Personally, as far as special edition boxes go, (I've only gotten 3 - resort, summer and fall), I have been pleased with the contents. Would I have spent $100 on the 2-3 items I use in each box? No, but I feel that the surprise and fun of opening the box and actually finding things I really like, make it worth it. I never would have known or sought out to buy any of these things without the box. Now, everyone's tastes are diferent and maybe my thinking is warped, but I have seen spoilers and gotten so pissed, but when I actually have it all in my hands, I'm always pleasantly surprised. I rarely carry clutches, but I have repurposed both of the previous clutches from these boxes in other ways and have used them enough times that justify the $100 I've spent, along with the other items. And I may be the only one who loved the Fall box. To me, that was the best value of the special edition boxes I've gotten so far, because I can wear hats and loved the quality of it and I loved how light that scarf was. I love how in some lights it looks like a black scarf and others the blue really shines. So this spoiler isn't making me fall out of my chair in excitement, but I know it will be used and looks really well made.
As far as Popsugar as a company is concerned, I have been and continue to be pissed for buying a year upfront while every one else is getting $10 off coupons, sometimes with gifts, every month. And I wasn't part of the shipping fiasco that was this month. I do feel they handled it poorly, but for how they have handled my complaints in the past regarding the year subscription, I'm not surprised. But at the end of the day, I wish I knew how to quit you Popsugar!