,bla,bla at a $14 difference. So Im no longer being a blockhead when it comes to this anymore
tongue.gif


 
I think it doesn't matter how much you pay for a product, but it might pay off in the long run to use the best quality moisturizer, sunscreen and eyecream you can afford, and make sure you put the sunscreen on your chest and neck, and hands, too.

smile.gif


I was a bit negligent of my neck, chest and hands, and now my face looks young but my chest and hands tend to look older and it's frustrating!

 

Latest posts

Back
Top