i've used a few and none of them took everything off 100% - even the ones that have gotten raves from others! at one point, i was using clean & clear's makeup removing cleanser (it's okay to use on your eyes!) and it worked really well, but being the product junkie i am, i tried others and i just bought this again. i LOVE it. it gets everything off, doesn't sting, or dry my face. loooove it.