I'm really in love with the Jessica Simspon lotions, but I don't own any because they're too expensive considering I don't lube up that often.....my skin, that is. I only apply lotion in the shower (in shower body lotions by Caress and Oil of Olay).
I do like Bath and Body Works Warm Vanilla Sugar and Victoria's Secret Strawberries and Champange. It'll take me years to go through them, so I find small travel sizes work best for any future purchases I might make.